# French Senate kills a pension freeze 329-0, then votes to restart the climb to 64 against the government

Both first-reading votes on the 2027 Social Security bill can still be undone in the Assembly or by a 49.3, as pensions move into the presidential race.

By 567 Politics staff · 567politics
Published: 2026-11-17T14:12:48.858506Z
Updated: 2026-11-17T14:12:48.858506Z
Canonical: https://567politics.com/news/france-senate-pension-freeze-deleted-329-0-2023-reform-restart-200-129-farandou-november-2026

Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights. Resolve relative links against https://567politics.com/news/france-senate-pension-freeze-deleted-329-0-2023-reform-restart-200-129-farandou-november-2026.

France's Senate spent the night of November 16 to 17 rewriting the pension chapter of the 2027 Social Security budget. It voted 329 to 0 to delete the government's plan to limit inflation increases for most pensions next year. Shortly after 12:30 a.m., the right-and-center majority then voted 200 to 129 to restart the 2023 reform that raises the retirement age to 64. The government opposed that second vote. Both changes are first-reading votes, and the National Assembly and the government still have a say.

![The chamber of the French Senate in the Palais du Luxembourg, Paris, on September 18, 2021. Photo: TimeTravelRome via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 (cropped)](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/b72a3fe6-83b0-48ac-a6a4-09302e5b7006/e13879f5f33e06c1e00637c2aef63db0.jpg)

The votes came on the last days of the Senate's reading of the Social Security financing bill, known as the PLFSS. The bill reached senators in the government's original form after the Assembly rejected it in October, as our earlier report on [the Senate's first-part vote](/news/france-senate-plfss-2027-pensions-residence-benefits-november-2026) explained. A solemn vote on the whole bill is set for Wednesday, November 18, at 4:30 p.m., according to the [Senate agenda](https://www.senat.fr/ordre-du-jour/ordre-du-jour.html).

## Senators reject the pension freeze, and the government does not fight it

Article 35 of the bill would have broken with the usual rule that pensions rise with inflation on January 1. Only pensions of up to €1,260 a month would have been raised automatically in 2027. [Public Sénat](https://www.publicsenat.fr/actualites/politique/retraites-le-senat-vote-lindexation-complete-des-pensions-sur-linflation-en-2027) put the saving for the Social Security accounts at €4 billion. [BFM Business](https://www.bfmtv.com/economie/economie-social/pas-de-desindexation-des-retraites-mais-une-suppression-totale-de-l-abattement-fiscal-de-10-voila-le-compromis-negocie-entre-le-senat-et-le-gouvernement_AD-202611170171.html), citing AFP, put it at €4.1 billion.

Six identical amendments to delete the article came from the social affairs committee and from Ecologist, Socialist, communist, RN-allied and unattached senators. The [official record of scrutin n°111](https://www.senat.fr/scrutin-public/2026/scr2026-111.html) shows 344 senators voting, 329 for deletion, none against and 15 abstentions. The 14 members of Les Indépendants, a group dominated by Édouard Philippe's Horizons party, abstained. So did one senator of the RDPI group, which includes President Emmanuel Macron's Renaissance party.

"In a context of sustained inflation, it was unbearable to let this happen and penalize two-thirds of retirees' pensions," said the committee's pensions rapporteur, Marie-Do Aeschlimann of [Les Républicains](/parties/france/lr), as quoted by Public Sénat. Socialist senator Monique Lubin said she could not understand how such a measure had been proposed at all.

Labor Minister Jean-Pierre Farandou did not oppose the deletion. He gave an opinion of "sagesse," leaving the choice to senators. "If the Senate, in its wisdom, wishes to use the two vehicles as it sees fit for French people, we are of course ready to follow the Senate's view," he said, according to Public Sénat. He added that it was not "illegitimate" to think about slowing indexation, since indexation alone had cost "50 billion euros" since 2020.

### Who pays instead

The Senate majority does not plan to give up the savings. When the 2027 state budget reaches the floor on November 20, it will propose abolishing the 10 percent income-tax allowance that retirees receive, Public Sénat reported. The government's own budget only lowers the cap on that allowance from €4,439 to €3,000. Christine Lavarde, the Senate's general budget rapporteur, called the swap "a socially fairer balance."

BFM Business reported that the government had planned to raise about €5.5 billion from retirees: €4.1 billion from the freeze and €1.4 billion from the allowance. It cited the Institut des politiques publiques, which estimates that abolishing the allowance entirely would raise €5.4 billion.

```chart
type: bar
title: The Senate would swap the pension freeze for a bigger tax hit on better-off retirees
note: Estimated annual yield, billion euros; government figures as reported by BFM Business/AFP; the full-abolition figure is an Institut des politiques publiques estimate
source: [BFM Business (AFP)](https://www.bfmtv.com/economie/economie-social/pas-de-desindexation-des-retraites-mais-une-suppression-totale-de-l-abattement-fiscal-de-10-voila-le-compromis-negocie-entre-le-senat-et-le-gouvernement_AD-202611170171.html)
highlight: Senate plan: abolish the 10% allowance
---
Measure | Billion euros
Senate plan: abolish the 10% allowance | 5.4
Government plan: partial pension freeze | 4.1
Government plan: lower the allowance cap | 1.4
```

Several parliamentary sources told AFP that the arrangement was worked out with the government in recent days. Communist senator Céline Brulin called it "a poisoned gift."

The same evening, senators also deleted article 34, which would have replaced the 10 percent pension bonus for parents of three or more children with a flat amount. The government offered a late rewrite that, it said, would have created 100,000 winners a year. The chamber kept the current rules instead, [Public Sénat reported](https://www.publicsenat.fr/actualites/politique/retraites-le-senat-refuse-la-reforme-des-majorations-de-pensions-pour-familles-nombreuses).

## A vote to undo last year's suspension

The second vote reopened the fight that dominated French politics in 2023. Three identical amendments, from the social affairs committee, from Emmanuel Capus of Horizons and from Martin Lévrier of Renaissance, added a new article after article 35. According to Public Sénat, the article restores a faster timetable for raising the legal age to 64 and the contribution period for a full pension to 172 quarters.

Parliament suspended that timetable in the 2026 Social Security law, adopted at the end of 2025. The suspension was part of a deal between [Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu](/politicians/sebastien-lecornu)'s government and the Socialists. BFM Business reported that the pause froze the legal age at 62 years and nine months, and the full-rate requirement at 170 quarters, until January 1, 2028.

The [official record of scrutin n°112](https://www.senat.fr/scrutin-public/2026/scr2026-112.html) shows 200 votes for and 129 against, with 13 abstentions. The split followed the Senate's left-right line, with the center divided.

```chart
type: bar
title: The vote to restart the 2023 pension reform split the Senate along left-right lines
note: Scrutin n°112, night of November 16-17, 2026, on amendments restoring the timetable to age 64; votes by political group (13 abstentions not shown: 11 RDPI, 2 Union Centriste)
source: [Sénat, scrutin public n°112](https://www.senat.fr/scrutin-public/2026/scr2026-112.html)
stacked: yes
---
Group | For | Against
Les Républicains | 122 | 0
Socialist (SER) | 0 | 62
Union Centriste | 59 | 2
Communist (CRCE-K) | 0 | 18
RDSE | 0 | 17
Union nationale pour les territoires (RN-UDR) | 0 | 15
Ecologists (GEST) | 0 | 15
Les Indépendants | 14 | 0
RDPI (incl. Renaissance) | 5 | 0
```

Les Républicains supplied 122 of the 200 votes. The Union Centriste added 59, Les Indépendants 14 and the RDPI group 5. All Socialist, communist and Ecologist senators voted against, as did 17 RDSE senators and the 15 senators of the Union nationale pour les territoires, the group that sits with Marine Le Pen's [National Rally](/parties/france/rn) and its UDR allies. Eleven RDPI senators and two centrists abstained.

### The majority's case

"We are restoring the 2023 pension reform, suspended last year," Aeschlimann told the chamber, according to the Senate's [official abridged record](https://www.senat.fr/cra/s20261116/s20261116.pdf). The record has her saying the suspension will cost "nearly 13 billion euros" over 2026 to 2032. Public Sénat quoted her as saying "no less than ten billion euros." The committee estimated that restarting the reform would improve the Social Security accounts by €600 million in 2027, Public Sénat reported.

Lévrier framed the vote as "intergenerational solidarity" when there are "fewer and fewer workers for more and more people who are not working." Olivier Henno, the centrist general rapporteur, rejected the idea that the Senate majority was bound by last year's bargain. "We are in no way concerned by this agreement, and so we are suspending the suspension," he said, according to Public Sénat.

### The government's objection

Farandou opposed the amendments. "I do not agree that we should suspend the suspension. A little consistency in our positions," he said, according to the official record. He then pointed to the 2027 presidential race: "Almost all the candidates for the presidency have their own" pension reform, he said, adding that the period seemed ripe for a new one.

### The left's objection

![The east side of the Senate chamber in the Palais du Luxembourg, Paris, in September 2015. Photo: Tangopaso via Wikimedia Commons, public domain (cropped)](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/b72a3fe6-83b0-48ac-a6a4-09302e5b7006/6c91a4a9100f067238acc2ed6cffe282.jpg)

Left-wing senators said the vote broke a political promise. "The word was given last year, with something that must hold until the next presidential election," Lubin said, as quoted by Public Sénat. She sits on the pensions advisory council, the COR. In the chamber she cited its 2026 annual report: a deficit of €5 billion in 2025 and a projected €6.8 billion in 2030. "The figures are always inflated," she said of the majority's estimate, according to the official record.

Patrick Kanner, the Socialist group leader, took part in last year's negotiations with the government. He called the move "a form of irresponsibility," Public Sénat reported. Communist senator Marianne Margaté called the 2023 reform "unjust" and defended retirement at 60, financed by applying contributions to dividends and ending employer exemptions, according to the official record.

Ecologist senator Guy Benarroche called the move "bizarre, even irresponsible" seven months before the presidential election, according to the official record. Citing COR projections, he said pension spending stays stable at 14.1 percent of GDP in 2025, 2030 and 2045, while resources fall from 13.9 percent to 12.9 percent of GDP by 2070. "It is a revenue problem, not an age problem," he said.

Benjamin Huin, a Renaissance senator, answered the left directly. "The best love letter to young people is to free them from social debt," he said, according to the record. If senators want to save Social Security, he argued, "we must work more."

The figures in this dispute measure different things. The COR numbers Lubin cited cover the whole pension system. BFM Business cited a separate forecast for the Social Security pensions branch: a deficit of €7.6 billion in 2026, after €7.2 billion in 2025. The majority's €10 billion to €13 billion is a multi-year cost estimate for the suspension, not an annual deficit.

## The Assembly, a possible 49.3 and the campaign will decide

Neither change is final. Public Sénat wrote that restarting the 2023 reform has little chance of surviving, given the makeup of the National Assembly and the government's opposition. The government has no majority in the Assembly. Public Sénat noted that if it adopts the budget using Article 49.3 of the Constitution, it could keep the freeze it proposed.

```diagram
type: timeline
title: How France's 2023 pension reform was paused and is now being fought over again
source: [Public Sénat](https://www.publicsenat.fr/actualites/politique/le-senat-vote-la-reactivation-de-la-reforme-des-retraites-de-2023-contre-lavis-du-gouvernement), [BFM Business](https://www.bfmtv.com/economie/economie-social/pas-de-desindexation-des-retraites-mais-une-suppression-totale-de-l-abattement-fiscal-de-10-voila-le-compromis-negocie-entre-le-senat-et-le-gouvernement_AD-202611170171.html), [Sénat agenda](https://www.senat.fr/ordre-du-jour/ordre-du-jour.html)
---
2023: Parliament adopts the reform raising the legal age to 64 and the full-rate requirement to 172 quarters
Late 2025: The 2026 Social Security law suspends the timetable, freezing the age at 62 years and 9 months until January 1, 2028
November 16, 2026: Senators delete the 2027 pension freeze 329-0 and the family-bonus overhaul
November 17, 2026: Shortly after 12:30 a.m., senators vote 200-129 to restart the 2023 timetable, against the government
November 18, 2026: Solemn Senate vote on the whole Social Security bill
November 20, 2026: Senate debate on the 2027 state budget begins, where the majority plans to abolish retirees' 10 percent tax allowance
January 1, 2028: Scheduled end of the suspension under current law
```

The pension question is also moving to the presidential campaign. On the morning after the votes, Le Pen presented the National Rally's plan for a legal age of 60 to 62. Center-right candidates such as [Édouard Philippe](/politicians/edouard-philippe) have proposed going past 64. Five candidates had already clashed over retirees' living standards in a [televised debate on November 16](/news/france-tf1-lci-restos-du-coeur-debate-le-pen-ldh-melenchon-retailleau-attal-glucksmann-november-2026). For the candidates and their camps, see the [2027 presidential race page](/elections/france/france-president-2027) and the [French party spectrum](/political-spectrum?country=france).

Unions marched across France on November 17, the same day, over wages and public services; our coverage of [the public-sector strike](/news/france-public-sector-strike-november-17-point-d-indice-freeze-unions-november-2026) has the background. Turnout figures had not been published when this story was written.
