{"version":"1.9","identifier":"7350dbcf-9027-4df3-99e5-9f72409b9974","language":"en-US","title":"Supreme Court leaves Maryland's gun-free zones in place, but Thomas invites a narrower challenge","layout":{"columns":7,"width":1024,"margin":32,"gutter":20},"componentLayouts":{"text":{"columnStart":0,"columnSpan":7,"maximumContentWidth":720,"margin":{"top":12,"bottom":12}},"photo":{"columnStart":0,"columnSpan":7,"margin":{"top":20,"bottom":20}}},"componentTextStyles":{"default":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":18,"lineHeight":29,"textColor":"#171717"},"headline":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue-Bold","fontSize":36,"lineHeight":42,"conditional":[{"conditions":{"maxViewportWidth":480},"fontSize":28,"lineHeight":34}]},"intro":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":20,"lineHeight":28,"textColor":"#555555"},"caption":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":13,"lineHeight":19,"textColor":"#666666"},"byline":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":13,"lineHeight":20,"textColor":"#666666"},"body":{"fontName":"HelveticaNeue","fontSize":18,"lineHeight":29,"paragraphSpacingAfter":14,"linkStyle":{"textColor":"#00704a"}}},"metadata":{"contentGenerationType":"AI","canonicalURL":"https://567politics.com/news/supreme-court-novotny-v-moore-maryland-sensitive-places-gun-law-thomas-november-2026","datePublished":"2026-11-17T12:28:48.9624Z","dateModified":"2026-11-17T12:28:48.9624Z","authors":["567 Politics staff"],"excerpt":"The justices denied Novotny v. Moore, keeping limits on guns in transit, parks and bars. Thomas urged a narrower test case; a New York parks ban is waiting.","thumbnailURL":"https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/7350dbcf-9027-4df3-99e5-9f72409b9974/aec0eb33a3956dc190d5f8fa93818b56.jpg","keywords":["policy"],"generatorName":"Frog News","generatorVersion":"1.0"},"components":[{"role":"title","text":"Supreme Court leaves Maryland's gun-free zones in place, but Thomas invites a narrower challenge","textStyle":"headline","layout":"text"},{"role":"intro","text":"The justices denied Novotny v. Moore, keeping limits on guns in transit, parks and bars. Thomas urged a narrower test case; a New York parks ban is waiting.","textStyle":"intro","layout":"text"},{"role":"byline","text":"By 567 Politics staff · AI-generated · Published November 17, 2026","textStyle":"byline","layout":"text"},{"role":"photo","URL":"https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/7350dbcf-9027-4df3-99e5-9f72409b9974/aec0eb33a3956dc190d5f8fa93818b56.jpg","caption":"The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington at dusk · Joe Ravi / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0","accessibilityCaption":"The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington at dusk","layout":"photo"},{"role":"caption","text":"The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington at dusk · Joe Ravi / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0","textStyle":"caption","layout":"text"},{"role":"body","format":"markdown","text":"The Supreme Court on Monday, November 16, 2026, turned away a challenge to Maryland's limits on carrying guns in \"sensitive places.\" The order leaves in force rules that bar permit holders from bringing firearms into mass transit, state parks, museums, stadiums, bars and restaurants, and the areas around public demonstrations. Some of the rules are decades old; others were added by a 2023 state law.\n\nThe order in [Novotny v. Moore, No. 25-1324](https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/26pdf/25-1324_0pm1.pdf) came without a noted dissent. But Justice Clarence Thomas wrote separately to say he is \"skeptical\" that each of Maryland's restrictions fits the nation's historical tradition of gun regulation. He agreed to deny review only because the challenge was so broad, and he urged the court to take up \"an appropriate and more narrowly focused case.\"\n\nThat points directly to a second petition already waiting at the court: a challenge, brought by two of the same gun-rights groups, to New York's ban on guns in public parks. Monday's order settles nothing about the constitutional question nationally. It does mean Maryland's law stays as the Fourth Circuit left it in January.\n\nThe respondents in the case are Maryland Governor [Wes Moore](https://567politics.com/politicians/wes-moore) and other state and local officials, defended by the office of Attorney General [Anthony G. Brown](https://567politics.com/politicians/anthony-g-brown).","textStyle":"body","layout":"text"},{"role":"body","format":"markdown","text":"## What the court did, and what Thomas wrote\n\nA denial of certiorari is not a ruling on the merits. It means at least six justices did not vote to hear the case, and the lower-court decision stands. The [Supreme Court docket](https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/25-1324.html) shows the petition was scheduled for the justices' private conference on September 28, then rescheduled three times before being distributed for conferences on November 6 and November 13. The denial followed on November 16, on the same order list in which the court turned away [a Colorado case over a state misgendering rule](https://567politics.com/news/supreme-court-gays-against-groomers-v-garcia-colorado-misgendering-rule-hb25-1312-tenth-circuit-november-2026).\n\nThomas's three-page statement, which no other justice joined, set out his concerns. \"Because each Maryland statute implicates a distinct historical tradition of firearm regulation, the breadth of petitioners' challenge would complicate our review,\" he wrote.\n\nHe then turned to the wider landscape. Under the court's 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, a state that limits where people can carry guns must show the rule \"is consistent with this Nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation.\" Bruen recognized that early legislatures barred weapons in \"legislative assemblies, polling places, and courthouses.\" It also warned that expanding sensitive places \"to all places of public congregation\" would \"eviscerate the general right to publicly carry arms for self-defense.\"","textStyle":"body","layout":"text"},{"role":"photo","URL":"https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/7350dbcf-9027-4df3-99e5-9f72409b9974/8d3d919557a852257e0af820d74b5306.jpg","caption":"Justice Clarence Thomas in his official Supreme Court portrait · Steve Petteway, Collection of the Supreme Court of the United States (public domain)","accessibilityCaption":"Justice Clarence Thomas in his official Supreme Court portrait","layout":"photo"},{"role":"caption","text":"Justice Clarence Thomas in his official Supreme Court portrait · Steve Petteway, Collection of the Supreme Court of the United States (public domain)","textStyle":"caption","layout":"text"},{"role":"body","format":"markdown","text":"Thomas argued that states \"have seized on the idea of 'sensitive places'\" to cover locations that \"bear little resemblance to legislatures, polling places, or courthouses.\" He wrote that the cumulative effect is \"to prohibit firearms wherever people gather for eating, drinking, recreation, amusement, and free speech.\"\n\nHe closed with a line gun-rights groups quickly highlighted: \"I harbor serious doubts that our Nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation supports many of these sweeping restrictions. In an appropriate case, this Court should consider whether particular sensitive-place laws are consistent with the right to public carry.\"\n\n## What the Fourth Circuit decided\n\nThe case began as two lawsuits filed in 2023 against Maryland's location limits, including new ones added that year by Senate Bill 1, which the General Assembly passed after Bruen. Chief U.S. District Judge George L. Russell III ruled first. A panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit heard argument on May 7, 2025, and issued its decision, [Kipke v. Moore, 165 F.4th 194](https://www.ca4.uscourts.gov/opinions/241799.P.pdf), on January 20, 2026.\n\nJudge Roger Gregory wrote the controlling opinion, joined by Chief Judge Albert Diaz. Judge G. Steven Agee concurred in part and dissented in part. The panel went location by location, and the votes split along the categories below.\n\n**The Fourth Circuit upheld nine of the ten Maryland location rules it reviewed**\n\nCount of the location categories decided in Kipke v. Moore (Jan. 20, 2026), by outcome and vote. Judge Agee was the dissenting vote in each 2-1 holding.","textStyle":"body","layout":"text"},{"role":"htmltable","html":"<table><tr><th>Outcome</th><th>Location categories</th></tr><tr><td>Upheld 3-0</td><td>3</td></tr><tr><td>Upheld 2-1</td><td>6</td></tr><tr><td>Struck down 3-0</td><td>1</td></tr></table>","layout":"text"},{"role":"body","format":"markdown","text":"Source: [Fourth Circuit, Kipke v. Moore](https://www.ca4.uscourts.gov/opinions/241799.P.pdf)","textStyle":"body","layout":"text"},{"role":"htmltable","html":"<table><tr><th>Location</th><th>Fourth Circuit holding</th><th>Vote</th></tr><tr><td>Government buildings</td><td>Ban upheld</td><td>3-0</td></tr><tr><td>School grounds</td><td>Ban upheld</td><td>3-0</td></tr><tr><td>Healthcare facilities</td><td>Ban upheld</td><td>3-0</td></tr><tr><td>Mass transit</td><td>Ban upheld</td><td>2-1</td></tr><tr><td>Within 1,000 feet of a public demonstration</td><td>Ban upheld, reversing the district court</td><td>2-1</td></tr><tr><td>State parks, state forests and Chesapeake Forest Lands</td><td>Ban upheld</td><td>2-1</td></tr><tr><td>Museums</td><td>Ban upheld</td><td>2-1</td></tr><tr><td>Stadiums, racetracks, amusement parks and casinos</td><td>Ban upheld</td><td>2-1</td></tr><tr><td>Places that sell alcohol</td><td>Ban upheld, reversing the district court</td><td>2-1</td></tr><tr><td>Private property open to the public, unless the owner consents</td><td>Default rule struck down</td><td>3-0</td></tr></table>","layout":"text"},{"role":"body","format":"markdown","text":"In each 2-1 holding, Agee was the dissenting vote. The only provision struck down was the rule that made private property open to the public, such as a store, off-limits to carriers unless the owner posted consent. On private property not open to the public, the court said the plaintiffs lacked standing.\n\nAgee's separate opinion, quoted in the petition, said the Supreme Court \"has offered scant guidance on what constitutes a 'sensitive place' beyond identifying a handful of examples.\" That, he wrote, had left \"some legislatures eager to label scores of locations 'sensitive.'\"\n\nIn June 2026, the Supreme Court separately decided Wolford v. Lopez, a Hawaii case, striking down that state's similar default rule for private property open to the public. That ruling did not address the location-specific bans Maryland defended here.\n\n## How the fight moved from Maryland to the courts and back\n\n**Maryland's sensitive-places law, from Bruen to the Supreme Court's denial**\n\n* **2008-06-26**: Heller first mentions \"sensitive places such as schools and government buildings\"\n* **2022-06-23**: Bruen requires gun limits to fit historical tradition\n* **2023**: Maryland enacts Senate Bill 1, adding new gun-free areas\n* **2025-05-07**: Fourth Circuit hears argument\n* **2026-01-20**: Fourth Circuit upholds all but one challenged restriction\n* **2026-05-20**: Gun-rights groups file petition at the Supreme Court\n* **2026-08-17**: Maryland files its brief in opposition\n* **2026-11-16**: Supreme Court denies review; Thomas writes separately\n\nSource: [Fourth Circuit opinion](https://www.ca4.uscourts.gov/opinions/241799.P.pdf), [Maryland brief in opposition](https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/25/25-1324/419189/20260817060449292_25-1324%20BriefInOpposition.pdf), [Supreme Court docket](https://www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?filename=/docket/docketfiles/html/public/25-1324.html), [Statement of Justice Thomas](https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/26pdf/25-1324_0pm1.pdf)\n\n## The case against the law\n\nThe petition was filed May 20, 2026. It was brought by three Maryland permit holders, Katherine Novotny, Sue Burke and Esther Rossberg. Maryland Shall Issue, the Second Amendment Foundation and the Firearms Policy Coalition joined them. A second set of plaintiffs, Susannah Warner Kipke and the Maryland State Rifle and Pistol Association, joined it. Counsel included the Washington firm Cooper & Kirk and Maryland lawyer Mark Pennak.\n\nThe [petition](https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/25/25-1324/409354/20260520133220255_25-%20Petition.pdf) asked a single question: whether Maryland's \"numerous prohibitions on carrying firearms in many places frequented by the general public violate the Second and Fourteenth Amendments.\"\n\nIts first argument heading said, \"The lower courts are eviscerating the Second Amendment protected right to carry arms in public.\" It argued that the courts of appeals are divided over how to judge location limits.\n\nThe petition's central theory concerns security. It argued that historical bans at polling places, courthouses and legislatures share one principle: the government protected people there. In its words, \"the self-defense right decreases only to the extent that the government's protective ability increases.\" Under that view, a place that the state does not secure, such as a park or a train, should not be off-limits.","textStyle":"body","layout":"text"},{"role":"photo","URL":"https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/7350dbcf-9027-4df3-99e5-9f72409b9974/de5595f2bd6f82e9e8e089473a4412cc.jpg","caption":"The Maryland State House in Annapolis, where the General Assembly passed the 2023 law · Ion628 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.5","accessibilityCaption":"The Maryland State House in Annapolis, where the General Assembly passed the 2023 law","layout":"photo"},{"role":"caption","text":"The Maryland State House in Annapolis, where the General Assembly passed the 2023 law · Ion628 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.5","textStyle":"caption","layout":"text"},{"role":"body","format":"markdown","text":"## Maryland's defense\n\nMaryland's [brief in opposition](https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/25/25-1324/419189/20260817060449292_25-1324%20BriefInOpposition.pdf), filed August 17, 2026, framed the question differently. It asked whether laws \"grounded in this Nation's historical tradition of firearms regulation\" are consistent with the Second Amendment.\n\nThe brief said many of Maryland's location limits are long-standing. It listed public school property, public transit, state buildings, state parks and forests, racetracks, the Camden Yards sports complex, state museums and casinos. The demonstration rule is also older, and the brief noted it applies only after police tell a person a demonstration is under way and order them to leave. It said Senate Bill 1 added three categories in 2023. They are areas for children and vulnerable people, government and public infrastructure areas, and special-purpose areas such as stadiums and places that serve alcohol. The same year, House Bill 824 removed Maryland's old \"good and substantial reason\" test for carry permits.\n\nThe state rejected the security theory. It noted that Maryland does not provide comprehensive security at any of its \"more than 1,500 polling places.\" Under the petitioners' theory, it argued, a ban there would be unconstitutional \"despite Heller and Bruen's express approval of such a prohibition.\" It called the theory \"unworkable even on its own terms,\" asking how much security would be needed for a ban to become valid.\n\nOn whether the court needed to step in, the brief argued that \"minor disputes are overshadowed by the vast areas of shared consensus\" among the circuits. It asked the court to \"allow the percolation process to continue.\" The court's order matched that request, though Thomas's statement did not adopt its reasoning.\n\n## Other states with long lists\n\nThomas's statement named three states with long lists of gun-free locations. He said New Jersey bans firearms in \"at least 25 locations,\" New York has designated 20 locations as sensitive, and California lists 29 gun-free spaces. He also cited Illinois and Hawaii in a footnote. His counts appear below; Maryland's own list is spread across several statutes and regulations, and he did not total it.\n\n**The three state lists of gun-free places that Thomas singled out**\n\nNumber of sensitive locations listed in each state's law, as counted in Justice Thomas's statement of Nov. 16, 2026. New Jersey's figure is \"at least 25.\"","textStyle":"body","layout":"text"},{"role":"htmltable","html":"<table><tr><th>State</th><th>Listed sensitive locations</th></tr><tr><td>California</td><td>29</td></tr><tr><td>New Jersey</td><td>25</td></tr><tr><td>New York</td><td>20</td></tr></table>","layout":"text"},{"role":"body","format":"markdown","text":"Source: [Statement of Justice Thomas, Novotny v. Moore](https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/26pdf/25-1324_0pm1.pdf)\n\nNew York's list traces to the Concealed Carry Improvement Act, which Governor [Kathy Hochul](https://567politics.com/politicians/kathy-hochul) signed on July 1, 2022, a week after Bruen. Her office's [announcement](https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor-hochul-signs-landmark-legislation-strengthen-gun-laws-and-bolster-restrictions) listed sites including airports, bars and restaurants that serve alcohol, houses of worship, public transit and Times Square. It also made \"no carry\" the default on private property unless the owner allowed guns. Hochul called Bruen \"a reckless decision\" at the signing.\n\nThomas noted that courts of appeals have upheld many of these limits. The Second Circuit upheld New York bans in places such as treatment centers, urban parks, zoos and theaters in Antonyuk v. James in 2024. A Third Circuit panel upheld many of New Jersey's limits, but that decision was vacated when the full court agreed to rehear it.\n\n## The next case to watch\n\nSecond Amendment Foundation official Bill Sack pointed to that next case. The group has a narrower case pending that focuses only on New York's ban in public parks, he noted in comments reported by [Maryland Matters](https://marylandmatters.org/2026/11/17/supreme-court-rejects-maryland-gun-case/). \"We are hopeful the Court takes a very hard look at that case,\" he wrote.\n\nThat petition, Christian v. James, No. 26-374, was filed September 16, 2026, by Brett Christian, the Firearms Policy Coalition and the Second Amendment Foundation. The respondents are Steven G. James, superintendent of the New York State Police, and Erie County District Attorney Michael J. Keane. The Second Circuit ruled against the challengers on May 18, 2026.\n\n**New York's parks ban, from Hochul's signature to the Supreme Court**\n\n* **2022-07-01**: Hochul signs the Concealed Carry Improvement Act\n* **2022-09-01**: The law takes effect\n* **2025-01-08**: Federal court in western New York issues its decision in the parks case\n* **2026-05-18**: Second Circuit rules against the challengers\n* **2026-09-16**: Christian v. James petition filed at the Supreme Court\n\nSource: [Office of Governor Hochul](https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor-hochul-signs-landmark-legislation-strengthen-gun-laws-and-bolster-restrictions), [Christian v. James petition](https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-374/424541/20260916143943154_26-%20Petition.pdf)\n\nThe [Christian petition](https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-374/424541/20260916143943154_26-%20Petition.pdf) asks whether New York's park ban violates the Second Amendment. It also asks whether laws from the second half of the 19th century can establish a tradition without support from the founding era. The petition argues that lower courts are split on that question. Thomas's call for \"a more narrowly focused case\" fits a single-location challenge, but his statement did not mention the New York petition.\n\nIn Maryland, the fight is also continuing at the county level. A week before the Supreme Court's order, a federal judge in Maryland upheld a similar Montgomery County gun law and dismissed a challenge brought by the U.S. Justice Department, Maryland Matters reported.\n\n## What the denial does not decide\n\nThe order leaves the Fourth Circuit's decision binding in Maryland, Virginia, West Virginia, North Carolina and South Carolina. It does not decide whether any particular sensitive-place ban is constitutional nationwide. It also does not bind other circuits, which may reach different results on parks, transit or alcohol.\n\nThomas's statement is not a holding. It represents one justice's view. Granting review requires four votes, and no other justice publicly joined his call to revisit the issue.\n\nOther gun cases remain on the docket. The court has agreed to hear two challenges to assault-weapons bans, Viramontes and Grant, with argument set for December 2, 2026, according to [Duke's Center for Firearms Law](https://firearmslaw.duke.edu/2026/11/scotus-gun-watch-11-16-2026). The same Monday order list denied 15 firearms-related petitions, 12 of them challenges to felon-in-possession bans, the center reported.\n\n## Responses\n\nBill Sack, senior director of legal operations at the Second Amendment Foundation, said the group was \"disappointed,\" Maryland Matters reported. He said Maryland \"has extinguished the Second Amendment rights of its residents\" by creating \"multiple categories of so-called sensitive places.\" He added, \"We are encouraged, however, with Justice Thomas' statement in which he casts serious doubt as to the constitutionality of laws like Maryland's.\"\n\nMaryland Shall Issue said the order \"is, of course, a disappointment.\" The group's statement added that it \"will continue to press appropriate challenges to misguided legislation that is designed for no other reason than to eviscerate the general right to publicly carry arms for self-defense.\"\n\nThe Maryland Attorney General's office did not immediately respond to a request for comment from Maryland Matters on Monday. 567politics did not contact Governor Moore's office, Attorney General Brown's office or the petitioners for this story. Maryland's legal position described here comes from its August 2026 brief.","textStyle":"body","layout":"text"}]}