FRANCE · 20 ISSUES
The policy choices to watch.
An editorial watchlist for France, rather than a poll of public priorities. The numbers describe policy positions; higher scores do not mean better policies. A politician stays unrated until we can attach dated evidence.
COMPARE THE RECORD
Where do they stand?
Legal immigration & asylum access · 1: Near-total closure of legal entry · 10: Minimal admission limits and broad regularization. Historical positions are dated in each profile; unreviewed positions stay blank.
Each score links to its politician’s evidence and full 10-step rubric. No overall ideological ranking.
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Israeli government: diplomatic & security support
Foreign policy
1 · End diplomatic and security ties
10 · Unconditional diplomatic and security backing
Read all ten definitions
- End diplomatic and security ties
- Diplomatic isolation and broad sanctions
- Maintain ties; suspend military cooperation
- Maintain ties; restrict most arms transfers
- Conditional cooperation and civilian safeguards
- Continue cooperation with targeted restrictions
- Maintain most existing security cooperation
- Expand security cooperation with conditions
- Expand cooperation with few conditions
- Unconditional diplomatic and security backing
Measures policy toward the Israeli government, not attitudes toward Jewish people or Israeli civilians. Diplomatic recognition alone does not establish an arms-policy score.
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Palestinian statehood & self-determination
Foreign policy
1 · Reject Palestinian statehood in principle
10 · Make recognition and full sovereignty a central diplomatic priority
Read all ten definitions
- Reject Palestinian statehood in principle
- Oppose recognition and statehood initiatives
- Defer recognition indefinitely
- Recognition only after a final peace agreement
- Support negotiated statehood with substantial preconditions
- Support negotiated Palestinian statehood in principle
- Support recognition with specified prerequisites
- Support recognition and diplomatic relations now
- Actively pursue recognition and full UN membership
- Make recognition and full sovereignty a central diplomatic priority
Separate from the Israel scale. Support for statehood does not imply support for Hamas or attacks on civilians.
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Civilian firearm access
Domestic law
1 · Prohibit most private firearm ownership
10 · Remove nearly all civilian firearm restrictions
Read all ten definitions
- Prohibit most private firearm ownership
- Allow narrow sporting exceptions only
- Strict licensing and broad weapon restrictions
- Licensing, checks and targeted weapon bans
- Regulated ownership with purchase checks
- Broader ownership with targeted restrictions
- Ease licensing and expand lawful carry
- Permitless carry with limited exclusions
- Repeal most purchase and carry restrictions
- Remove nearly all civilian firearm restrictions
Rates legal access, not concern about public safety. National legal starting points differ.
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Legal abortion access
Reproductive law
1 · Ban abortion without exceptions
10 · No statutory gestational cutoff; clinical decision-making
Read all ten definitions
- Ban abortion without exceptions
- Ban except imminent threat to life
- Allow life, rape and incest exceptions
- Allow broader health exceptions only
- Allow early pregnancy access with substantial limits
- Allow first-trimester access with medical safeguards
- Allow access through an extended gestational period
- Protect access through viability with later medical exceptions
- Remove major procedural and funding barriers
- No statutory gestational cutoff; clinical decision-making
A higher score means broader legal access, not a moral endorsement. Gestation, funding and procedure rules can pull in different directions.
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Legal immigration & asylum access
Migration policy
1 · Near-total closure of legal entry
10 · Minimal admission limits and broad regularization
Read all ten definitions
- Near-total closure of legal entry
- Sharp cuts and offshore-only asylum
- Large admission cuts and narrow asylum
- Lower admissions and tighter eligibility
- Maintain admissions with stricter screening
- Maintain admissions and asylum pathways
- Targeted expansion of lawful pathways
- Broader admission and regularization routes
- Large expansion with strong asylum access
- Minimal admission limits and broad regularization
This axis covers admission and legal status; border enforcement is a separate dimension. No score is inferred from rhetoric alone.
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
European integration
France · EU institutions
1 · Leave the EU and single market
10 · Support a federal European state
Read all ten definitions
- Leave the EU and single market
- Seek an EU-exit referendum
- Reject EU legal primacy broadly
- Demand major national opt-outs
- Remain; resist further integration
- Cooperate within current EU treaties
- Expand shared EU policies
- Expand common fiscal and defense powers
- Transfer major powers to EU institutions
- Support a federal European state
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Birthright citizenship (droit du sol)
France · nationality
1 · End birthright routes entirely
10 · Unconditional territorial birthright citizenship
Read all ten definitions
- End birthright routes entirely
- Naturalization only with strict assimilation tests
- Remove automatic birthright acquisition
- Substantially tighten residence conditions
- Keep routes with added conditions
- Maintain current conditional birthright routes
- Simplify existing birthright applications
- Expand automatic citizenship for resident children
- Citizenship at birth with limited conditions
- Unconditional territorial birthright citizenship
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Citizenship preference in benefits & housing
France · public services
1 · Equal eligibility regardless of nationality or status
10 · Reserve nearly all benefits and public housing for citizens
Read all ten definitions
- Equal eligibility regardless of nationality or status
- Equal eligibility for all lawful residents
- Limit differences to narrow benefits
- Short residency conditions for some benefits
- Maintain existing nationality and residency rules
- Longer residency conditions for selected benefits
- Citizen preference for selected benefits
- Citizen priority in housing and employment
- Broad citizen-only benefits with narrow exceptions
- Reserve nearly all benefits and public housing for citizens
Higher means stronger nationality preference, not better treatment of residents.
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Restrictions on religious expression
France · laïcité
1 · Remove state limits except direct safety risks
10 · Prohibit visible religious expression throughout public life
Read all ten definitions
- Remove state limits except direct safety risks
- Remove most public-space religious restrictions
- Limit neutrality to state officials
- Retain narrow public-school restrictions
- Maintain current secularism framework
- Extend restrictions in selected public institutions
- Broaden limits on visible religious symbols
- Restrict symbols across public-service settings
- Broad restrictions in shared public spaces
- Prohibit visible religious expression throughout public life
Measures restrictions, not a person’s religion or views of any faith.
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Nuclear energy expansion
France · energy
1 · Close all reactors rapidly
10 · Make nuclear dominant with maximum buildout
Read all ten definitions
- Close all reactors rapidly
- Set a binding nuclear phaseout
- Close reactors without replacement
- Reduce nuclear share substantially
- Maintain existing fleet only
- Extend existing reactor lifetimes
- Build selected replacement reactors
- Launch a major new-reactor program
- Expand reactors and advanced nuclear at scale
- Make nuclear dominant with maximum buildout
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Onshore wind expansion
France · energy
1 · Dismantle existing wind farms
10 · Prioritize maximum feasible wind deployment
Read all ten definitions
- Dismantle existing wind farms
- Ban new projects and reduce existing capacity
- Moratorium on new wind construction
- Tighten permits and reduce targets
- Maintain existing deployment policy
- Allow targeted additional projects
- Expand permits and deployment targets
- Major publicly supported wind rollout
- Accelerated large-scale national rollout
- Prioritize maximum feasible wind deployment
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Earlier retirement eligibility
France · pensions
1 · Raise statutory age to 70 or above
10 · General retirement before age 60
Read all ten definitions
- Raise statutory age to 70 or above
- Raise statutory age to 68–69
- Raise statutory age to 66–67
- Retain age 64 with fewer exceptions
- Retain age 64 with existing exceptions
- Add earlier retirement for long careers
- Move toward age 62 with contribution conditions
- Age 60 for long careers; 62 otherwise
- General retirement age of 60
- General retirement before age 60
Contribution years, long-career exceptions and fiscal conditions must accompany the score.
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Cuts to household energy taxes
France · purchasing power
1 · Large increases in household energy taxes
10 · Remove household energy taxes entirely
Read all ten definitions
- Large increases in household energy taxes
- Moderate energy-tax increases
- Small tax increases
- End temporary energy-tax relief
- Maintain current rates
- Targeted relief for vulnerable households
- Small broad reductions
- Large cuts for selected energy types
- Broad reduction toward minimum VAT rates
- Remove household energy taxes entirely
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Public healthcare coverage
Health
1 · End public healthcare coverage
10 · Comprehensive public coverage with no patient charges
Read all ten definitions
- End public healthcare coverage
- Restrict public care to emergencies
- Large cuts to eligibility and benefits
- Target public care to narrower groups
- Maintain current public coverage
- Expand selected public benefits
- Substantial expansion of public eligibility
- Universal basic public coverage
- Universal comprehensive public coverage
- Comprehensive public coverage with no patient charges
Coverage is distinct from public versus private delivery.
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Mandatory & custodial sentencing
France · justice
1 · Replace most custody with restorative alternatives
10 · Maximum custodial terms with virtually no early release
Read all ten definitions
- Replace most custody with restorative alternatives
- Major reduction in prison use
- Remove mandatory minimums; expand alternatives
- Reduce custody for nonviolent offenses
- Maintain current sentencing rules
- Targeted increases for violent crimes
- Expand minimum sentences for repeat offending
- Broad minimum sentences and prison expansion
- Restrict sentence reductions and parole broadly
- Maximum custodial terms with virtually no early release
This describes sentencing policy, not whether a politician is personally lawful.
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Military assistance to Ukraine
France · security
1 · End all military support
10 · Support direct combat deployment alongside Ukraine
Read all ten definitions
- End all military support
- End weapons transfers; diplomacy only
- Defensive nonlethal support only
- Limited defensive weapons; no long-range arms
- Maintain aid with strict use restrictions
- Maintain current military support
- Expand weapons and training
- Expand long-range support with conditions
- Large-scale aid including broad strike permissions
- Support direct combat deployment alongside Ukraine
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Protection of French agriculture
France · agriculture
1 · Remove farm supports and import barriers
10 · Near-total domestic sourcing and major import barriers
Read all ten definitions
- Remove farm supports and import barriers
- Large subsidy cuts and trade opening
- Reduce protections and subsidies
- Limited domestic preference
- Maintain current EU and French protections
- Targeted domestic procurement support
- Expand subsidies and standards-based import controls
- Strong domestic procurement and import limits
- Broad national preference and protected producer prices
- Near-total domestic sourcing and major import barriers
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Tax progressivity
Economy
1 · Flat or regressive taxes; no redistribution
10 · Very high top taxes and extensive redistribution
Read all ten definitions
- Flat or regressive taxes; no redistribution
- Large cuts for highest incomes
- Lower top rates and capital taxes
- Modest cuts to top tax rates
- Maintain current tax distribution
- Modestly raise high-income taxes
- Raise top rates and capital taxes
- Add substantial wealth or inheritance taxes
- Broad wealth taxes and large redistribution
- Very high top taxes and extensive redistribution
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Citizen-initiated referendums
France · institutions
1 · Remove most national referendum mechanisms
10 · Broad binding citizen ballots with minimal thresholds
Read all ten definitions
- Remove most national referendum mechanisms
- Allow only exceptional executive referendums
- Narrow current referendum eligibility
- Tighten initiation thresholds
- Maintain current constitutional referendum rules
- Modestly lower initiation thresholds
- Introduce limited citizen-initiated ballots
- Citizen-initiated legislative referendums
- Binding legislative and constitutional citizen ballots
- Broad binding citizen ballots with minimal thresholds
POLICY SPECTRUM · 1–10
Public & social housing expansion
Housing
1 · Sell most public housing; end new provision
10 · Universal publicly guaranteed housing provision
Read all ten definitions
- Sell most public housing; end new provision
- Large reductions in social housing
- Cut construction and eligibility
- Reduce public construction modestly
- Maintain current social-housing programs
- Expand selected housing schemes
- Increase construction and housing subsidies
- Major social-housing construction program
- Universal access to subsidized housing pathways
- Universal publicly guaranteed housing provision
Placements, evidence dates and primary-source links appear in each politician’s profile.