{"schema_version":1,"citation_url":"https://567politics.com/news/israel-prosecution-high-court-petition-mandelblit-cross-examination-netanyahu-trial-november-2026","title":"Israel's prosecution asks High Court to let it cross-examine Mandelblit in Netanyahu trial","description":"The state says a November 2 ruling limiting it to re-examining the former attorney general breaks the law. A justice ordered a quick hearing.","author":"567 Politics staff","publisher":"567politics","date_published":"2026-11-16T17:39:21.992222Z","date_modified":"2026-11-16T17:39:21.992222Z","body_markdown":"Israel's state prosecution asked the High Court of Justice on Monday to overrule the judges in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's corruption trial. The dispute is over how prosecutors may question Avichai Mandelblit, the former attorney general who filed the indictment and now testifies as a defense witness. The trial panel ruled on November 2 that the state may only re-examine him, a narrower format than full cross-examination. The prosecution says that ruling breaks the law and will cause harm that no later appeal can repair.\n\n![The Supreme Court building in Jerusalem, where the High Court of Justice will hear the prosecution's petition. Photo: Fallaner, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/6a05312f-f864-4ef2-964d-228b0b82b1af/4b473f55edb34c5fd9a509a26904fe61.jpg)\n\nJustice Yael Willner ordered a hearing \"as soon as possible\" but declined to issue an interim order, [Kikar HaShabbat reported](https://www.kikar.co.il/laws/supreme-court-netanyahu-trial-mandelblit). That means the limit stays in place for now. The same day, the trial judges agreed to push back by a week a court appearance they had ordered from Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara.\n\n## What the prosecution is asking for\n\nThe petition was filed with the approval of Baharav-Miara and State Attorney Amit Aisman, [Bizportal's legal news service Takdin reported](https://www.bizportal.co.il/takdin/news/article/20048798). It names the trial court as the first respondent. In practice, the judges will not answer it. Lawyers for the defendants are expected to defend the ruling.\n\nThe state wants three things. It wants the High Court to strike down the November 2 decision. It wants a broad ruling that prosecutors may cross-examine anyone the defense calls from the state's original witness list. And it asked the court to freeze the questioning of such witnesses until the case is decided.\n\nThe difference between the two formats matters in court. In cross-examination, a lawyer may ask leading questions and confront a witness with documents and earlier statements. Re-examination is mostly limited to clarifying points raised in earlier questioning. Under the ruling, prosecutors may ask only open questions on topics the defense raised, [i24NEWS legal commentator Avishai Grinzaig wrote](https://www.i24news.tv/he/news/news/law/artc-c6905447). They may not lead the witness or show him relevant papers.\n\nThe petition rests on Section 174 of Israel's Criminal Procedure Law. According to the prosecution, it lets each side cross-examine a witness called by the other side. The state says the trial court cited no reasons, exceeded its powers and borrowed a civil-law idea, a \"witness identified with a party,\" from a ruling known as Borisi. Criminal law has its own complete set of rules, the state argues. It adds that the prosecution is a public body seeking the truth, not a private litigant with a personal stake.\n\n```diagram\ntype: flow\ntitle: What the prosecution asks the High Court to do\nsource: [Takdin via Bizportal](https://www.bizportal.co.il/takdin/news/article/20048798), [Kikar HaShabbat](https://www.kikar.co.il/laws/supreme-court-netanyahu-trial-mandelblit)\n---\nStrike down: cancel the November 2 ruling that limits the state to re-examining Mandelblit\nSet a rule: let prosecutors cross-examine defense witnesses taken from the state's original witness list\nFreeze: pause questioning of such witnesses until the petition is decided (Justice Willner declined)\n```\n\n## Why the prosecution says Mandelblit is a special case\n\nMandelblit was never on the prosecution's witness list. The state says that follows a practice in which the head of the prosecution system does not testify in his own cases. Netanyahu's defense called him instead. He began testifying on October 11, and the defense has questioned him for 11 sessions, i24NEWS reported. The state says the defense has questioned him in a cross-examination format since the start.\n\nThe prosecution argues that its position is unusually weak with this witness. Mandelblit is testifying about approvals for the probe, the investigation and the indictment, events from about a decade ago. Investigators never took statements from him. He had no prep interview before testifying. He also gave no direct testimony. With only re-examination, the state says, it cannot refresh his memory with records from the time or press him on gaps.\n\nOne exchange shows what is at stake. Asked about one line of inquiry in Case 2000, which involves the newspaper Israel Hayom, Mandelblit said, \"I'm not familiar with it. To the best of my knowledge, I did not approve investigating that line,\" Kikar HaShabbat reported. The site noted that the answer referred to that line of inquiry, not to the approvals for the case as a whole. Prosecutors say they need room to put records from the time to him on points like this.\n\n## The defense case for the limit\n\nThe trial judges ruled that \"the questioning of Avichai Mandelblit by the state will be conducted in the format of a re-examination,\" [JFeed reported](https://www.jfeed.com/news-israel/toloha). They added that if the state asks to question him another way on a specific matter, \"we will address it.\" Takdin reported that the judges saw the defense's questioning as cross-examination in substance. That was because of a memo Mandelblit filed at the start of the trial on the approvals to investigate Netanyahu.\n\nNetanyahu's lawyers and those of his co-defendants argued that Mandelblit and the police investigators are \"identified with the prosecution,\" according to the petition as described by i24NEWS. They said the memo he signed in January 2021, which listed the approvals for the probes, works like an affidavit for the prosecution. They also argued that letting the state drop witnesses and then cross-examine them when the defense calls them gives it an \"improper tactical procedural advantage.\" In their view, it would also reward padding witness lists.\n\n![The Jerusalem District Court building, photographed in 2007. Netanyahu's corruption case is before a panel of that court. Photo: Sir kiss, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/6a05312f-f864-4ef2-964d-228b0b82b1af/62636b1c914639217d9b5403d5b23bd9.jpg)\n\nThe prosecution rejects both points. It says the 2021 memo was not an affidavit. It adds that criminal trials in Israel have no process for using affidavits in place of direct testimony. It calls the court's approach \"changing the rules of the game during the game,\" because the state had already closed its case and planned around the plain text of the law.\n\nSome lawyers outside the case question the route the state chose. Criminal defense lawyer Liran Ohayon [wrote on X](https://x.com/liranadv/status/2122331108918403166) that the state chose not to call Mandelblit and that the court ruled it would not get cross-examination of a witness it had given up. \"The High Court is not an appeals court for interim decisions,\" he wrote. Commentator Amit Segal [wrote](https://www.jfeed.com/news-israel/toloha) that the petition shows the prosecution \"sees Mandelblit, the man who filed the indictment, as a witness for the defense.\"\n\n## A string of earlier limits\n\nThe Mandelblit ruling was not the first of its kind. The petition lists a series of earlier decisions, i24NEWS reported. In March 2025, the court limited the state to re-examining police investigator Superintendent Rinat Saban. She had been on the prosecution's list but was called by the defense. The court said she was \"identified with the prosecution.\" It later applied the same rule to 14 more police investigators. Questioning of two more witnesses, including former lawmaker Eitan Cabel, was limited in April and October 2026.\n\nThe state says it held back from challenging those rulings. It says it is not asking to recall witnesses who have finished. It wants a clear rule before the defense calls more witnesses. It also says the reasoning is spreading. According to the petition, defense lawyers in other cases, including the trial of lawmaker David Bitan and the Turgeman case, have tried to use the Jerusalem rulings to block cross-examination of defense witnesses.\n\n```diagram\ntype: timeline\ntitle: How the dispute over questioning defense witnesses reached the High Court\nsource: [i24NEWS](https://www.i24news.tv/he/news/news/law/artc-c6905447), [Takdin via Bizportal](https://www.bizportal.co.il/takdin/news/article/20048798), [Kikar HaShabbat](https://www.kikar.co.il/laws/supreme-court-netanyahu-trial-mandelblit), [Ynet](https://www.ynet.co.il/news/article/b14ff4damg)\n---\n2025-03: Court limits state to re-examining investigator Rinat Saban, later 14 more\n2026-04: A further witness is limited to re-examination\n2026-10-11: Mandelblit takes the stand as a defense witness\n2026-11-02: Panel rules the state may only re-examine Mandelblit\n2026-11-10: Court orders the attorney general to appear in person\n2026-11-16: State petitions the High Court; Willner orders a quick hearing, no freeze\n2026-11-25: Attorney general's postponed court appearance\n```\n\n## Why the High Court rarely steps in\n\nThe High Court usually does not review interim rulings in a criminal trial. Those issues normally wait for an appeal after the verdict. The state argues this is an exception. It says the trial has run for almost seven years, that the damage to the evidence could not be fixed on appeal and that the rulings are already affecting other cases.\n\nWillner's decision did not touch the merits. Kikar HaShabbat noted that a panel of justices will hear the case and both sides must file their positions first. Until then, the format set by the trial court stands. Mandelblit's questioning by the defense is near its end, so the timing of the hearing may decide whether the state gets any wider questioning of him at all.\n\n## The attorney general's delayed appearance\n\nThe second fight of the day was over the attorney general herself. On Tuesday, November 10, the trial panel ordered Baharav-Miara to come to court, over her objection, [Ynet reported](https://www.ynet.co.il/news/article/b14ff4damg). Judges Rivka Friedman-Feldman, Moshe Bar-Am and Oded Shaham wrote that \"there is added value\" in her presence. \"To hold a purposeful two-way dialog,\" they wrote, \"the official responsible for making the decisions\" must be able to hear the arguments directly and respond.\n\nProsecutor Yehudit Tirosh had argued that the attorney general runs the case through her prosecutors, who report to her regularly. Netanyahu's lead lawyer, Amit Hadad, said the court has the power to summon her. \"The fact that the attorney general does not want to come here, it is entirely possible to summon her,\" he said. On Monday the judges granted Tirosh's request to delay the appearance by a week because of scheduling limits, [The Yeshiva World reported](https://www.theyeshivaworld.com/news/israel-news/2623900/unusual-move-prosecution-petitions-high-court-against-netanyahu-trial-judges-over-mandelblit-testimony.html). Ynet said she is now due next Wednesday, November 25.\n\n```diagram\ntype: timeline\ntitle: The attorney general's court appearance, ordered and then delayed\nsource: [Ynet](https://www.ynet.co.il/news/article/b14ff4damg), [The Yeshiva World](https://www.theyeshivaworld.com/news/israel-news/2623900/unusual-move-prosecution-petitions-high-court-against-netanyahu-trial-judges-over-mandelblit-testimony.html)\n---\n2026-11-10: Trial panel orders Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara to appear in court, over her objection\n2026-11-16: Judges grant the prosecution's request to delay her appearance by a week\n2026-11-25: Baharav-Miara is due in court\n```\n\nBaharav-Miara is a central figure in Israel's political fights beyond the trial. This month she said she had seen no evidence \"even close\" to changing the election result, as [567 Politics reported](/news/israel-attorney-general-no-evidence-close-election-result-shin-bet-probe-fuel-cards-november-2026). She also told the Shin Bet that [evidence must come before it questions Arab party leaders](/news/israel-shin-bet-zini-arab-party-leaders-questioning-attorney-general-evidence-november-2026).\n\n## The trial itself keeps moving\n\nTestimony went on in court on Monday. Hadad asked the court to recall state witness Ari Harow, a former Netanyahu chief of staff. He said the defense had received investigative material that contradicts what was presented over the years. \"We have been operating in the dark for years,\" he said. The prosecution said those issues had already been dealt with.\n\nThe defense then called Topaz Luk, a longtime Netanyahu adviser. Luk testified that Netanyahu spends only about 20 minutes on media matters and that the Walla news site never came up in the spokesmen's work. \"The Prime Minister had zero involvement in the matter,\" Luk said. Under cross-examination by Tirosh, he said he admires Netanyahu and that their tie is \"personal and professional,\" The Yeshiva World reported.\n\n[Benjamin Netanyahu](/politicians/benjamin-netanyahu) faces charges of bribery, fraud and breach of trust in three cases, known as Cases 1000, 2000 and 4000. He has pleaded not guilty and denies wrongdoing. He is serving as caretaker prime minister after the October 27 election, while [Gadi Eisenkot holds the mandate to form a government](/news/israel-eisenkot-mandate-us-midterms-netanyahu-bipartisan-ties-november-2026).\n\n## What to watch\n\nNo date has been set for the High Court hearing. If the justices rule for the state, prosecutors could get full cross-examination of Mandelblit and of later defense witnesses who were once on the state's list. If they decline, the trial court's approach would stand until any appeal after a verdict. The attorney general's appearance on November 25 is the next fixed date. No response from Mandelblit to the petition was found at publication.","link_base":"https://567politics.com/news/israel-prosecution-high-court-petition-mandelblit-cross-examination-netanyahu-trial-november-2026","citation_guidance":"Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights."}