# Turkey's top court strikes down the 1930 law behind state-licensed brothels, citing human dignity

The ruling, in force from Nov. 17, does not make sex work a crime or close brothels, but leaves registration and health checks without a legal basis.

By 567 Politics staff · 567politics
Published: 2026-11-17T17:18:41.480273Z
Updated: 2026-11-17T17:18:41.480273Z
Canonical: https://567politics.com/news/turkey-constitutional-court-annuls-brothel-law-article-128-public-hygiene-human-dignity-november-2026

Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights. Resolve relative links against https://567politics.com/news/turkey-constitutional-court-annuls-brothel-law-article-128-public-hygiene-human-dignity-november-2026.

Turkey's Constitutional Court has struck down the 96-year-old law that let the state license brothels and register the women who work in them. The court held that supervising prostitution, even in the name of public health, gives "legitimacy and security" to a practice it called incompatible with human dignity. The unanimous ruling, decided on July 16, was published in the Official Gazette on Tuesday, Nov. 17, and took effect the same day.

The decision does not make prostitution a crime, and it does not order any brothel to close. It removes what the court called the only legal basis for prostitution under state supervision. That leaves the licensed brothels that remain, the registration of their workers and the twice-weekly health checks attached to it without a clear footing in law. 567 Politics found no public response by Tuesday afternoon from the Interior and Health ministries, which ran the system jointly.

The ruling settles a constitutional question but reopens an old political one. Sex workers' rights groups have for years argued that licensed brothels are safer than the street and asked for more of them. Some officials in the governing AKP have pressed to close them as a form of exploitation. The court sided with neither camp's practical demands. It held that the state's duty is to fight the causes that push people into prostitution, not to regulate the trade.

![The Constitutional Court of Turkey in Ankara, which annulled Article 128 of the 1930 Public Hygiene Law in a ruling published on Nov. 17, 2026. Photo: Murat Karabulut/VOA, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/85efa411-1eb2-4405-8ec5-8d59036ad73c/3e8d4b022ccb70f63dce2d7a2b013be4.jpg)

## What the court struck down

The provision was Article 128 of the Public Hygiene Law No. 1593, which entered into force on April 24, 1930. Its first sentence told the health and interior ministries to issue a joint regulation setting "the rules to which public women and houses will be subject." It also covered the measures to stop the spread of diseases "caused by prostitution, especially venereal diseases." Its second sentence said that "public women, public houses and similar places" would be defined in that regulation.

The court annulled the first sentence as contrary to Articles 5 and 17 of the Constitution. It then annulled the second because, without the first, it could no longer be applied. The court [published the full decision](https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2026/11/20261117-3.pdf), file 2025/144 and decision 2026/164, in Tuesday's Official Gazette. It did not delay the annulment's effect, as it may for up to a year.

The case did not begin as a challenge to brothels as such. Three administrative courts sent the question to Ankara while hearing lawsuits over orders that had closed and sealed homes and workplaces for set periods. They were the Erzurum Regional Administrative Court, the Mardin 3rd Administrative Court and the Fourth Chamber of the Council of State, Turkey's top administrative court. They argued that the law left everything to a regulation without setting its limits. In their view, that handed the administration an unbounded power to make rules, contrary to the Constitution's requirements of legal certainty and of lawmaking by parliament.

The judges took a different route. Under the law on the court's procedures, they examined the rule against Article 17, which guarantees everyone "the right to protect and improve their material and spiritual existence." They also examined it against Article 5, which lists the state's basic aims and duties. Having found it unconstitutional on those grounds, they did not rule on the courts' original arguments. The court's president, Kadir Özkaya, took part in the unanimous decision.

```diagram
type: flow
title: How the brothel law reached the Constitutional Court
source: [Constitutional Court decision, Official Gazette](https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2026/11/20261117-3.pdf)
---
Closure orders: authorities close and seal homes and workplaces for set periods
Lawsuits: owners challenge the orders in administrative courts
Referrals: Erzurum regional court, Mardin court and the Council of State ask whether Article 128 is constitutional
Ruling: Constitutional Court annuls Article 128's first paragraph on July 16, 2026, unanimously
Effect: decision published Nov. 17, 2026; referring courts must apply it to the suspended cases
```

## The court's reasoning

The decision runs to eight pages. Its core argument is that a right to protect one's own dignity cannot be waived and puts positive duties on the state, not just a duty to stay out.

The judges acknowledged that the question of adult consent is unsettled. "While there is no doubt that forcing someone into prostitution is inhuman or degrading treatment, it is debatable whether adults' consensual prostitution has a value that can be protected under human rights," the court wrote. "That a person has the power to dispose of their own body as part of personal autonomy does not mean they can use this power without limit."

It then questioned how free that consent is. When prostitution follows social and economic hardship, physical, psychological or sexual abuse, or persuasion by traffickers, "it is difficult to speak of individuals' consent being free," the court said. It added that treating prostitution as a profession "is incompatible with human dignity" and would open the way to turning "the human body, especially the female body, into an economic market."

The public-health purpose of the 1930 law did not save it. Bringing prostitution into a legal framework under state supervision, "even if it is based on the aim of protecting public safety and health, does not make prostitution compatible with human dignity," the judges wrote.

The decisive passage set out what the court sees as the state's real job. "The state's primary duty in this matter is to eliminate the structural causes that lead individuals into prostitution through effective social policies, and to fight effectively against the people and organizations that act as intermediaries," it said. "Regulating an area in which a person's bodily integrity is commodified by exploiting their desperation or economic hardship means weakening the state's function of protecting the individual and indirectly granting legitimacy and security to a structure that violates human dignity."

```diagram
type: flow
title: The Constitutional Court's chain of reasoning
source: [Constitutional Court decision, Official Gazette](https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2026/11/20261117-3.pdf)
---
Right: Article 17 protects everyone's material and spiritual existence, a right that cannot be waived
Duty: Article 5 gives the state positive duties to protect that right, not just to stay out
Consent: hardship, abuse or traffickers' pressure make free consent hard to establish
Dignity: treating prostitution as a profession is incompatible with human dignity
Conclusion: licensing and supervising it lends legitimacy, so Article 128 is annulled
```

## What Turkish law says now

The court was explicit that the ruling creates no new crime. "In Turkish law in force, adults engaging in prostitution with their own consent has not been accepted as a crime," it noted. Human trafficking, forcing people into prostitution, encouraging children or adults into it, acting as an intermediary and providing a place for it are crimes, and remain so. A 2006 amendment added "making someone engage in prostitution" to the definition of trafficking in Article 80 of the penal code.

The court also described the system the 1930 law produced. A 1933 ordinance was replaced in 1961 by a regulation on "general women" and brothels and on fighting venereal disease. Under that regulation, as the court summarized it, a woman could be registered only if she had made prostitution her trade, was at least 21, was a Turkish citizen and was not married. Registered women had to work in brothels licensed by a commission, undergo medical examinations twice a week, and fell under anti-prostitution commissions run by provincial governors.

The decision says nothing about that 1961 regulation, which the court did not review. An analysis of the ruling [published by the Turkish legal news site Hukukçular Evi](https://hukukcularevi.com/hukuk-gundemi/aym-umumi-hifzissihha-kanunu-128-iptal-genelev-genel-kadin-e-2025-144-k-2026-164-2026/), notes the gap. The registration, licensing and examination system rested on the regulation, and the regulation rested on the annulled article. New licenses, registrations or closure orders can no longer be based on Article 128. Annulments do not apply retroactively, so earlier decisions do not lapse automatically. It also says courts that referred the case must apply the ruling to the cases they suspended.

```diagram
type: timeline
title: Turkey's licensed-brothel system, from the 1930 law to its annulment
source: [Constitutional Court decision, Official Gazette](https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2026/11/20261117-3.pdf); [Turkey Unfolding](https://turkeyunfolding.com/turkeys-top-court-scraps-brothel-law-on-grounds-of-human-dignity/)
---
1930-04-24: Public Hygiene Law takes effect; Article 128 orders rules for "public women and houses"
1933-11-12: First ordinance on fighting diseases spread by prostitution takes effect
1961-04-19: New regulation sets registration, brothel licensing and twice-weekly checks
2004-09-26: New penal code adopted; it defines human trafficking in Article 80
2006-12-06: "Making someone engage in prostitution" added to trafficking offense
2020: Istanbul's Zürafa Street brothels close during the pandemic
2026-07-16: Constitutional Court annuls Article 128 unanimously
2026-11-17: Ruling published in the Official Gazette and takes effect
```

## How many people are affected

Nobody knows precisely, which is part of the policy problem. Turkey publishes no official count of licensed brothels or registered sex workers. "The current number of operational brothels across Turkey remains unclear," [Turkey Unfolding](https://turkeyunfolding.com/turkeys-top-court-scraps-brothel-law-on-grounds-of-human-dignity/), an English-language news site, noted on Tuesday.

The most-cited figures are two decades old. A 2004 report by the Ankara Chamber of Commerce put the number of licensed brothels at 56 and registered women at about 3,000. It estimated that around 100,000 people sold sex in Turkey in all, according to a [data summary by the civil-society news site Sivil Sayfalar](https://www.sivilsayfalar.org/2016/03/03/rakamlarla-seks-isciligi/). That piece called the 2004 report the only figure of its kind published in Turkey. Sex workers' groups dispute such estimates, and they do not separate women, men and trans people consistently.

```chart
type: bar
title: Sex workers in Turkey: the only published estimate
note: Approximate numbers of people from a 2004 Ankara Chamber of Commerce report. No official count has been published since; brothel closures since then mean the registered figure is now lower, by an unknown amount.
source: [Sivil Sayfalar, citing the Ankara Chamber of Commerce](https://www.sivilsayfalar.org/2016/03/03/rakamlarla-seks-isciligi/)
---
Group | People
Registered in licensed brothels | 3000
Estimated total, registered and unregistered | 100000
```

The licensed sector shrank long before the ruling. In 2013, Kemal Ördek, head of the Red Umbrella (Kırmızı Şemsiye) sex workers' rights association, told [Hürriyet](https://www.hurriyet.com.tr/gundem/tazminat-verelim-genelevler-kapansin-25355186) that brothels had closed in Antalya, Aydın, Afyon, Antakya, Ankara, Bursa and Balıkesir. He said six houses had also closed in Istanbul's Karaköy district. He said no new women had been admitted to brothels since 1999 and that the number working in them had roughly halved. He cited a parliamentary answer that put the youngest woman in a brothel at 31 and the oldest at 60. Turkey Unfolding notes that Zürafa Street in Karaköy, once the country's best-known red-light district, closed during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. Many of its buildings were later demolished for redevelopment.

## The arguments on each side

Three broad positions have shaped Turkey's debate. The court's ruling fits squarely with none of them.

**Close the brothels.** The court's language echoes arguments made within the governing party for more than a decade. In 2013, AKP deputy Nureddin Nebati, later finance minister, proposed a regulation to shut Turkey's brothels, which defined them as "modern-age slavery." "States shouldn't allow women to be sold like material things," he reportedly said, according to the [Hürriyet Daily News](https://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/turkish-deputy-proposes-shutting-down-brothels-40226). The same report said party sources expected the idea to fail because a ban would push the trade onto the streets, unregistered. That December, the family ministry met sex workers' representatives and asked whether paying compensation to workers if the brothels closed would remedy their grievances, Hürriyet reported. The Red Umbrella association said it would not.

**Keep and expand licensed brothels.** Sex workers' advocates have made the opposite case: that licensed houses, whatever their faults, are the safest option available. "Brothels are more supervisable places in terms of preventing violence, exploitation and forced labor," Şevval Kılıç of the Kadın Kapısı group told [Kaos GL](https://kaosgl.org/haber/seks-iscileri-fislenmek-degil-guvenceli-is-istiyor) in 2010. "The likelihood of being subjected to violence or killed in brothels is lower. They work registered with social security, and they can benefit from regular health checks." Ördek's association answered the 2013 closure idea by asking the ministry to open more brothels instead. It said the real problem was the plight of the roughly 100,000 sex workers outside them.

**Recognize sex work as work.** A third view, held by the same activist network, criticizes the registration system itself, including the special identity card registered women carried. It asks for sex work to be treated as a job with labor rights. "We want sex work to be accepted as a job, a profession, and brought up to certain standards," the Red Umbrella initiative said in a [2009 statement published by Kaos GL](https://kaosgl.org/haber/seks-isciligi-de-isciliktir). It demanded social security, an end to discriminatory laws and police violence, and "a world without bosses and pimps."

```diagram
type: flow
title: Three positions in Turkey's brothel debate, and how the ruling treats them
source: [Constitutional Court decision](https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2026/11/20261117-3.pdf), [Hürriyet Daily News](https://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/turkish-deputy-proposes-shutting-down-brothels-40226), [Kaos GL](https://kaosgl.org/haber/seks-isciligi-de-isciliktir)
---
Close the brothels: argued by AKP deputy Nureddin Nebati in 2013; the ruling removes the licensing law but orders no closures
Keep and expand them: argued by Red Umbrella and Kadın Kapısı; the ruling does not address their safety argument
Recognize sex work as work: argued by Red Umbrella in 2009; the ruling rejects treating prostitution as a profession
```

The court's reasoning rejects the third position directly, holding that treating prostitution as a profession violates human dignity. It is silent on the practical claims of the second, that closure pushes people into more dangerous, unregulated work. It does not adopt the first camp's remedies either. It neither orders closure nor creates new offenses, and instead puts the burden on social policy.

No statement on the ruling from sex workers' organizations, the ministries or the political parties had been published by Tuesday afternoon in Turkey, in sources found by 567 Politics. The views above are the groups' earlier public positions, not responses to this decision.

## Where the European debate fits

The court placed its decision within European and international law. It cited a 2007 resolution of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe that called forced prostitution "modern slavery" and a grave human-rights violation. The same resolution also discussed "voluntary" adult prostitution and recommended against punishing people who sell sex. It cited European Court of Human Rights case law holding that forced prostitution is inhuman and degrading treatment, while noting that Strasbourg has found no consensus among member states on the legal status of prostitution. And it cited Turkey's ratification of the UN's 1956 slavery convention and the 2000 trafficking protocol.

That European record cuts more than one way. The Council of Europe resolution the court quoted urged states not to criminalize sex workers and to help those who want to leave. The court's own citation of the Strasbourg case law acknowledges that European states take sharply different approaches. Some license sex work. Others penalize buyers. Many tolerate it without a licensing system.

## A sensitive moment for sex workers

The ruling arrives as rights groups say sex workers in Turkey face growing pressure. Four European and global networks, including the European Sex Workers' Rights Alliance and Trans Europe and Central Asia (TGEU), issued a joint statement this month. In it, they [condemned what they called a crackdown](https://www.tgeu.org/joint-statement-we-call-on-turkiye-to-end-the-targeting-of-trans-people-and-sex-workers/) under the "My Family Is Safe" operation, which they said began on Sept. 12. Their statement says 45 people, including 12 trans women, were taken into custody on Oct. 23. It says that on Oct. 26, 19 people, including 10 trans women, were arrested on prostitution-related allegations. It says 22 more people, including trans women, were detained on Nov. 3 on allegations of "encouraging, facilitating or coercing prostitution." According to the statement, the Ankara Chief Public Prosecutor's Office cited detainees' social media posts as containing material "contrary to public morality" and "disruptive to public order."

```chart
type: column
title: Detentions reported in Turkey's "My Family Is Safe" operation
note: Number of people taken into custody or arrested on each date, as reported by four sex workers' and trans rights networks. The Oct. 23 figure includes 12 trans women and the Oct. 26 figure 10 trans women.
source: [ESWA, NSWP, SWAN and TGEU joint statement](https://www.tgeu.org/joint-statement-we-call-on-turkiye-to-end-the-targeting-of-trans-people-and-sex-workers/)
---
Date | People
Oct. 23 | 45
Oct. 26 | 19
Nov. 3 | 22
```

The same period has seen other prosecutions over gender and sexuality. An opposition MP's wife was [questioned about LGBT projects](/news/turkey-yonca-verdioglu-sik-espionage-probe-heinrich-boll-travel-ban-tip-ahmet-sik-november-2026) in an espionage probe this month.

The Constitutional Court has often been at the center of Turkey's legal fights. It has twice found that jailed MP Can Atalay's rights were violated, a position the European Court of Human Rights [backed on Nov. 17](/news/turkey-echr-can-atalay-release-mp-seat-article-18-november-2026) against the Court of Cassation. Debate over the high courts' makeup is also live, with proposals to [raise judges' retirement age](/news/turkey-arinc-judges-retirement-age-72-yildiz-156-high-court-members-2028-term-limit-november-2026) before term limits take effect in 2028. In this case, the court's reasoning echoed the dignity-based case for closure made inside the governing party, rather than arguments about individual choice. Other courts have recently struck down old laws on sex and morality in different contexts, such as the Privy Council's Nov. 10 ruling that [ended Trinidad and Tobago's ban on gay sex](/news/trinidad-tobago-privy-council-jason-jones-buggery-serious-indecency-ruling-november-2026).

## Open questions for the government and parliament

Several questions now fall to the government and parliament:

- **The 1961 regulation.** It still exists on paper, but the law it implemented is gone. The ministries could repeal it, try to rebase it on another law, or leave it in limbo.
- **Licensed brothels and registered workers.** The ruling does not say how existing licenses and registrations end. The Hukukçular Evi analysis says that under Turkey's data-protection law, personal data must be deleted once the reason for processing it is gone, either by the authorities or at the person's request.
- **Health checks.** The twice-weekly examinations rested on the same rules. No alternative system for sexual-health services for sex workers has been announced.
- **New legislation.** Because the court did not delay the annulment, parliament is not obliged to fill the gap on a deadline, but nothing stops it from legislating. Any new law that tried to license prostitution would have to contend with this ruling's reasoning.
- **Pending cases.** The closure-and-sealing lawsuits that prompted the referral now go back to the three administrative courts, which must apply the decision.

The decision itself gives the state a direction rather than a plan: fight "the structural causes" and the intermediaries. How the government turns that into policy, or whether it does at all, will decide what the ruling means for the people it concerns.
