# European court orders Turkey to free jailed MP Can Atalay, finds detention meant to silence him

A 6-1 Strasbourg ruling sides with Turkey's Constitutional Court against the Court of Cassation; Turkey's judge dissents and the ruling is not yet final.

By 567 Politics staff · 567politics
Published: 2026-11-17T14:15:17.529876Z
Updated: 2026-11-17T14:15:17.529876Z
Canonical: https://567politics.com/news/turkey-echr-can-atalay-release-mp-seat-article-18-november-2026

Cite citation_url. Preserve source links, dates and qualifications. date_modified is an edit date, not proof that every claim was rechecked. Third-party images and quoted material retain their own rights. Resolve relative links against https://567politics.com/news/turkey-echr-can-atalay-release-mp-seat-article-18-november-2026.

Europe's human rights court on Tuesday, Nov. 17, ordered Turkey to free Can Atalay, a lawyer who was elected to parliament from prison in 2023, and to let him take up his seat. A seven-judge chamber of the European Court of Human Rights found that his continued detention after the election broke the European Convention on Human Rights in four ways. In its most serious finding, the court said the detention was meant "to silence him and to stifle pluralism."

The ruling turns on a fight inside Turkey's own courts. Turkey's Constitutional Court twice ruled that Atalay's rights were violated and ordered his release. Turkey's Court of Cassation, the top appeals court for criminal cases, refused both times and filed a criminal complaint against the constitutional judges who voted for him. Strasbourg sided with the Constitutional Court. Turkey's government had argued that the clash was a legitimate legal debate between two equal high courts.

The judgment is not yet final. Either side can ask for a rehearing before the court's Grand Chamber within three months. Turkey's own judge on the panel, Saadet Yüksel, dissented on three of the four findings.

![The Human Rights Building in Strasbourg, France, home of the European Court of Human Rights, which ruled on Can Atalay's case on Nov. 17. Photo: Gzen92, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/094713fb-ea42-4e15-849f-f154973fc570/d0073f3ab1955a024de148fce2f3e9b1.jpg)

## What the court decided

In [Şerafettin Can Atalay v. Türkiye](https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-253534) (application no. 11503/24), the court found violations of four provisions, according to its [press release](https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng-press?i=003-8697147-12412463):

- Article 5 § 1, the right to liberty and security, by six votes to one
- Article 5 § 4, the right to a speedy court review of detention, unanimously
- Article 3 of Protocol No. 1, the right to free elections, by six votes to one
- Article 18, which bars states from restricting rights for purposes the convention does not allow, by six votes to one

```chart
type: column
stacked: yes
title: How judges voted on Atalay's case
note: Number of judges finding a violation or not, in each ruling
source: [European Court of Human Rights judgment](https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-253534)
---
Ruling | Violation | No violation
Constitutional Court, Oct. 2023 | 9 | 5
Constitutional Court, Dec. 2023 | 11 | 3
ECtHR, liberty (Art. 5 § 1) | 6 | 1
ECtHR, speedy review (Art. 5 § 4) | 7 | 0
ECtHR, free elections | 6 | 1
ECtHR, political motive (Art. 18) | 6 | 1
```

Under Article 46, which makes the court's judgments binding, the judges went further than a finding of violation. They held that Turkey must release Atalay and allow him to take up his seat in parliament. They also said full compliance with Constitutional Court rulings was "essential to the rule of law" and that Turkey must take steps to prevent similar violations. Turkey must pay Atalay 32,500 euros for non-pecuniary damage, meaning harm such as distress rather than financial loss.

The court stressed that its finding on the right to a speedy review was limited to this case. It did not, the judges wrote, call into question the effectiveness of the Constitutional Court as a whole. Instead it "shed light on the attitude of certain lower courts as to the binding force of its judgments."

## How Atalay ended up in prison as an elected MP

Atalay, a lawyer born in 1976, was one of the defendants in the trial over the 2013 Gezi Park protests in Istanbul. On April 25, 2022, an Istanbul court convicted him of aiding an attempt to overthrow the government. It found that he had helped businessman Osman Kavala, the main defendant, and sentenced him to 18 years in prison. He has been in custody since that day.

While his appeal was pending, the Workers' Party of Turkey (TİP) ran him for parliament in Hatay province, and he won a seat on May 14, 2023. He then asked to be released under Article 83 of Turkey's constitution, which gives lawmakers immunity from prosecution unless parliament lifts it.

The Court of Cassation said no. Article 83 has an exception for cases covered by Article 14, if the investigation began before the election. Article 14 bars using rights to destroy the state's unity or its democratic order. The Court of Cassation ruled that Atalay's offense fell under that exception. It upheld his conviction on Sept. 28, 2023.

The Constitutional Court disagreed. On Oct. 25, 2023, by nine votes to five, it found that Atalay's detention and the block on his political rights were not "prescribed by law." It had held in earlier cases that no clear law defines which crimes fall under Article 14, so courts cannot apply the exception in a foreseeable way. It ordered his release and a retrial.

On Nov. 8, 2023, the Court of Cassation refused to implement that ruling. It said the Constitutional Court had acted as a "fourth-instance court" beyond its powers. It also filed a criminal complaint against the constitutional judges who voted for Atalay. The Constitutional Court ruled for him again on Dec. 21, 2023, by 11 votes to three. On Jan. 3, 2024, the Court of Cassation refused again. Its decision was read out in parliament on Jan. 30, 2024, which ended Atalay's term as a member.

```diagram
type: timeline
title: Can Atalay's case, from conviction to Strasbourg
source: [European Court of Human Rights judgment](https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-253534)
---
2022-04-25: Istanbul court convicts Atalay in the Gezi trial and sentences him to 18 years
2023-05-14: Elected MP for Hatay on the Workers' Party of Turkey ticket
2023-07-13: Court of Cassation rejects his claim to parliamentary immunity
2023-09-28: Court of Cassation upholds his conviction
2023-10-25: Constitutional Court finds violations and orders his release, 9-5
2023-11-08: Court of Cassation refuses to comply and files a complaint against constitutional judges
2023-12-21: Constitutional Court rules for him again, 11-3
2024-01-03: Court of Cassation refuses a second time
2024-01-30: Decision read in parliament; his membership ends
2024-04-16: Atalay applies to the European Court of Human Rights
2026-11-17: European court orders his release and return to parliament
```

## Why the court found a political motive

Article 18 findings are rare, and the bar is high. The court must be satisfied that a state restricted rights for a hidden purpose. Here the majority found that purpose was to silence Atalay.

The judges said his case "could not be viewed in isolation." They placed it alongside the detention of other political opponents, human rights defenders and journalists in Turkey. They listed several specific factors, according to the press release:

- The Court of Cassation's second refusal to carry out a Constitutional Court ruling was "unprecedented." It could not be explained only by a legal debate between the high courts, as the government argued.
- The Court of Cassation departed from its own earlier rulings on the binding effect of Constitutional Court judgments.
- It filed a criminal complaint against the constitutional judges who ruled for Atalay.
- President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and his chief adviser, Mehmet Uçum, made public statements backing the Court of Cassation.
- The Council of Europe's Venice Commission and its human rights commissioner had raised concerns about political pressure on judges.

The judgment quotes those statements. In a speech reported on Nov. 10, 2023, Erdoğan said that if friends from his own party were faulting the Court of Cassation and praising the Constitutional Court, "they are doing wrong as well." In January 2024, he criticized an opposition leader. He said, "This mentality is preoccupied with digging a tunnel from the prison to Parliament in order to rescue a terrorist who has been sentenced to 18 years in prison." Atalay told the court that remark referred to him. Uçum wrote on social media in November 2023 that the Court of Cassation's refusal was "correct in its reasoning" and called the Constitutional Court's rulings "judicial activism."

The court found that Atalay's detention was meant "to silence him and to stifle pluralism." It added that this "could have a dissuasive effect on the work of human-rights defenders."

The court has dealt with the Gezi case before. Its press release points readers to its recent Grand Chamber judgment in Kavala v. Türkiye (no. 2), the case of the businessman Atalay was convicted of aiding. The judgment also cites earlier Article 18 rulings against Turkey, including the Kavala case.

## Turkey's defense and the dissent

```diagram
type: flow
title: The immunity question at the heart of the case
source: [European Court of Human Rights judgment](https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-253534)
---
Rule: Article 83 of Turkey's constitution shields MPs from prosecution and detention
Exception: the shield does not apply to "situations referred to in Article 14" if the investigation began before the election
Court of Cassation: judges can decide which crimes fall under Article 14, so Atalay stays in prison
Constitutional Court: no law defines those crimes, so the exception is not foreseeable and he must be freed
Strasbourg majority: sides with the Constitutional Court and orders his release
```

Turkey's government told the court that the Court of Cassation and the Constitutional Court are separate high courts with no hierarchy between them. It said their different readings of Articles 14 and 83 were "legally defensible and reasonable" and part of developing case law. Atalay had been able to challenge his detention before both courts, which examined it in detail, it argued.

On the political-motive claim, the government said Article 18 has "a particularly high evidential threshold" and that the convention system presumes authorities act in good faith. Public statements by politicians were not enough to show a hidden agenda by judges, it argued, "particularly in the absence of manifest procedural irregularities or fabricated charges." Public debate about the case, including views in Atalay's favor, was "a normal feature of democratic societies," the government said.

The court rejected that line. In its view, the government's argument meant that Constitutional Court rulings were valid only if the lower courts approved them. That, the court said, "was neither in keeping with the European Court's case-law nor with the principles established in the Turkish Court of Cassation's own decisions."

Judge Yüksel agreed that the failure to implement the Constitutional Court's judgments violated Article 5 § 4. She dissented on the other three findings. In her view, Articles 14 and 83 were foreseeable enough, because until 2021 it had been "undisputed" in Turkish practice that judges decide which offenses fall under the exception. She also wrote that a dispute over interpretation between two high courts did not prove a political motive, [T24 reported](https://t24.com.tr/haber/aihmden-can-atalay-icin-hak-ihlal-karari-serbest-birakilmali-ve-milletvekilligi-gorevine-donmeli,1359431). She voted against the order to release him.

## Reactions and what comes next

![The plenary chamber of Turkey's Grand National Assembly in Ankara, where Can Atalay's membership was ended on Jan. 30, 2024. Photo: Yıldız Yazıcıoğlu/VOA, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons](https://pub-fac99da959e344fe99d810d309cef7df.r2.dev/photos/article/094713fb-ea42-4e15-849f-f154973fc570/4cfab0847186a2e43bca54c6a2ef7722.jpg)

Erkan Baş, chair of the Workers' Party of Turkey, called on all parties and on Parliament Speaker Numan Kurtulmuş to act. "This lawlessness must end immediately," he wrote, according to [Evrensel](https://www.evrensel.net/haber/6009884/aihm-den-can-atalay-karari-derhal-serbest-birakilmali-milletvekilligi-yapabilmeli). "Can Atalay must immediately be registered in the parliament's rolls, released, and allowed to take his oath and do his job." He summed up the ruling this way: "A person goes to court, is found to be right, must be released, but stays in prison because the decision is not implemented."

By Tuesday afternoon in Turkey, 567 Politics could not find a public response to the ruling from the Justice Ministry, the presidency or the governing AKP. The government's position before the court is set out in the judgment.

Several steps could follow. Turkey can ask for the case to be referred to the Grand Chamber within three months. If no referral is granted, the judgment becomes final and goes to the Committee of Ministers, which supervises how states carry out rulings. Atalay remains in prison in Istanbul.

The case lands as other legal fights test how Turkey handles lawmakers' immunity. An immunity file on independent MP Mustafa Sarıgül [is waiting in Ankara](/news/turkey-sarigul-laundering-probe-nine-jailed-immunity-file-november-2026). CHP leader Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu has [urged parliament to lift immunities](/news/turkey-immunity-kilicdaroglu-ozel-yeni-parti-fezleke-leadership-vote-november-2026) in the investment-fund case. Former speaker Bülent Arınç, meanwhile, has [proposed raising judges' retirement age](/news/turkey-arinc-judges-retirement-age-72-yildiz-156-high-court-members-2028-term-limit-november-2026) as many high-court terms near their end.

The Workers' Party has faced other legal pressure this month; prosecutors questioned the wife of its lawmaker Ahmet Şık [in an espionage probe](/news/turkey-yonca-verdioglu-sik-espionage-probe-heinrich-boll-travel-ban-tip-ahmet-sik-november-2026). Rights groups have also gone to Strasbourg over the detention of [Istanbul Mayor Ekrem İmamoğlu](/news/turkey-imamoglu-echr-brief-hrw-icj-tlsp-ibb-trial-witnesses-november-2026), whose own case there is pending.
