# Rahul Gandhi wants India's election chiefs to answer 48 questions on oath. The court will decide Dec. 9

The ECI cites "very serious prejudice." The BJP says a Congress letter asking to use SIR rolls in the Andamans shows double standards.

By 567 Politics staff · 567politics
Published: 2026-11-17T16:12:49.985413Z
Updated: 2026-11-17T16:12:49.985413Z
Canonical: https://567politics.com/news/india-supreme-court-rahul-gandhi-48-interrogatories-eci-sir-bjp-andaman-letter-november-2026

Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights. Resolve relative links against https://567politics.com/news/india-supreme-court-rahul-gandhi-48-interrogatories-eci-sir-bjp-andaman-letter-november-2026.

India's Supreme Court on Tuesday, Nov. 17, put off until Dec. 9 a decision on whether opposition leaders can make the Election Commission of India (ECI) answer 48 formal questions under oath. The questions ask how the commission decided on the special intensive revision, or SIR, a review of voter rolls that has removed millions of names. The ECI's lawyer told the court the request would cause "very serious prejudice."

The same day, the [Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)](/parties/india/bjp) went on the attack outside the court. Its spokesperson Gaurav Bhatia read out a letter from a [Congress](/parties/india/congress) committee in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. The letter asks local officials to use the post-SIR voter list for 2027 municipal and panchayat polls. Bhatia called it proof of "double standards." Congress had not responded publicly in the reports reviewed for this article.

## What happened in court

The application was filed by [Rahul Gandhi](/politicians/rahul-gandhi), Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, and ten other opposition leaders, [Bar & Bench reported](https://www.barandbench.com/news/rahul-gandhis-plea-to-serve-48-interrogatories-on-eci-supreme-court-to-decide-after-considering-ecis-objections). Interrogatories are written questions that the other side must answer on oath. The petitioners rely on the Supreme Court Rules, 2013, which allow them.

A bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana heard the request. Senior advocate [Kapil Sibal](/politicians/kapil-sibal), for Gandhi, asked the court to issue notice to the ECI. Senior advocate Harish Salve, for the commission, objected. "We have something to say about that. There is very serious prejudice," Salve said.

"Whatever it is, you may file your reply. You can raise your objections," the chief justice said. "We will examine the interrogatories issue and then take a call." The court first agreed to issue notice, but Salve and senior advocate Maninder Singh opposed any notice before a preliminary hearing, [The Hindu reported](https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/sir-row-supreme-court-to-hear-rahul-gandhis-application-on-december-9/article71710964.ece). The bench then listed the matter for Dec. 9. [LiveLaw reported](https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/supreme-court-seeks-ecis-response-to-india-blocs-plea-to-serve-48-interrogatories-on-sir-decisions-558747) that the bench was also hearing another part-heard case that day.

The hearing follows Gandhi's Nov. 16 rejoinder, covered in our earlier report on [his claim that the ECI has not proved its SIR decision was unanimous](/news/india-rahul-gandhi-rejoinder-eci-sir-unanimous-supreme-court-hearing-november-2026).

![The central wing of the Supreme Court of India in New Delhi. Photo: Subhashish Panigrahi, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/f6542238-8b26-4e97-aea7-fa2ee46bbcb7/b78cbe1e1d53329af9b96e7cd00859c7.jpg)

## What the 48 questions ask

The core dispute is about who decided. The petition says Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar used the commission's "collective powers" without the knowledge or approval of Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi. The ECI says all three agreed.

The questions are grouped into ten categories, according to Bar & Bench. They include:

- **Unanimity.** For SIR orders dated June 24, 2025, Oct. 27, 2025 and May 14, 2026, the file numbers, dates and how each decision was taken: at a meeting, by circulating a file or electronically. They also ask when each member signed off.
- **Dissent.** How many times, between Feb. 19, 2025 and Oct. 26, 2026, either election commissioner recorded a written objection on the SIR, the ECINET database, Form 6 or the filing of appeals, LiveLaw reported.
- **The RTI gap.** Why the ECI's affidavit says a nationwide SIR was decided, when an August 2025 reply under the Right to Information Act said the commission had "so far not taken any decision" on a nationwide SIR in 2025, The Hindu reported.
- **Records.** Whether ECINET kept an audit trail for every addition, deletion and restoration since June 24, 2025.
- **West Bengal appeals.** How many appeals the ECI has filed against names restored to the rolls, and who decided to file them.
- **Form 7.** How many deletion objections in each state turned out to be false or filed in the names of people who do not exist.

The petitioners say these facts are only in the ECI's own records. They cite the Constitution Bench ruling in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India for the point that a court can order disclosure when the facts lie with one side.

## The commission's position

The ECI says the SIR is lawful. In a counter-affidavit dated Oct. 26 and a supplementary affidavit dated Nov. 14, both affirmed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu, it said the SIR orders followed unanimous decisions of the three-member body, according to Bar & Bench. The Oct. 26 affidavit said it was itself "approved for filing before this Hon'ble Court by a unanimous decision of the three members," LiveLaw reported.

The commission also says the petitioners' claims about changes to voter registration and its decision-making are "misconceived," [The Indian Express reported](https://indianexpress.com/article/legal-news/supreme-court-hearing-on-sir-cec-live-updates-eci-functioning-10966148/). It has not yet filed its written objections to the interrogatories. The reports reviewed do not say what prejudice Salve had in mind. The ECI is expected to set that out in its reply.

Nothing has been decided on the merits. The court has not found that any SIR decision was made unlawfully or by one member alone. It has only agreed to hear whether the questions may be put.


![Rahul Gandhi, Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, at a Constitution Day event in New Delhi on Nov. 26, 2025. Photo: Press Information Bureau, Government Open Data License – India, via Wikimedia Commons.](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/f6542238-8b26-4e97-aea7-fa2ee46bbcb7/4663c9ec78e79a4f4b894f0f3385423c.jpg)

## The BJP's Andaman letter

At a press conference in New Delhi, Bhatia read from a Nov. 14 letter by G. Bhaskar, chairman of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands Congress campaign committee, to the islands' Chief Electoral Officer. The letter describes "confusion and difficulties" for the public and booth-level agents because local polls were set to use voter rolls from before the SIR, [PTI reported](https://swadesi.com/news/congs-andaman-campaign-panel-urges-holding-municipal-panchayat-polls-b-mwkv0jl2). It asks the officer to adopt the "latest SIR electoral rolls as the primary basis" for the 2027 local polls.

"This letter is a very crucial piece of evidence of the Congress' double standards and its politics of propaganda, falsehood, lies and deceit," Bhatia said. He called the SIR a constitutional exercise under Article 324 that ensures only citizens are listed as voters.

Bhatia also cited Keralam Chief Minister V.D. Satheesan and Karnataka minister Satish Jarkiholi as having spoken well of the SIR in their states. "If SIR is good in Kerala and Karnataka, why is it being opposed elsewhere?" he asked, [IANS reported](https://ianslive.in/bjp-accuses-congress-of-double-standards-on-sir-process--20261117205031). He called on Gandhi and Congress president [Mallikarjun Kharge](/politicians/mallikarjun-kharge) to explain the party's position.

## How Congress has answered this charge before

No Congress reply to the Andaman letter had been reported by Tuesday evening. But Satheesan addressed a similar argument in October. He said the SIR in Keralam was "different" because neither the BJP nor the Communist Party of India (Marxist) had complained there, and the United Democratic Front had checked rolls at every polling booth, [The New Indian Express reported](https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/kerala/2026/Oct/10/cm-satheesan-rejects-sir-irregularity-charge-says-keralams-case-is-different). He pointed to West Bengal, Maharashtra, Haryana and Karnataka as states where roll concerns had been raised. "The BJP has a chance of winning in certain states. Such things have been done there. Why would they do it elsewhere?" he said.

The CPI(M) disputed part of that account. CPI(M) state secretariat member M.V. Jayarajan said the party had filed around a dozen written complaints about the SIR in Keralam, [Onmanorama reported](https://www.onmanorama.com/news/kerala/2026/10/10/sir-cm-s-claim-that-cpm-did-not-complain-is-a-blatant-lie-kelkar-s-role-should-be-probed-mv-jayarajan.html).

The two arguments test different things. Bhatia's case is that a party cannot reject the SIR nationally while asking to use its rolls locally. The opposition's legal case is narrower: it challenges how the commission made its decisions and how deletions were handled, not the idea of revising rolls. Asking that a local poll use the newest roll does not, by itself, endorse how that roll was made. It may still be politically awkward for a party that calls the exercise illegitimate. The letter, as quoted, does not address the SIR's legality either way.

![File photo: voters queue at a polling booth in Belgharia, North 24 Parganas, during the 2006 West Bengal Assembly election. Photo: Election Commission of India / PIB, Government Open Data License – India, via Wikimedia Commons.](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/f6542238-8b26-4e97-aea7-fa2ee46bbcb7/170d43682bb2811a4d67bb7e0068cf02.jpg)

## What the numbers show, and what they don't

Published totals for SIR deletions vary by phase, stage and source. The Hindu put the number excluded at around 13 crore, or 130 million. [The Hindustan Times reported](https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/special-summary-revision-about-5-million-voters-added-across-9-states-fraction-of-sir-removals-101794806567761.html) that the electorate in the 12 states and Union Territories of phase two fell from 509 million to 444 million at the draft stage. 567 Politics has not found a single official all-India total.

West Bengal shows how far the appeals process lags. When the SIR started there on Oct. 27, 2025, the state had 7.66 crore voters. That fell to 7.04 crore after names marked absent, shifted, dead or duplicate were removed. About 60 lakh more were flagged for "logical discrepancies." After judicial officers reviewed them, about 32 lakh were added back and 27 lakh deleted, [The Indian Express reported](https://indianexpress.com/article/india/west-bengal-sir-list-revision-under-adjudication-voter-election-commission-10965966/). One lakh is 100,000.

The Supreme Court ordered appeal tribunals on March 20. By Sept. 18, the ECI told the court that only 1.26 lakh of 38.31 lakh appeals had been decided, as the chart shows.

```chart
type: bar
title: Bengal's SIR tribunals had decided about 3% of appeals by September
note: West Bengal SIR appeals, in lakh (1 lakh = 100,000), as the ECI told the Supreme Court on Sept. 18, 2026
source: [The Indian Express, Nov. 17, 2026](https://indianexpress.com/article/india/west-bengal-sir-list-revision-under-adjudication-voter-election-commission-10965966/)
highlight: Appeals decided
---
Appeals | Lakh
Filed by voters who were deleted | 22.21
Filed against names restored to rolls | 16.10
Appeals decided | 1.26
```

Some voters cannot even appeal. More than 25,000 people in Murshidabad, Malda, Nadia and Howrah remain "under adjudication," according to The Indian Express, citing sources. Because no decision was made on their cases, they are neither on the rolls nor able to go to a tribunal. "I can't appeal, nor can I vote," said Md Salauddin Sheikh, 35, of Dhulian.

A routine update is now under way. The ECI published draft rolls for its annual Special Summary Revision on Nov. 12 in 13 states and three Union Territories. Claims and objections are open until Dec. 11, and final rolls are due Jan. 4. About 5 million voters were added across the nine states with data, the Hindustan Times reported. That is a small share of those removed under the SIR. Earlier, the ECI gave voters marked absent, shifted, dead or duplicate [another path back onto the rolls](/news/india-eci-asdd-voters-enumeration-forms-sir-facilitation-november-2026) in seven regions.

```diagram
type: timeline
title: The SIR dispute, from the first order to the Dec. 9 hearing
source: [LiveLaw](https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/supreme-court-seeks-ecis-response-to-india-blocs-plea-to-serve-48-interrogatories-on-sir-decisions-558747), [The Hindu](https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/sir-row-supreme-court-to-hear-rahul-gandhis-application-on-december-9/article71710964.ece), [The Indian Express](https://indianexpress.com/article/india/west-bengal-sir-list-revision-under-adjudication-voter-election-commission-10965966/), [Hindustan Times](https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/special-summary-revision-about-5-million-voters-added-across-9-states-fraction-of-sir-removals-101794806567761.html)
---
2025-06-24: ECI orders an SIR "in the entire country"
2025-08-27: RTI reply says no information on a nationwide SIR decision
2025-10-27: Second SIR order; Bengal's revision begins
2026-03-20: Supreme Court orders appeal tribunals for deleted voters
2026-05-14: Third SIR order
2026-09-18: ECI tells the court 1.26 lakh of 38.31 lakh Bengal appeals are decided
2026-10-26: ECI affidavit says SIR decisions were unanimous
2026-11-14: Supplementary ECI affidavit; Andaman Congress letter
2026-11-17: Court defers the interrogatories plea; BJP cites the letter
2026-12-09: Next Supreme Court hearing
2027-01-04: Final rolls due under the summary revision
```

## What to watch

The ECI must now file its objections before Dec. 9. The court will then decide whether the commissioners must answer any of the 48 questions on oath. If it allows them, the answers could show whether Sandhu and Joshi ever recorded dissent. If it refuses, the case will go ahead on the affidavits already filed.

The political fight is moving faster than the legal one. Home Minister [Amit Shah has offered a special session on the SIR](/news/india-amit-shah-rahul-gandhi-special-session-sir-debate-november-2026), and Gandhi has asked for an open debate with Prime Minister Narendra Modi instead. The Congress has not said whether its Andaman unit's request reflects party policy.

https://567politics.com/embed/politician-spectrum/rahul-gandhi

The chart above shows our dated editorial estimate of Gandhi's position. It is an estimate, not a measured score.
