# Delhi's worst Diwali air since 2021 sets off a fight over Punjab's fires and missing pollution data

The BJP alleges a plot behind Punjab's Diwali fire surge. AAP and Congress question Delhi's AQI data. Official records back parts of each claim.

By 567 Politics staff · 567politics
Published: 2026-11-09T20:18:41.562392Z
Updated: 2026-11-09T20:19:42.575111Z
Canonical: https://567politics.com/news/india-delhi-diwali-smog-bjp-aap-punjab-stubble-fires-missing-aqi-data-november-2026

Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights. Resolve relative links against https://567politics.com/news/india-delhi-diwali-smog-bjp-aap-punjab-stubble-fires-missing-aqi-data-november-2026.

Delhi woke up under thick smog on Monday, the day after Diwali, and its politicians spent the day arguing about who caused it and whether the official numbers can be trusted. The Bharatiya Janata Party, which governs the capital, blamed a sudden surge of farm fires in Punjab, which is run by the Aam Aadmi Party. AAP said the BJP government was hiding the true level of pollution. Congress asked why many monitoring stations went blank during the worst hours of the night.

The official record shows a bad festival night. The Central Pollution Control Board's daily bulletin put Delhi's average air quality index at 376 on Diwali, November 8. That is "Very Poor" and the highest Diwali-day reading since 2021. The next day's bulletin put the average at 344, but only 47 of the city's 59 stations contributed to it. Here is what each side says, what the public data show, and where the gaps are.

## What the BJP alleges about Punjab

Delhi Labour Minister Kapil Mishra, a BJP leader, held a press conference at his official residence on Monday. He said satellite data showed farm fires in Punjab jumped on Diwali evening. According to [The Indian Express](https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/delhi/delhi-pollution-diwali-aqi-punjab-stubble-burning-kapil-mishra-10956292/), he said Punjab had recorded between 100 and 125 fires a day from November 5 to 7. He said that number rose to about 1,200 on the evening of November 8.

"How did the number suddenly rise to 1,200 locations on Diwali? How did the figures increase by more than 10 times?" Mishra asked. He called it "a conspiracy against farmers, a conspiracy against Diwali, a conspiracy against Delhi and a conspiracy against Punjab."

Mishra did not blame Punjab's farmers. He said his office had received calls from farmers who said strangers were setting their fields alight while families were at home for the festival. He asked Punjab Chief Minister [Bhagwant Mann](/politicians/bhagwant-mann) to register police complaints, known as FIRs, in the affected areas. He also asked that phone records of AAP legislators and of party workers who had traveled from Delhi to Punjab be examined. He said that if an honest inquiry were held, former Delhi chief minister [Arvind Kejriwal](/politicians/arvind-kejriwal) "could end up in jail in this matter." He offered no evidence for that claim in the reported remarks.

BJP Member of Parliament Praveen Khandelwal made a similar charge. "This is a well-thought-out conspiracy," he said, [according to The Times of India](https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/delhi-pollution-sparks-row-bjp-alleges-conspiracy-aap-and-congress-question-aqi-data/articleshow/135674399.cms). He said the Punjab government let stubble burn "so that Delhi remains polluted on Diwali and they can blame us for it." He also blamed earlier Congress and AAP governments in Delhi for years of inaction.

No official body has found that the Diwali fires were set deliberately or by anyone linked to a party. The calls Mishra described have not been made public. The conspiracy charge remains an allegation.

## What the fire count shows

The jump in fires is real. Official Punjab data cited by the [Press Trust of India](https://theprint.in/india/punjab-minister-cheema-slams-bjp-over-stubble-burning-issue/3094342/) recorded 1,152 new farm fires on November 8. That was the state's sharpest one-day rise this season. It took the season's total from 3,307 on November 7 to 4,459.

The Indian Express compared those totals with last year. Up to November 7, Punjab was 2.3 percent below the same point in 2025, with 3,307 fires against 3,384. After Diwali, the state was 23.1 percent above last year, with 4,459 fires against 3,622.

A spike does not by itself show who lit the fires or why. Diwali falls at the end of the paddy harvest, when farmers race to clear fields before sowing wheat. A holiday can also change when fires are set and when satellites catch them. The numbers fit Mishra's account, but they also fit an ordinary late-harvest surge. The data alone cannot tell the two apart.

There is also a question of how much Punjab smoke reached Delhi on Diwali night. Sunil Dahiya, founder of the think tank Envirocatalysts, told [The Indian Express](https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/delhi/diwali-air-pollution-monitoring-stations-missing-readings-10956324/) that "firecrackers drove most of the spike." He said winds were calm and the layer of air that mixes pollution was only 55 to 80 meters deep. Sulfur dioxide, a gas typical of firecracker smoke, "nearly quadrupled," he said, and most of the rise came after the 10 p.m. deadline for bursting crackers.

## How Punjab's government answered

AAP leaders in Punjab rejected the charge. Punjab Finance Minister Harpal Singh Cheema said, "Kapil Mishra is lying." He said the BJP was taking revenge on Punjab's farmers for the long protest that forced the central government to repeal three farm laws in 2021. He asked why the 300-kilometer stretch of Haryana between Punjab and Delhi, and the Uttar Pradesh districts that surround the capital, were never blamed. Haryana is governed by the BJP. Cheema also said Punjab's fire counts are far lower than a few years ago.

Baltej Pannu, AAP's media in-charge in Punjab, said BJP leaders began blaming the state "even before paddy harvesting began." He said, "Punjab has almost brought stubble-burning incidents under control, yet the BJP continues to target the state."

Neither Cheema nor Pannu addressed, in the reported remarks, why fires rose so sharply on the festival night itself.

## The fight over Delhi's own numbers

The second front of the row is about data. AAP's Delhi president Saurabh Bharadwaj accused the BJP government of fraud. "The government which shuts down air quality monitoring stations on the night of Diwali, the government that does data fraud, how will you trust such a government?" he said in a video, [The Hindu reported](https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Delhi/delhi-air-pollution-aap-slams-delhi-govt-for-alleged-air-quality-data-manipulation/article71681459.ece).

Bharadwaj repeated earlier charges. He said the government had placed 20 new stations in remote green areas, which would pull the city average down. He also said water was being sprayed directly over stations in polluted spots. AAP wrote to the Commission for Air Quality Management and the pollution control board about these claims last week. No regulator has made a finding on them.

Congress leader Pawan Khera asked a narrower question. "There were no PM2.5 readings recorded at 25 of Delhi's 39 monitoring stations between 2 and 3 a.m. on the night of November 8 to 9. WHY?" he asked, according to The Times of India. He asked whether the readings were withheld, whether machines were switched off, or whether pollution had gone past what the machines can measure.

Mishra said on Monday that the government would look into the missing data within an hour and tell reporters. The Hindu reported his promise. An explanation from the Delhi government had not been located by the time of publication.

The data row is not new. After similar charges following Diwali in 2025, Chief Minister Rekha Gupta said, "The data cannot be tampered with or hidden," [Hindustan Times reported](https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/delhi-news/delhis-aqi-data-is-tamper-proof-govt-hits-out-at-oppn-101761935473653.html). Her environment minister, Manjinder Singh Sirsa, called the stations "tamper-proof and fully automatic." He said they are run by three agencies and publish on several platforms at once.

## What the missing readings mean

Independent analysts offered a different account of the gaps from either party's. Several of them point to the limits of the instruments rather than to deliberate tampering.

The Indian Express examined all 59 stations. It found that 45 had at least one missing hourly reading for at least one pollutant on Diwali night. Only 14 reported complete data. At Lodhi Road, 96 of 192 expected hourly data points were blank.

Officials told the paper that the outages came from a mix of software and hardware strain. On the central board's portal, hourly particle readings went blank when concentrations passed 1,000 micrograms per cubic meter. That is the top of the instruments' range. Yet the Delhi Pollution Control Committee's own dashboards logged values far above that at the same hours. They showed 4,697 micrograms at Punjabi Bagh and 4,985 at Jahangirpuri.

Manoj Kumar, lead pollution analyst at the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air, said those blanks should not be treated like ordinary missing data. Dropping them "could result in an underestimation of pollution levels," he said. He suggested using 1,000 micrograms as a floor for those hours instead. He also flagged "unusually low" fine-particle readings at four stations for checking.

Dahiya said the board's official city average of fine particles peaked at 592 micrograms at 1 a.m. That is almost 10 times India's 24-hour standard. Following only the stations that kept reporting, he estimated the true peak was near 800.

These accounts suggest the official average likely understated the worst hours. They do not establish that anyone switched stations off on purpose. They also do not answer AAP's separate claims about station siting and water spraying.

## How this Diwali compares

The central board publishes a daily bulletin at 4 p.m. It gives each city's average air quality index for the previous 24 hours. The chart below uses those bulletins for Diwali and the day after in each of the last six years.

```chart
type: column
title: Delhi's average air quality index on Diwali and the day after, 2021-2026
source: [Central Pollution Control Board daily AQI bulletins](https://cpcb.nic.in/upload/Downloads/AQI_Bulletin_20261109.pdf)
note: 24-hour averages from the 4 p.m. bulletins. Above 300 is "Very Poor"; above 400 is "Severe." The November 9, 2026 figure is based on 47 of 59 stations. Earlier bulletins are at cpcb.nic.in under AQI_Bulletin_ with the date.
---
Year | Diwali day | Day after
2021 | 382 | 462
2022 | 312 | 302
2023 | 218 | 358
2024 | 328 | 339
2025 | 345 | 351
2026 | 376 | 344
```

By this measure, Diwali day in 2026 was worse than every year since 2021. The day after looks better than 2023 and 2025. But that day-after average left out 12 stations, and the gaps fell during the hours of peak smoke. That is the point Khera and the analysts raised.

The figures also do not settle Mishra's claim that pollution around Diwali rose much less this year than in 2023 and 2024. He said it fell by 1.33 percent on his before-and-after comparison. He did not say which days or readings he used, and that figure could not be checked against the bulletins.

## The parties behind the row

The dispute pits the three main parties in the capital against one another. The [BJP](/parties/india/bjp) won Delhi's assembly in February 2025 after more than two decades out of power there. [AAP](/parties/india/aap) lost Delhi in that election but still governs Punjab, where Mann faces voters in early 2027. [Congress](/parties/india/congress) is in opposition in both places. The 567politics [India political spectrum](/political-spectrum?country=india) places the three parties on its economic and social axes.

https://567politics.com/embed/political-spectrum?country=india

Pollution has become a standing quarrel between Delhi and Punjab each winter. Whichever party runs Delhi tends to point to farm fires across the border. Whichever runs Punjab tends to point to traffic, industry, dust and firecrackers inside the capital.

The national stage is crowded too. Parliament has been [sitting for a record stretch without being prorogued](/news/india-parliament-unprorogued-88-days-delimitation-womens-reservation-november-2026). The BJP and Congress are also fighting over [the revision of the voter rolls](/news/india-amit-shah-rahul-gandhi-special-session-sir-debate-november-2026). Air quality may now join those issues on the agenda.

## Open questions

Several things would help settle the row. Punjab could publish the location and time of each November 8 fire, which would show whether they cluster in a way that suggests coordination. Delhi's government could explain, station by station, why readings went blank and how the daily average treats those hours. The air quality commission could respond to AAP's letter on station siting and water spraying.

Until then, each side has some data on its side and none has proof of its strongest claim. The fire spike is real, but the conspiracy is unproven. The missing readings are real, but deliberate tampering is unproven. What the official record does show is that Delhi's Diwali-day air was the worst since 2021, even before counting the hours the monitors could not see.