{"version":"1.9","identifier":"66af6313-1e01-4e21-9e3c-67fd4b56efba","language":"en-US","title":"Rahul Gandhi tells India's top court the election body has not proved its SIR decision was unanimous","layout":{"columns":7,"width":1024,"margin":32,"gutter":20},"componentLayouts":{"text":{"columnStart":0,"columnSpan":7,"maximumContentWidth":720,"margin":{"top":12,"bottom":12}},"photo":{"columnStart":0,"columnSpan":7,"margin":{"top":20,"bottom":20}}},"componentTextStyles":{"default":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":18,"lineHeight":29,"textColor":"#171717"},"headline":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue-Bold","fontSize":36,"lineHeight":42,"conditional":[{"conditions":{"maxViewportWidth":480},"fontSize":28,"lineHeight":34}]},"intro":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":20,"lineHeight":28,"textColor":"#555555"},"caption":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":13,"lineHeight":19,"textColor":"#666666"},"byline":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":13,"lineHeight":20,"textColor":"#666666"},"body":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":18,"lineHeight":29,"paragraphSpacingAfter":14,"linkStyle":{"textColor":"#00704a"}}},"metadata":{"contentGenerationType":"AI","canonicalURL":"https://567politics.com/news/india-rahul-gandhi-rejoinder-eci-sir-unanimous-supreme-court-hearing-november-2026","datePublished":"2026-11-16T16:23:54.345996Z","dateModified":"2026-11-16T16:23:54.345996Z","authors":["567 Politics staff"],"excerpt":"Gandhi's rejoinder says the ECI produced no minutes or files. The commission says all three members agreed. The court hears the case Nov. 17.","thumbnailURL":"https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/66af6313-1e01-4e21-9e3c-67fd4b56efba/4bb0472387604db35b7ded3df6a5dc55.jpg","keywords":["in"],"generatorName":"Frog News","generatorVersion":"1.0"},"components":[{"role":"title","text":"Rahul Gandhi tells India's top court the election body has not proved its SIR decision was unanimous","textStyle":"headline","layout":"text"},{"role":"intro","text":"Gandhi's rejoinder says the ECI produced no minutes or files. The commission says all three members agreed. The court hears the case Nov. 17.","textStyle":"intro","layout":"text"},{"role":"byline","text":"By 567 Politics staff · AI-generated · Published November 16, 2026","textStyle":"byline","layout":"text"},{"role":"photo","URL":"https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/66af6313-1e01-4e21-9e3c-67fd4b56efba/4bb0472387604db35b7ded3df6a5dc55.jpg","caption":"The Supreme Court of India in New Delhi, where a bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant is set to hear the SIR petitions on Nov. 17. · Pinakpani via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)","accessibilityCaption":"The Supreme Court of India in New Delhi, where a bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant is set to hear the SIR petitions on Nov. 17.","layout":"photo"},{"role":"caption","text":"The Supreme Court of India in New Delhi, where a bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant is set to hear the SIR petitions on Nov. 17. · Pinakpani via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)","textStyle":"caption","layout":"text"},{"role":"body","format":"markdown","text":"India's Leader of the Opposition, [Rahul Gandhi](https://567politics.com/politicians/rahul-gandhi), told the Supreme Court on Monday, Nov. 16, that the Election Commission of India (ECI) has not proved its central claim about the voter-roll review known as the special intensive revision, or SIR. The commission says the SIR was a \"unanimous\" decision of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi.\n\n\"No minutes of the meeting, file notings, recorded approvals, agenda, deliberations or other primary material evidencing the participation and approval of all three members have been produced,\" Gandhi said in a rejoinder, [The Hindu reported](https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/no-proof-from-eci-to-show-sir-was-a-unanimous-decision-rahul-gandhi-to-sc/article71707772.ece). He urged the court not to accept \"bare assertions.\"\n\nThe case is listed for Tuesday, Nov. 17, before a bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant. It tests how India's three-member election body makes its decisions. It also tests whether the court will order the commission to open its internal files.\n\nThe ECI denies any wrongdoing. In an Oct. 26 counter-affidavit, it said all three SIR orders were issued on unanimous decisions. It said notes and questions by single commissioners are part of debate and are not decisions of the commission. It also said the case against it rests on \"a single newspaper report,\" according to [LawBeat](https://lawbeat.in/top-stories/sir-a-unanimous-decision-no-amendments-made-to-form-6-eci-submits-before-supreme-court-1646076).\n\n## What Gandhi's rejoinder says\n\nGandhi, Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, filed the main petition along with [Mallikarjun Kharge](https://567politics.com/politicians/mallikarjun-kharge), his counterpart in the Rajya Sabha, and other INDIA bloc leaders. The writ petition, under Article 32 of the Constitution, alleges that Kumar used the \"collective powers\" of the commission on his own during the SIR. It asks the court to call for the commission's files, minutes and notings, according to LawBeat.\n\nThe rejoinder, Gandhi's reply to the ECI's affidavit, makes several points, according to The Hindu:\n\n* **No record of the decision.** The affidavit does not say when and where the decision to run a nationwide SIR was made. Gandhi is represented by senior advocate A.M. Singhvi and advocate Prasanna S.\n* **An RTI answer.** The affidavit's claims clash with a Right to Information reply. That reply said \"the Commission has so far not taken any decision on initiating a special intensive revision (SIR) across the country in 2025.\"\n* **Letters to the Cabinet Secretary.** Sandhu and Joshi wrote directly to the Cabinet Secretary about how the poll body was run during the SIR. \"That two members of the Commission found it necessary to address the Cabinet Secretary, and to issue a joint direction of their own, is itself inconsistent with the picture of unanimous functioning,\" the rejoinder says.\n* **Who filed the affidavit.** Gandhi asked why the ECI filed the affidavit when Kumar, Sandhu and Joshi were each named as respondents.\n* **Form 6.** The ECI says an extra SIR declaration is \"not a part of Form 6,\" the legal form for joining the roll. Gandhi says the declaration sat on the online Form 6 page, under a single one-time password and e-signature. \"An applicant accessing the online Form 6 process was required to encounter and complete the additional declaration as part of that process,\" the rejoinder says.\n\nGandhi and other bloc leaders have also filed \"interrogatories,\" written questions for the chief, the two commissioners and senior officials. The questions ask about each SIR file. They also ask on which occasions, between Feb. 19, 2025, and Oct. 26, 2026, the two commissioners objected in writing or voiced dissent on the SIR, the ECINET platform, Form 6 or the filing of appeals.\n\n## The West Bengal appeals\n\nOne of the sharpest disputes is over appeals in West Bengal. The ECI's affidavit says officers in the state's Chief Electoral Office filed more than 16 lakh (1.6 million) appeals against the inclusion of voters on the roll. It says they did so without consulting the commission, The Hindu reported.\n\nGandhi said this \"confirms the very grievance reportedly raised by the Election Commissioners.\" That grievance, he said, was \"that appeals were filed in the name of the Commission without the knowledge of its Members.\" If that is not the case, he said, the ECI should put the approvals for those appeals on the record.\n\nThe ECI's affidavit says those matters \"were not brought to the Commission.\" It argues that the officers had the power to file the appeals under the Supreme Court's own orders, according to [an Indian Express analysis](https://indianexpress.com/article/india/election-commission-affidavit-sir-supreme-court-10938068/).\n\nThe rejoinder also says the ECI was \"entirely silent\" on several issues, The Hindu reported. Gandhi listed the removal of about 20.66 lakh (2.07 million) names from Punjab's roll. He also cited the missing orders for the 2003 revision used as a benchmark, the bulk filing of Form 7 objections, some allegedly in forged names, and an analysis that women made up about 62% of electors excluded in West Bengal. These are the petitioners' figures and claims. The court has not ruled on them.\n\n## The commission's answer\n\nThe ECI filed a joint counter-affidavit on Oct. 26 on behalf of the commission, Kumar, Sandhu and Joshi, [the Hindustan Times reported](https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/all-3-sir-orders-unanimous-plea-against-cec-gyanesh-kumar-based-on-single-news-report-ec-tells-sc-101793027114031.html). It was filed through Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu. The Indian Express reported that the affidavit says it was approved for filing \"by a unanimous decision of the three members.\"\n\nThe commission said the three SIR orders, dated June 24, 2025, Oct. 27, 2025, and May 14, 2026, followed unanimous decisions. It said they complied with Article 324 of the Constitution and Section 18 of the 2023 law on the commission's members. \"All contentions to the contrary are erroneous, and the attempt to make aspersions against the Election Commission is unfortunate,\" the affidavit says.\n\nOn how the body works, the affidavit says files go first to one commissioner, then the other, then the chief. Approved decisions are noted in the files and carry all three signatures. Views raised along the way \"are considered for arriving at the decision,\" it says. The law prefers unanimity, it adds, but \"there may be occasions where the decision may have to be by majority.\"\n\nThe affidavit confirmed that Sandhu and Joshi wrote to Cabinet Secretary T.V. Somanathan. But it says the July 29 letters were about an officer on deputation and the internal allocation of work, not policy. The office order in question was \"never implemented\" after the two commissioners issued a joint direction on July 30, the Hindustan Times reported.\n\nOn Form 6, the ECI called the claim that it amended the form \"misleading.\" Only the central government can amend Form 6, it said. The added declaration was meant to link applicants to the 2002–2003 rolls, so they would not need to file more documents. The affidavit did admit that the way the declaration appeared online \"could be construed as though an amendment of Form 6 had been made,\" The Indian Express reported.\n\nThe ECI also defended ECINET, its roll platform. It said \"no entry is added or deleted or modified except by the order of\" the Electoral Registration Officer, the official the law makes responsible for the roll. And it challenged the evidence. \"In the eyes of law, a newspaper report is not treated as evidence of the facts it narrates,\" the affidavit says, according to LawBeat. It said the commission has not released or authorized the release of any internal file.\n\n## What the notes say, and what the affidavit leaves open\n\nThe dispute began with a Sept. 23 report in The Indian Express. It said Sandhu and Joshi formally recorded at least 14 objections over 10 months, from Oct. 28, 2025, to Aug. 14, 2026. They said key steps were taken in the commission's name without their knowledge. They described some of them as unauthorized and illegal.\n\nThe Express's own analysis says most of those notes came after the fact. The notes record that a decision had been made or an order issued and that the two had not been told. The affidavit \"does not, by itself, resolve the concerns the two Commissioners recorded about how the process worked in practice,\" the analysis says.\n\nIt gives Form 6 as an example. In May, Joshi recorded that the form could not be changed without amending the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, and Sandhu agreed. The online change went ahead in July anyway. The affidavit does not say who approved it. On Oct. 21, the commission's electoral-roll division decided to separate Form 6 from the SIR declaration online, the Express reported.\n\nFormer election officials have called for disclosure. Former Chief Election Commissioner S.Y. Quraishi said decisions are illegal if they are neither unanimous nor backed by a majority. \"The list of all decisions should now be made public as to how many were unanimous and how many were by majority,\" he told [The Hindu](https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/eci-should-give-details-of-decisions-taken-and-whether-they-had-majority-backing-former-election-commissioners/article71500603.ece). Former Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa said the only way to rebut the two commissioners would be \"to show a record that they were present in the commission meeting in which these decisions were taken.\"\n\nOne more fact bears on the dispute. Sandhu and Joshi are named on the counter-affidavit that calls the decisions unanimous, according to the Hindustan Times. Neither has spoken publicly about the case in the reports reviewed.\n\n## The politics around the case\n\nThe SIR has been a central fight between the government and the opposition this autumn. INDIA bloc parties have pressed to [remove Gyanesh Kumar](https://567politics.com/news/india-bloc-cec-impeachment-sir-electoral-rolls-october-2026), and opposition marches on Nov. 1 [demanded his removal](https://567politics.com/news/india-delhi-save-democracy-march-election-commission-voter-rolls-november-2026). Home Minister [Amit Shah](https://567politics.com/politicians/amit-shah) has [offered a special session](https://567politics.com/news/india-amit-shah-rahul-gandhi-special-session-sir-debate-november-2026) of Parliament on the SIR. Gandhi answered by challenging Prime Minister [Narendra Modi](https://567politics.com/politicians/narendra-modi) to debate him.\n\nThe commission has also changed some rules while the case runs. A Nov. 6 letter [gave some deleted voters another path](https://567politics.com/news/india-eci-asdd-voters-enumeration-forms-sir-facilitation-november-2026) back onto the rolls in seven SIR regions. Gandhi's rejoinder calls such changes \"woefully belated course-correction.\" \"The present proceedings cannot be disposed of on the basis of general denials or subsequent explanations,\" it says.\n\nOther petitions are before the court too. Activist Rakesh Kumar Singh filed one after the Express report, The Indian Express reported. AIMIM chief [Asaduddin Owaisi](https://567politics.com/politicians/asaduddin-owaisi) has challenged how the SIR is being carried out, LawBeat reported.\n\n## Timeline\n\n**The SIR decision-making dispute**\n\n* **2025-06-24**: First SIR order issued\n* **2025-10-27**: Second SIR order extends the revision to more states\n* **2025-10-28**: First of the two commissioners' 14 recorded objections, per The Indian Express\n* **2026-05-14**: Third SIR order issued\n* **2026-07-29**: Sandhu and Joshi write to the Cabinet Secretary\n* **2026-07-30**: The two commissioners issue a joint direction; the office order is never carried out\n* **2026-08-14**: Last recorded objection in the Express's count\n* **2026-09-23**: The Indian Express reports the objections\n* **2026-10-21**: The ECI decides to separate Form 6 from the SIR declaration online\n* **2026-10-26**: ECI counter-affidavit says all SIR orders were unanimous\n* **2026-11-16**: Gandhi's rejoinder says the ECI has offered no proof\n* **2026-11-17**: Hearing before Chief Justice Surya Kant's bench\n\nSource: [Hindustan Times](https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/all-3-sir-orders-unanimous-plea-against-cec-gyanesh-kumar-based-on-single-news-report-ec-tells-sc-101793027114031.html), [The Indian Express](https://indianexpress.com/article/india/election-commission-affidavit-sir-supreme-court-10938068/), [The Hindu](https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/no-proof-from-eci-to-show-sir-was-a-unanimous-decision-rahul-gandhi-to-sc/article71707772.ece)\n\n## What the filings do not show\n\nThe rejoinder and the affidavit are each side's legal arguments. Neither is a finding by the court. The Indian Express report and its analysis rest on file notes the paper says it reviewed. The ECI says it did not release them, and they are not public documents.\n\nThe case does not yet show whether any SIR order lacked majority support. That would take the commission's files, which the petitioners want the court to call for. It also does not show how many of the excluded voters were wrongly removed. The figures for Punjab and West Bengal are the petitioners' and have not been tested in court.\n\n## What to watch\n\n* **Tuesday's hearing.** The bench may decide whether the ECI must answer the interrogatories or produce its files and minutes.\n* **The two commissioners.** Sandhu and Joshi are respondents in their own names. Any separate filing by them would be new.\n* **The West Bengal appeals.** The court may ask who approved more than 16 lakh appeals filed in the commission's name.\n* **Parliament.** Shah's offer of a special session and the opposition's push against Kumar remain open.","textStyle":"body","layout":"text"}]}