{"schema_version":1,"citation_url":"https://567politics.com/news/brazil-pf-rodrigues-broken-trust-master-delegates-senate-hearing-fachin-reports-november-2026","title":"Brazil's police chief blames 'broken trust' for sidelining the delegates who named justices in Master files","description":"Andrei Rodrigues denies interfering as rewritten reports on six Supreme Court justices head to Fachin and senators question the removals on Wednesday.","author":"567 Politics staff","publisher":"567politics","date_published":"2026-11-17T12:18:10.61197Z","date_modified":"2026-11-17T12:18:10.61197Z","body_markdown":"Brazil's Federal Police chief has put his reasons in writing. In a reply to the Justice Ministry made public on Monday, November 16, Director-General Andrei Rodrigues explained why two senior delegates lost their leadership posts. He cited \"a break in the fundamental relationship of mutual trust\" with their superiors. The two had written the first police reports on how Supreme Court justices appear in the Banco Master files. He denied any interference in the investigation.\n\nThe explanation arrives two days before a double deadline. On Wednesday, November 18, two Senate committees plan to question Justice Minister Wellington César Lima e Silva, and have invited Rodrigues, about the removals. The same day, the police plan to hand Chief Justice Edson Fachin the rewritten reports, which now cover six Supreme Court justices rather than three, [CNN Brasil reported](https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/politica/pf-deve-entregar-a-fachin-na-quarta-relatorios-sobre-ministros-no-master/).\n\nThe dispute is no longer about whether the moves happened. It is about why. Police leaders say the delegates broke a court-set format and the chain of command. The delegates' association and a senator who once served as a police delegate say the moves punish investigators for naming powerful judges. Quotations from Portuguese-language documents below are 567 Politics translations.\n\n## What Rodrigues told the ministry\n\nThe Justice Ministry asked for a formal explanation on November 11, after the removals set off a public dispute inside the force, [CartaCapital reported](https://www.cartacapital.com.br/politica/pf-atribui-afastamento-de-delegados-a-descumprimento-de-ordem-sobre-relatorios-do-caso-master/). TV Globo published the core of the reply on Monday night, [according to G1](https://g1.globo.com/politica/noticia/2026/11/16/pf-cita-quebra-de-confianca-para-afastamento-de-delegados-e-nega-interferencia-em-investigacao.ghtml).\n\nRodrigues wrote that the police \"chose not to proceed\" with appointing delegates Daniel Mostardeiro Cola and Wedson Cajé Lopes to newly created posts of trust. He cited \"administrative convenience and timeliness\" and the broken relationship of trust between \"direct and hierarchically related\" leadership roles. Both had worked in the unit that handles corruption, financial crime and money laundering.\n\nHe gave two reasons the reports were rejected. First, they cited only three justices, Alexandre de Moraes, Dias Toffoli and Kassio Nunes Marques, rather than \"all mentions found without exception.\" Second, they contained \"elements that went beyond the 'strictly descriptive character'\" the chief justice had set. [Poder360](https://www.poder360.com.br/poder-justica/delegados-foram-afastados-por-quebra-de-confianca-diz-andrei-rodrigues/) reported the same wording.\n\nHe closed with a denial. \"There was no avocation of or interference in any criminal investigation,\" he wrote, calling the step \"an administrative measure in the interest of strict compliance with a judicial order.\" Avocation means a superior taking a case away from the investigator in charge.\n\nEarlier reporting adds a procedural complaint. CartaCapital and [O Globo](https://oglobo.globo.com/politica/noticia/2026/11/11/fachin-avalia-que-relatorio-descritivo-da-pf-sobre-ministros-pode-contemplar-indicios-de-crimes.ghtml) reported that leadership had asked for the reports to be discussed at a meeting before completion. The delegates filed them in the force's electronic records system first. Rodrigues's letter, as published, does not mention that point.\n\n## The court order at the center of the fight\n\n![Federal Police headquarters in Brasília's Setor Comercial Norte. Photo: Marcos Oliveira/Agência Senado, CC BY 2.0](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/c9ed99ee-ef2a-4197-8904-568dd03a176f/aac4e49f001a67af376783acde694a72.jpg)\n\nBoth sides invoke the same instruction. On October 13, after a meeting between Fachin and Rodrigues, the court and the police issued a joint note. It said the police must send the court every mention of a justice found in the investigations, \"without exception\" and \"in strictly descriptive character,\" [according to Estadão's report of the note](https://noticias.uol.com.br/ultimas-noticias/agencia-estado/2026/10/13/stf-pf-deve-encaminhar-mencoes-no-caso-master-sem-excecao-em-carater-descritivo.htm). Investigating a sitting justice requires authorization from the full court. \"Once the necessary elements are presented, the plenary of the Supreme Federal Court, after hearing the Prosecutor-General's Office, may deliberate,\" the note said.\n\nThe phrase \"strictly descriptive\" carries the dispute. Police leaders read it as barring analysis and cross-referencing of data that would amount to investigating judges without permission. But Fachin's aides told O Globo on November 11 that a descriptive report can still point to signs of possible crimes. In their account, the line falls at reaching conclusions that belong to the courts, not at identifying evidence. That account came from unnamed aides, not a written ruling. It still undercuts a reading of the order as a ban on technical analysis.\n\nThe first versions also left people out. CartaCapital reported that the revised work will produce individual reports on six Supreme Court justices and at least two judges of the Superior Court of Justice. Valdo Cruz's G1 blog named André Mendonça, Luiz Fux and Gilmar Mendes as among those also mentioned.\n\nA mention is not an accusation. CNN Brasil noted that the appearance of a justice's name in seized messages does not, by itself, mean that person is suspected of wrongdoing. After the reports arrive, Fachin is expected to send them to Prosecutor-General Paulo Gonet, who can request more steps, seek an investigation or ask that the matter be dropped. The full court has the final word.\n\n```diagram\ntype: timeline\ntitle: How the Master reports on Supreme Court justices became a police crisis\nsource: [Federal Police](https://www.gov.br/pf/pt-br/assuntos/noticias/2026/11/nota-a-imprensa), [Estadão via UOL](https://noticias.uol.com.br/ultimas-noticias/agencia-estado/2026/10/13/stf-pf-deve-encaminhar-mencoes-no-caso-master-sem-excecao-em-carater-descritivo.htm), [ADPF](https://web.adpf.org.br/noticia/adpf/adpf-repudia-afastamento-de-delegados-em-investigacoes-do-caso-master/), [Agência Senado](https://www12.senado.leg.br/noticias/audios/2026/11/master-comissoes-convidam-ministro-da-justica-e-diretor-da-pf), [G1](https://g1.globo.com/politica/noticia/2026/11/16/pf-cita-quebra-de-confianca-para-afastamento-de-delegados-e-nega-interferencia-em-investigacao.ghtml), [CNN Brasil](https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/politica/pf-deve-entregar-a-fachin-na-quarta-relatorios-sobre-ministros-no-master/)\n---\n2026-10-02: Fachin formally requests a police report on mentions of justices\n2026-10-13: Court and police issue joint note on complete, descriptive reports\n2026-11-09: Police say staff moves are administrative and case teams are unchanged\n2026-11-10: Delegates' association condemns the removals\n2026-11-11: Senate committees invite the justice minister and police chief\n2026-11-16: Rodrigues sends written reasons to the Justice Ministry\n2026-11-18: Senate hearing; police plan to deliver revised reports to Fachin\n```\n\n## The case that the removals were improper\n\nThe National Association of Federal Police Delegates, known as ADPF, issued a [note of repudiation](https://web.adpf.org.br/noticia/adpf/adpf-repudia-afastamento-de-delegados-em-investigacoes-do-caso-master/) on November 10. It called the police explanations \"insufficient\" to clarify the removals and the order to redo the documents. It said investigations must respect the \"technical-legal autonomy\" of the delegates in charge, a guarantee it traces to Law 12,830 of 2013.\n\nThe association went further than the two cases. It backed a long-pending constitutional amendment, PEC 412/2009, to give the Federal Police autonomy. It also proposed that the director-general be chosen from a list of three names elected by delegates, with a fixed term that does not coincide with the president's. \"Investigative autonomy cannot depend on the position or influence of the people mentioned in an investigation,\" the note said. It offered to start that vote at once to pick a new director-general.\n\nSenator Alessandro Vieira, of the centrist MDB party in Sergipe and a former police delegate, called the order \"completely irregular\" in a [November 12 interview with CNN Brasil](https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/politica/master-afastamento-de-delegados-e-irregular-e-abusivo-diz-vieira-a-cnn/). \"The police delegate concludes his work and sends it to the courts,\" he said. \"He does not submit it to review by the boss on duty, who has no autonomy for that.\" He said he saw \"an attempt at a grand deal\" in Brasília and argued the aim was \"to prevent investigations from advancing.\" Those are his allegations. He has not presented documents showing such a deal, and no court or committee has found one.\n\n## The police chief's answer to his critics\n\n![Andrei Rodrigues (second from left) at an April 2025 hearing of the Senate Public Security Committee. Photo: Agência Senado, CC BY 2.0](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/c9ed99ee-ef2a-4197-8904-568dd03a176f/c347d776066209b4a1d620c6bd6fe49e.jpg)\n\nRodrigues used Monday's ceremony for Federal Police Day to answer the criticism in public. \"There is no crisis, internal split, much less loss of autonomy in the Federal Police,\" he said, [according to G1](https://g1.globo.com/politica/noticia/2026/11/16/pf-cita-quebra-de-confianca-para-afastamento-de-delegados-e-nega-interferencia-em-investigacao.ghtml). He said \"isolated voices\" should not see themselves as bigger than the institution of more than 16,000 staff.\n\nHe also offered his own account of motive. \"However much they attack the institution, me and my family directly, they will not intimidate me,\" he said, [as reported by Agência Brasil](https://agenciabrasil.ebc.com.br/geral/noticia/2026-11/diretor-diz-que-recuperacao-de-r-20-bilhoes-comprova-eficiencia-da-pf). \"We know what is behind it all: greed for strategic posts and the command of our institution.\" He did not name anyone or describe the threats. His claim about rivals' motives is no more established than Vieira's claim about a deal.\n\nRodrigues framed hierarchy and discipline as inseparable from technical autonomy. Agência Brasil reported that he cited R$20 billion recovered from criminal groups over four years, R$4.4 billion of it from June to September 2026, as evidence of the force's record. He also said the recently approved public security amendment would widen the police's role, a change covered in [our report on the security overhaul](/news/brazil-security-pec-18-juvenile-age-separate-vote-november-2026).\n\nThe force's earlier position is on the record. A [November 9 police statement](https://www.gov.br/pf/pt-br/assuntos/noticias/2026/11/nota-a-imprensa) said appointments and dismissals are internal management acts. It said leadership roles are separate from case work and that teams in the Master operation, known as Compliance Zero, remain unchanged.\n\n## What the justices named have said\n\nMoraes, Toffoli and Nunes Marques have each addressed the Master affair before. In a September 14 filing to Fachin, Moraes denied any wrongdoing and said he never favored the bank or its former owner, Daniel Vorcaro. He said there was \"no message at all\" from him showing legal advice, favoritism or advance knowledge of a police operation, [G1 reported](https://g1.globo.com/politica/noticia/2026/09/15/moraes-se-manifesta-pela-1a-vez-sobre-mensagens-de-vorcaro-e-nega-irregularidades.ghtml). He called the case against him politically motivated.\n\nThe next day, Nunes Marques told the full court he had never exchanged messages with Vorcaro or ruled on a Master case, and that his son \"never provided any service to the bank,\" [Valor reported](https://valor.globo.com/politica/noticia/2026/09/15/nunes-marques-se-declara-impedido-em-julgamento-sobre-moraes.ghtml). Toffoli stepped aside from that session for personal reasons and noted that an earlier challenge to his role in the case had been archived. That September session, on whether to open an investigation of Moraes, ended without a decision after Justice Flávio Dino asked for more time, [R7 reported](https://noticias.r7.com/brasilia/julgamento-no-stf-sobre-moraes-e-adiado-apos-pedido-de-vista-de-flavio-dino-15092026/). None of the three has been charged. The new reports were not public as of Tuesday morning.\n\nEarlier steps in this story, including Glenn Greenwald's accusation of a cover-up and the Senate's first request for answers, are covered in [our November 12 report](/news/brazil-greenwald-master-pf-reports-moraes-november-2026). The court's own crisis also shaped [Fachin's decision to close the long-running fake news inquiry](/news/brazil-stf-fachin-archives-fake-news-inquiry-4781-moraes-november-2026).\n\n## What Wednesday can and cannot settle\n\n```diagram\ntype: flow\ntitle: What happens to the reports on justices after they reach the court\nsource: [CNN Brasil](https://www.cnnbrasil.com.br/politica/pf-deve-entregar-a-fachin-na-quarta-relatorios-sobre-ministros-no-master/), [Estadão via UOL](https://noticias.uol.com.br/ultimas-noticias/agencia-estado/2026/10/13/stf-pf-deve-encaminhar-mencoes-no-caso-master-sem-excecao-em-carater-descritivo.htm)\n---\nDelivery: police hand descriptive reports on each justice mentioned to Chief Justice Fachin\nReferral: Fachin is expected to send them to Prosecutor-General Paulo Gonet\nProsecutor's view: Gonet can ask for more steps, seek an investigation or ask to drop the matter\nDecision: the full Supreme Court decides whether any justice is investigated\n```\n\nThe Senate session is an invitation, not a summons. Rodrigues is not legally required to attend. As of Monday night he had not confirmed. Columnist Matheus Leitão of Metrópoles reported that he would consult President [Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva](/politicians/luiz-inacio-lula-da-silva) first, [according to J1 News](https://j1newsbrasil.com.br/2026/11/16/caso-master-senado-andrei-rodrigues/).\n\nThe hearing and the delivery can test the competing accounts in limited ways. Senators can ask whether the instruction to discuss the reports before filing was written down, and when. They can ask whether the original reports will reach the court alongside the revised ones. Fachin can compare the versions he receives. Without those documents, the public has two competing accounts and no way to choose between them.\n\nSenate politics will shape what follows. Senate President [Davi Alcolumbre](/politicians/davi-alcolumbre) has opposed impeachment requests against Supreme Court justices. A Senate with more right-wing members takes office in February 2027, and some incoming senators have threatened impeachment over the Master messages, [Veja reported](https://veja.abril.com.br/politica/ministros-do-stf-esperam-para-esta-semana-anuncio-de-sucessor-de-barroso/). Whether the reports lead to an investigation of any justice depends on Gonet and the full court, not on the police or the Senate.","link_base":"https://567politics.com/news/brazil-pf-rodrigues-broken-trust-master-delegates-senate-hearing-fachin-reports-november-2026","citation_guidance":"Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights."}