# A Bakersfield bakery fought California for nine years over a wedding cake. It just settled for $12,000

The proposed decree covers Tastries' standard cakes and says nothing about custom designs, the ground owner Cathy Miller has defended since 2017.

By 567 Politics staff · 567politics
Published: 2026-11-17T16:11:41.631712Z
Updated: 2026-11-17T16:11:41.631712Z
Canonical: https://567politics.com/news/tastries-bakery-settlement-california-civil-rights-department-same-sex-wedding-cake-november-2026

Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights. Resolve relative links against https://567politics.com/news/tastries-bakery-settlement-california-civil-rights-department-same-sex-wedding-cake-november-2026.

A Bakersfield bakery that spent nine years in court over a wedding cake has agreed to settle with California. Tastries, owned by Cathy Miller, will sell its standard products to all customers regardless of sexual orientation, pay $12,000 and report to the state for five years, the [California Civil Rights Department announced on Nov. 16](https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/2026/11/16/after-rejection-at-supreme-court-bakersfield-bakery-backs-down-on-blanket-cake-ban-for-same-sex-weddings/).

The deal ends one of the longest-running disputes between a religious business owner and a state civil rights law. It also narrows what the fight was about. The [proposed consent decree](https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2026/11/2026.11.16-Joint-Stipulation-for-Entry-of-Proposed-Consent-Decree.pdf) binds the bakery only on "generic, multi-purpose" cakes and products. It does not mention custom designs, the ground Miller and her lawyers have defended since 2017.

## What Tastries agreed to

The settlement was filed as a joint stipulation in Kern County Superior Court. Miller's lawyer, Paul Jonna of LiMandri & Jonna, signed it on Nov. 13; the department's assistant chief counsel, James Zahradka, signed on Nov. 16. It takes effect only once a judge enters it.

Under the decree, Tastries and Miller must:

- comply with the state's Unruh Civil Rights Act as the state appeals court applied it in 2025, which means that if the bakery offers "generic, multi-purpose" cakes or other products, it must sell them on equal terms, including to same-sex couples;
- report any discrimination complaint from customers or employees to the department within five business days;
- have all employees attend a live virtual training on the Unruh Act within 120 days, then review the department's training video every year;
- post two state civil rights notices where staff and customers gather, within 30 days;
- file a written compliance report every year starting in January 2027.

The money breaks down in two parts. The bakery pays $8,000 in damages, $4,000 each to Eileen and Mireya Rodriguez-Del Rio, the couple whose 2017 complaint started the case. It also pays the department $4,000 toward fees and costs, in four $1,000 installments running from Nov. 15, 2026, to Feb. 16, 2027.

```chart
type: bar
title: Two-thirds of the $12,000 goes to the couple; the rest covers state fees
note: Payments under the proposed consent decree, in U.S. dollars. Fees are paid in four $1,000 installments.
source: [Joint stipulation and proposed consent decree, Kern County Superior Court, Nov. 16, 2026](https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2026/11/2026.11.16-Joint-Stipulation-for-Entry-of-Proposed-Consent-Decree.pdf)
prefix: $
---
Payment | Amount
Damages to Eileen Rodriguez-Del Rio | 4,000
Damages to Mireya Rodriguez-Del Rio | 4,000
Civil Rights Department fees and costs | 4,000
```

The court keeps jurisdiction for five years. If the department believes the bakery has broken the terms, it must first send a written summary and allow at least 21 days to fix the problem before asking a judge to enforce the decree. The obligations end early if Miller sells or gives up control of the business, though the department can challenge a sale it believes is not genuine. The decree contains no admission of liability; it states that the parties entered it "for the purposes of settlement only."

"In California, we don't turn people away because of who they love or where they come from," department director Kevin Kish said in the announcement. "This settlement shows that California is open to business for all."

No public statement on the settlement from Miller or her lawyers at the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty and the Thomas More Society could be found as of Tuesday morning. Her most recent public comment on the case came after the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear it in December 2025. "This isn't the result I prayed for, but I am sure God will use this for His glory," she said then, in a statement [reported by the San Joaquin Valley Sun](https://sjvsun.com/news/bakersfield/supreme-court-declines-to-hear-tastries-appeal/). "I will continue to work to use my creative skills to bless others and reflect my faith in Jesus."

## How a tasting appointment became a nine-year case

The facts are set out in the [state Court of Appeal's February 2025 opinion](https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2025/02/Tastries-Merits-Appeal_Courts-Opinion-F085800.pdf). In August 2017 the Rodriguez-Del Rios picked a cake from one of the bakery's display models: three tiers, white buttercream, no writing, symbols or topper. An employee described it at trial as a "very popular," "simple" design sold for birthdays, baby showers, weddings and quinceañeras.

When the couple returned for a tasting, Miller took over the appointment. On learning there was no groom, she told them she could not supply their wedding cake and referred them to another bakery. Miller follows written design standards, developed with her minister, that bar products for "explicit sexual content," drug use and similar themes, and state that "wedding cakes must not contradict God's sacrament of marriage between a man and a woman." The court found she would not provide any preordered cake for a same-sex wedding, whatever its design, while selling the identical cake for an opposite-sex wedding.

The aftermath was hard on both sides. The court recorded that the couple were "shocked, humiliated and frustrated," and that within hours the bakery began receiving threatening calls and pornographic emails, lost corporate accounts and had to shorten its hours. Miller and her employees received threats.

```diagram
type: timeline
title: Tastries and California: from a 2017 tasting to a 2026 settlement
source: [California Court of Appeal opinion](https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2025/02/Tastries-Merits-Appeal_Courts-Opinion-F085800.pdf); [Becket case page](https://becketfund.org/case/cathy-miller-tastries/); [SCOTUSblog docket](https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/miller-v-civil-rights-department/); [joint stipulation](https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2026/11/2026.11.16-Joint-Stipulation-for-Entry-of-Proposed-Consent-Decree.pdf)
---
Aug. 26, 2017: Miller declines the couple's wedding order at a tasting
Nov. 29, 2018: The state files its amended lawsuit in Kern County
Dec. 27, 2022: Trial court issues final decision for the bakery
Feb. 11, 2025: Court of Appeal reverses and rules for the state
May 28, 2025: California Supreme Court declines review
Dec. 8, 2025: U.S. Supreme Court denies Miller's petition
Nov. 13, 2026: Miller's lawyer signs the settlement stipulation
Nov. 16, 2026: Civil Rights Department announces the settlement
```

## Why the appeals court ruled for the state

The Kern County trial court sided with Miller after a 2022 bench trial. It found the state had not proven intentional discrimination, treated her referral to another bakery as adequate service, and concluded that preparing a preordered cake for a wedding is always protected expression. Becket's [2025 petition announcement](https://becketfund.org/media/supreme-court-to-decide-whether-california-can-prosecute-custom-baker/) highlights the trial judge's finding that Miller's "only intent, her only motivation, was fidelity to her sincere Christian beliefs."

The Fifth District Court of Appeal reversed on every point that mattered. It accepted that Miller's belief was sincere and held "in good faith without ill will or malice." But it held that the policy itself "pivots upon the sexual orientation of the end user," because it cannot operate until the couple's same-sex status is known. That, the court said, "necessarily" establishes intentional discrimination under the Unruh Act.

On the referral, the court warned that if pointing customers to another business counted as equal service, businesses "would be free to refuse service to anyone on account of protected characteristics" as long as a willing competitor existed.

On free speech, the court drew a line between this cake and the custom wedding websites at issue in the U.S. Supreme Court's 2023 decision in *303 Creative v. Elenis*. A "three-tiered, plain white cake with no writing, engravings, adornments, symbols or images is not pure speech," it wrote, and "other than flavoring and size, nothing about the predesigned cake was to be customized" for the couple. The court also rejected Miller's free exercise defense under existing precedent. The state was represented on appeal by Attorney General [Rob Bonta](/politicians/rob-bonta)'s office.

```diagram
type: flow
title: How the Court of Appeal answered each defense
source: [Civil Rights Department v. Cathy's Creations, Fifth District Court of Appeal, Feb. 11, 2025](https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2025/02/Tastries-Merits-Appeal_Courts-Opinion-F085800.pdf)
---
Intent: a policy triggered by a couple's same-sex status is intentional discrimination, even without malice
Referral: sending customers to another bakery is not full and equal service
Free speech: a predesigned, plain white cake is not the baker's speech
Free exercise: the defense fails under existing precedent
Result: trial judgment reversed and case sent back
```

## Two accounts of the same cake

The parties still describe the 2017 order differently, and the difference explains why both can claim the settlement fits their view.

The state calls it a "generic, multi-purpose white cake." The court of appeal agreed, noting that Tastries labels every preordered cake "custom" regardless of design. Miller's lawyers describe a custom commission. Becket's case page says the couple asked her "to design a custom cake for their wedding," and that Miller spends more than an hour with each couple explaining "the religious and symbolic meaning" of a wedding cake. "All I want is to serve my neighbors as the Gospel of Jesus Christ calls me to without being forced to create messages that violate my beliefs," she said in August 2025.

The consent decree tracks the court's line. It requires equal access to "generic, multi-purpose" products and is silent on custom designs. Whether Tastries may decline a genuinely custom design for a same-sex wedding, the kind of work the Supreme Court protected in *303 Creative*, was not decided in this case and is not addressed in the settlement. After the Supreme Court denied review, Miller's lawyers said they were evaluating how she could keep running Tastries in line with her faith. The bakery's website still advertises custom wedding cakes, saying "faith and artistry come together" in each design.

## What the public thinks

The most detailed recent measure of opinion on this question comes from PRRI's 2025 American Values Atlas, [published in March 2026](https://prri.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/PRRI-Mar-2026-LGBTQ-50State-final.pdf). PRRI asked whether respondents favor or oppose "allowing a small business owner in your state to refuse to provide products or services to gay or lesbian people if doing so would violate their religious beliefs." The survey interviewed 22,111 adults online between Feb. 28 and Dec. 8, 2025, mostly through Ipsos's probability-based KnowledgePanel, with 1,340 opt-in respondents added to reach at least 150 per state. PRRI reports a national margin of error of plus or minus 0.87 percentage points. It was funded by the Arcus Foundation and the Unitarian Universalist Veatch Program at Shelter Rock.

Nationally, 59% opposed such refusals in 2025, the same share as in 2015 and down from a peak of 66% in 2021. In California, 65% opposed them. The national figure hides a widening partisan gap.

```chart
type: column
title: The partisan gap on religious service refusals has widened since 2015
note: Percent of U.S. adults who oppose allowing a small business owner to refuse products or services to gay or lesbian people on religious grounds. Online surveys of U.S. adults.
source: [PRRI, Mapping Support for LGBTQ Rights Across the 50 States, March 2026](https://prri.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/PRRI-Mar-2026-LGBTQ-50State-final.pdf)
suffix: %
---
Group | 2015 | 2025
All adults | 59 | 59
Democrats | 74 | 82
Republicans | 40 | 35
```

PRRI found opposition to refusals at 46% among white Christians, down from 55% in 2020, and at 31% among white evangelical Protestants. The question asks about refusing service to gay or lesbian people in general. It does not distinguish between standard products and custom creative work, the distinction at the center of the Tastries case and of *303 Creative*, so it cannot show how the public would split on that narrower line.

## Where the case fits nationally

The U.S. Supreme Court has now turned away the Tastries case without comment, after deciding two related disputes on narrower grounds. In 2018's *Masterpiece Cakeshop*, it ruled for a Colorado baker because the state commission had shown hostility to his religion. In *303 Creative*, it held that Colorado could not compel a web designer to create custom wedding websites. Miller's petition, docket No. 25-233, asked the Court to go further: to decide whether compelled participation in a ceremony requires that third parties perceive endorsement, and whether *Employment Division v. Smith*, the 1990 precedent that limits free exercise claims against neutral, generally applicable laws, should be overruled. Ten amicus briefs were filed at the petition stage, including one from Alabama and other states, [according to the docket](https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/miller-v-civil-rights-department/).

Similar fights over speech, religion and LGBTQ protections are moving through other courts. A federal appeals court heard arguments on Monday over [Colorado's law adding chosen names and pronouns to its public accommodations statute](/news/supreme-court-gays-against-groomers-v-garcia-colorado-misgendering-rule-hb25-1312-tenth-circuit-november-2026), where a Christian bookstore and an apparel company say they fear enforcement for their speech. Earlier this month the justices [pressed both sides in a Catholic preschool's challenge](/news/st-mary-catholic-parish-v-roy-oral-argument-justices-questions-colorado-preschool-november-2026) to Colorado's LGBTQ nondiscrimination rule for its universal pre-K program. And in Virginia, voters this month weighed [a constitutional amendment on marriage](/news/virginia-amendments-results-reproductive-freedom-marriage-voting-rights-november-2026) alongside one on reproductive rights.

## Deadlines once a judge signs

A Kern County judge must enter the decree before it takes effect. The deadlines run from that date.

```diagram
type: flow
title: The decree's clock starts when a judge enters it
source: [Proposed consent decree, Nov. 16, 2026](https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2026/11/2026.11.16-Joint-Stipulation-for-Entry-of-Proposed-Consent-Decree.pdf)
---
Entry: a Kern County judge signs the decree and it takes effect
14 days: the bakery mails $4,000 to each member of the couple
30 days: state civil rights notices go up in the shop
January 2027: first annual compliance report to the department
120 days: all employees complete a live Unruh Act training
Five years: the decree expires and the state seeks dismissal
```

Absent an extension or a pending enforcement motion, the department will ask the court to dismiss the case with prejudice when the five-year term ends.

The settlement resolves only this case. The decree states that it does not limit any customer's right to file a new complaint against the bakery, and nothing in it decides how California law applies to custom wedding designs.
