{"schema_version":1,"citation_url":"https://567politics.com/news/palestine-high-court-sharvit-wadi-al-fara-farmers-state-failed-army-ordered-acri-november-2026","title":"Israel's High Court finds the state failed to protect Jordan Valley farmers from settler Moshe Sharvit","description":"The unanimous ruling orders the army to keep Sharvit off 12 Palestinian farmers' land and secure their access; the state said it was already doing enough.","author":"567 Politics staff","publisher":"567politics","date_published":"2026-11-16T23:12:01.632332Z","date_modified":"2026-11-16T23:12:01.632332Z","body_markdown":"Israel's High Court of Justice has ruled that the state is failing its legal duty to protect Palestinian farmers in the Jordan Valley from a settler, Moshe Sharvit, and ordered the army to keep him off their land. The unanimous ruling, given on Sunday, November 15, accepted a petition filed for 12 farmers from the Wadi al-Far'a area. They say they have been unable to reach and work their plots since October 2023.\n\nJustice Daphne Barak-Erez wrote the judgment. Justices Ofer Grosskopf and Gila Canfy-Steinitz agreed. The court ordered \"effective steps\" to protect the farmers. These include removing Sharvit from their land, enforcing grazing limits, and taking active measures so they can reach and farm their land, with escorts if needed. That is according to long quotations from the ruling published by the legal news service [Takdin on Bizportal](https://www.bizportal.co.il/takdin/news/article/20048724) (Hebrew).\n\nThe state had argued that it was already doing enough. Sharvit denied the farmers' claims. The court rejected the state's position and ordered it to pay 25,000 shekels in costs. Sharvit must pay 10,000 shekels.\n\n## What the court ordered\n\nThe petition was filed in June 2025 by the [Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI)](https://www.english.acri.org.il/post/remove-a-violent-settler-from-the-west-bank-and-ensure-palestinian-farmers-are-protected) with the planning-rights group Bimkom, according to ACRI and the Palestinian outlet [PNN](https://pnn.ps/news/730230) (Arabic). It asked the military commander to remove Sharvit from the West Bank, or at least from the farmers' fields and homes. It also asked the army to remove a barrier and let the farmers work their land without interference.\n\n![The Tirza stream valley and the area around Wadi al-Far'a in the northern Jordan Valley, photographed in 2008.](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/858ccdd3-7fae-4c65-a63a-5f48929aee50/15334e8fc525af6cbcab98013707a789.jpg)\n\nThe ruling does not order Sharvit out of the West Bank as a whole. It orders the army to take concrete steps on the ground. According to Takdin's account, the court ordered:\n\n- removal of Sharvit from the petitioners' land;\n- effective enforcement where herds graze beyond permitted limits;\n- active steps to secure the farmers' routine access to their land, including escort and security when needed;\n- a permanent way through a gate placed in the area, or moving the gate somewhere else.\n\nACRI's summary of the ruling says the court required \"regular daily passage\" through the gate or another solution that ensures passage. PNN reported that the court also criticized the army for giving retroactive approval to a gate built without a permit. The full text of the November 15 judgment was not available online when this story was written. Its terms are reported here through Takdin, ACRI and PNN, which quote it at length.\n\n## Why the court said the state fell short\n\nBarak-Erez wrote that the case \"revealed a grim, troubling and difficult picture\" of state authorities \"showing helplessness in the face of frequent and continuing violations of the law by Israeli citizens in the area, and in particular by Sharvit.\" She wrote that many acts that hurt the farmers \"were not dealt with at all,\" and that even \"minimal steps\" the authorities decided on \"remained only 'on paper.'\" Those quotations are 567 Politics translations of the Hebrew text published by Takdin.\n\n```diagram\ntype: flow\ntitle: What the High Court told the army to do in Wadi al-Far'a\nsource: [Takdin](https://www.bizportal.co.il/takdin/news/article/20048724), [ACRI](https://www.english.acri.org.il/post/remove-a-violent-settler-from-the-west-bank-and-ensure-palestinian-farmers-are-protected)\n---\nRemove: keep Sharvit and those acting for him off the petitioners' land\nEnforce: act when herds graze beyond permitted limits\nEscort: secure the farmers' routine access, with security when needed\nOpen the gate: allow daily passage, or move the gate elsewhere\nPay costs: the state pays 25,000 shekels and Sharvit 10,000\n```\n\nThe judge listed what she described as the conduct shown in the case. It included violent assaults that sometimes caused injuries, gunfire into the air, stun and smoke grenades thrown at homes, threats, physical expulsion from farmland and homes, blocked access roads, damaged crops and property damage. She said this happened \"frequently and continuously.\"\n\nThe state argued that the farmers' claims could not be verified because they did not appear in police logs or in the records of the army's regional brigade. The court disagreed. Barak-Erez wrote that there was \"much unequivocal evidence\" of Sharvit's conduct, including video and photographs. She added that while the High Court does not usually decide disputes of fact, in this case the pattern was clear and the state had not answered it well enough.\n\nThe court did not say the army had denied its duty. According to Takdin, the army accepted that it must protect the farmers but argued that it was doing so. Barak-Erez wrote that \"without making light of the complexity\" of the army's work, the court \"cannot accept\" a situation that amounts to \"de facto acceptance\" of routine harm to the farmers, their property and their livelihoods.\n\nShe also criticized the police. \"It is impossible to finish without pointing to the difficulty in the fact that police activity in this context was not seen at all,\" she wrote. The court did not issue orders to the police, because the farmers had not asked for them, but said it expected the issue to be addressed.\n\n## Who Moshe Sharvit is\n\nSharvit runs the Emek Tirtza farm, also known as Moshe's Farm, near the farmers' land. ACRI calls it an unauthorized outpost. It says Sharvit has broken a restraining order issued against him in March 2025 and that his goal is to drive Palestinians out of the area. Those are ACRI's allegations. Sharvit has denied the claims against him in this case, according to Takdin.\n\nSeveral governments have acted against him. The [UK government](https://www.gov.uk/government/news/uk-sanctions-extremist-settlers-in-the-west-bank) sanctioned him on February 12, 2024, describing him as \"an extremist settler who has threatened, harassed and assaulted Palestinian shepherds and their families in the Jordan Valley.\" The [U.S. Treasury](https://ofac.treasury.gov/recent-actions/20240314) added Sharvit and \"Moshes Farm,\" also called the Tirza Valley farm outpost, to its sanctions list on March 14, 2024.\n\nThat U.S. listing no longer stands. On January 24, 2025, the [Treasury removed](https://ofac.treasury.gov/recent-actions/20250124) all names listed under the West Bank sanctions order after President [Donald Trump](/politicians/donald-trump) revoked it. A [Maariv report](https://www.maariv.co.il/news/law/article-1107531) from June 2024 said Canada had also sanctioned him.\n\n```diagram\ntype: timeline\ntitle: How the Wadi al-Far'a petition reached a ruling\nsource: [ACRI](https://www.english.acri.org.il/post/remove-a-violent-settler-from-the-west-bank-and-ensure-palestinian-farmers-are-protected), [High Court interim order (Hebrew)](https://01368b10-57e4-4138-acc3-01373134d221.usrfiles.com/ugd/01368b_9ad9823860e5480e9c3ce5298c4326b0.pdf), [Takdin](https://www.bizportal.co.il/takdin/news/article/20048724)\n---\n2023-10: Farmers say Sharvit blocks the access road to their plots\n2024-02-12: UK sanctions Sharvit over attacks on Palestinian shepherds\n2024-03-14: U.S. Treasury lists Sharvit and his farm under sanctions\n2025-01-24: U.S. removes West Bank sanctions after Trump revokes the order\n2025-03: A restraining order is issued against Sharvit, ACRI says\n2025-06-29: ACRI files the petition for 12 farmers\n2026-02-26: Court issues a conditional order to the state\n2026-03-11: Court issues an interim order to remove Sharvit from the land\n2026-11-15: Court accepts the petition and orders the army to act\n```\n\nSharvit has rejected the accusations in his own words before. In a March 2024 interview with [Arutz Sheva](https://www.inn.co.il/news/631176) (Hebrew), he said left-wing groups had \"been persecuting us for several years.\" He called the British sanctions \"a badge of victory and heroism for important pioneering work,\" and said: \"No lawsuits were filed against me in court, nor complaints with the police.\" He described the farm's work as helping \"to keep guarding the Land of Israel,\" and said he was carrying on the work of his brother, reserve Capt. Harel Sharvit, who was killed in Gaza.\n\nThe farm's buildings have also been the subject of other litigation. In 2024 the settlement watchdog group [Peace Now](https://peacenow.org.il/petition-against-moshe-sharvit) petitioned the High Court to enforce demolition orders against structures at the farm. Sharvit asked the court to dismiss that petition, arguing that it lacked jurisdiction, Maariv reported.\n\n## What each side says now\n\nACRI argues that the army's failure to protect the farmers leads to their dispossession. Its petition says the army told farmers to accept Sharvit's restrictions, or acted in ways that reinforced them. It says the farmers' efforts to coordinate safe access with the army failed, and that five written appeals to army officials \"went nowhere.\" Under international humanitarian law, ACRI argues, Palestinians in the West Bank are protected residents whom the military commander must protect.\n\nIn an April 2026 notice to the court, ACRI said that even after the interim order, Sharvit kept damaging the farmers' fields, entering homes and making threats. It also alleged that soldiers in uniform continued to back and accompany him. The army has not publicly answered that specific allegation, and no response from the Israel Defense Forces to the final ruling had been published when this story was written.\n\nThe court framed the ruling as a broader warning. \"Similar claims are brought before this court day after day, and it seems that many proceedings are being held on the subject, too many,\" Barak-Erez wrote, according to Takdin. She said she hoped the judgment would serve as a \"wake-up call\" and ended: \"This is the time to act.\"\n\n## The wider pattern in the West Bank\n\nThe ruling comes during a tense olive harvest season. United Nations monitors have [recorded a record month of settler attacks](/news/palestine-west-bank-october-incidents-pa-commission-3133-ocha-olive-harvest-november-2026), while Israeli officials point to arrests and to what they call provocations by activists, as covered in [earlier reporting on the harvest](/news/west-bank-olive-harvest-record-settler-attacks-ocha-israel-arrests-activists-november-2026). The army has also [cleared several outposts it called sources of violence](/news/palestine-west-bank-idf-clears-four-outposts-burqa-wadi-rahim-jalud-settlers-detained-november-2026), and has hunted suspects after a [mass vehicle arson in Lubban ash-Sharqiya](/news/palestine-lubban-sharqiya-arson-100-vehicles-settlers-idf-search-firing-ranges-ocha-harvest-november-2026).\n\nBy the count of the Palestinian Authority's Colonization and Wall Resistance Commission, incidents it attributes to settlers rose from 647 in September to 1,369 in October, according to reports by [Al-Quds](https://alquds.com/en/posts/260122-official-report-2051-israeli-attacks-against-palestinians-and-their-property) and the official Palestinian news agency [WAFA](https://www.wafa.ps/news/2026/11/2/هيئة-الجدار-والاستيطان-3133-اعتداء-لقوات) (Arabic). The commission is a Palestinian government body. It uses its own, broader definitions than UN monitors, and its figures have not been independently verified. Israeli authorities have not published a comparable monthly count.\n\n```chart\ntype: column\nstacked: yes\ntitle: Settler incidents more than doubled from September to October, by a PA body's count\nnote: Incidents the Palestinian Authority's Colonization and Wall Resistance Commission attributes to Israeli forces or settlers across the West Bank. The commission's own classification, broader than the UN's; not independently verified.\nsource: [Al-Quds (September report)](https://alquds.com/en/posts/260122-official-report-2051-israeli-attacks-against-palestinians-and-their-property), [WAFA (October report, Arabic)](https://www.wafa.ps/news/2026/11/2/هيئة-الجدار-والاستيطان-3133-اعتداء-لقوات)\nhighlight: By settlers\n---\nMonth | By Israeli forces | By settlers\nSeptember 2026 | 1,404 | 647\nOctober 2026 | 1,764 | 1,369\n```\n\nThe Wadi al-Far'a case differs because a court has now found, in a final judgment, that the state did not meet a duty it does not dispute. It does not decide any criminal charge against Sharvit. Whether the army now removes him and keeps the gate open is the next question.\n\n## What is not yet known\n\nSeveral facts remain open. The full judgment has not been posted publicly. The state has not said how or when the army will carry out the orders. It is also not clear whether the Israel Police will open new criminal cases after the court's criticism.\n\nThe farmers have not been able to farm their plots for more than three years, by ACRI's account. The damage to their income has not been measured in any public court record seen for this story.","link_base":"https://567politics.com/news/palestine-high-court-sharvit-wadi-al-fara-farmers-state-failed-army-ordered-acri-november-2026","citation_guidance":"Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights."}