Rent now, insulate later: France's Assembly debates letting 700,000 drafty homes back on the market
The government says the bill keeps about 700,000 F- and G-rated homes rentable by 2028. Tenant groups object, and Philippe pledges four million homes.

France's National Assembly began debating the government's housing bill on Monday, November 16. Its most disputed measure would let owners keep renting homes rated F or G for energy use, the two worst grades, if they sign up to renovate them. The government says the change would keep or put back about 700,000 homes on the rental market by 2028. Tenant groups and the left say it would leave poor households in cold, costly flats for years.
The bill also widens a tax break for private landlords, speeds up planning rules and launches a third urban renewal program. Deputies have filed more than 1,100 amendments. Debate is set to run through Friday, with a formal vote on Tuesday, November 24, AFP reported via France 24. The debate opened a day after Édouard Philippe, a 2027 presidential candidate, promised four million more homes in ten years. Quotes from French-language sources are 567politics translations.

What the bill would change#
The text is formally titled the bill "for the revival and decentralization of housing." Housing Minister Vincent Jeanbrun tabled it in the Senate on June 25, 2026, under the fast-track procedure, according to the Senate's legislative file. Fast-track means one reading in each chamber. After the Assembly votes, a joint committee of seven deputies and seven senators will try to agree on one text. The government hopes for final adoption before the end of the year, AFP reported.
The Assembly's agenda page lists the first reading from Monday, November 16, to Friday, November 20. The Assembly's legislative file shows the Senate adopted the bill on July 8. The Socialist, Communist and Ecologist groups voted against it, Banque des Territoires reported.
- Bill tabled in the Senate under the fast-track procedure
- Senate adopts it; Socialists, Communists and Ecologists vote against
- Assembly committee report filed after 70 amendments
- Assembly floor debate opens
- Formal Assembly vote scheduled
Source: Senate legislative file
The main measures are:
- Rentals of poorly insulated homes. Homes rated G have been barred from new leases since 2025. F-rated homes are due to follow in 2028 and E-rated homes in 2034. The bill would let owners keep renting if they commit to works: within three years for a house and five years in a shared building, franceinfo reported.
- The "Jeanbrun" tax break. Created in the 2026 budget to replace the older Pinel scheme, it lets private landlords write down the cost of a rental home over time. The bill would widen it.
- Faster planning. A new "operation of local interest" would let towns, with the prefect's approval, waive parts of their land-use plan to build faster.
- Urban renewal. A third national program for poorer neighborhoods would get €5 billion for 2026 to 2040, according to Banque des Territoires.
- More power for local councils. Groups of towns could become "housing authorities" that run local policy.
The government also filed an amendment for a fast-track rebuilding regime after disasters. AFP said the government cited this summer's fires, Cyclone Chido in Mayotte in late 2024 and the destruction of Limoges city hall during the October 17 protests.
Why the government wants it#
Jeanbrun calls the situation "the worst housing crisis our country has known since the Second World War," AFP reported. Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu wrote on X on Monday that "housing is the first fixed expense for millions of families. To fight the high cost of living, we must build more, renovate and put homes back on the market," according to AFP.

Jeanbrun set out the case in the Senate on July 7, according to the official record. "We do not produce enough if we do not mobilize investment. We do not build fast enough if we do not simplify procedures," he said. He told senators that 700,000 homes would be hit by rental bans tied to energy ratings "by the end of next year."
His answer is to let owners rent while they renovate. An owner who signs with a builder and pays a deposit could rent again, so rent could help pay for the works. "To a wave of bans, I prefer a wave of renovations," he said. "Banning is easy. Renovating takes courage."
Building firms back speed. The Alliance pour le logement, which groups the main industry federations, called for "rapid adoption" to give the sector "visibility," AFP reported. AFP said the industry agrees on easing building rules and backs the renewal program, though not on every measure.
How far construction has fallen#
The bill arrives after a steep fall in building. France started about 434,000 homes in 2017. It started about 258,000 in 2024 and about 265,000 in 2025, according to INSEE's series of housing starts, built from the ministry's Sitadel2 permit database.
Source: INSEE, from SDES Sitadel2
Show the numbers
| Year | Homes started (thousands) |
|---|---|
| 2017 | 433.9 |
| 2018 | 400.5 |
| 2019 | 385.4 |
| 2020 | 369.6 |
| 2021 | 412.6 |
| 2022 | 388.4 |
| 2023 | 295.9 |
| 2024 | 258.1 |
| 2025 | 264.8 |
Permits have started to recover. The ministry's statistics service says 379,222 homes were authorized in 2025, up 15% on 2024 but 8.8% below the average of the five years before. A permit is not a start, and many authorized projects are delayed or dropped.
These figures count new homes. They do not measure how many existing homes left the rental market because of the energy rules. The 700,000 figure is the government's own estimate, and no independent count was found.
What deputies already rewrote#
The Assembly is debating the text of its economic affairs committee, not the Senate's. The committee adopted 70 of 744 amendments in September, NosParlementaires counted. The rapporteur is Annaïg Le Meur, a deputy from President Macron's EPR group. She had said the Senate went "too far in derogations" from renovation rules "and in the powers given to mayors," AFP reported.
Source: NosParlementaires, from Assembly data
Show the numbers
| Group | Amendments adopted |
|---|---|
| EPR (Macron's group) | 12 |
| LIOT | 9 |
| MoDem | 5 |
| Droite républicaine | 5 |
| Ecologists | 4 |
| Socialists | 4 |
| La France insoumise | 3 |
| Horizons | 3 |
| National Rally | 0 |
| GDR (Communists and overseas) | 0 |
The committee changed four areas:
- Mayors and social housing. The Senate gave mayors a "reasoned veto" over who gets social housing. The committee deleted most of that article. Amendment CE184 by Pierre Cordier of the Droite républicaine group argued the choice "must remain based on a collegial procedure."
- Ordinances. It struck an article that let the government rewrite planning rules by decree. The Ecologist group's amendment CE466 said "simplification" often hides "a logic of unpicking environmental protections." An identical amendment came from La France insoumise.
- The tax break. It set a rule that renovation works must equal 20% of the purchase price for an older home to qualify. Current law requires 30%, and the Senate had dropped any threshold. It also closed the Senate's change that let owners rent the home to their own children or parents.
- The rental exemption. It capped the delay allowed when a building's co-owners refuse works at three years after the first refusal. Owners who cite a works contract must prove they paid a 30% deposit. A tenant who blocks works could no longer claim the home is unfit.
No amendment from the National Rally (RN) was adopted, even though the RN filed the most, 134, NosParlementaires reported. The committee rejected 34 RN amendments on the rental rules. They sought to delay or repeal the bans. One of them, CE36, called the French timetable "one of the most coercive schemes in Europe" and said EU law does not require it. It proposed pushing the deadlines back so that "the majority that emerges from the 2027 elections" can decide whether to keep, reform or scrap them.
Tenant groups and the left object#
On Monday afternoon, the Plateforme logement pour tou.te.s called a rally near the Assembly. The coalition includes tenant unions such as the CNL, the CGL and the DAL, and the Solidaires union. Its call to protest says the bill "attacks working-class neighborhoods, social housing tenants, tenants of thermal sieves and the poorly housed." It calls the tax break "tax gifts to the rich and to speculators" in place of funding social housing. The group wants lower rents, higher housing benefits and much more low-rent social housing.
Some anti-poverty groups want tenants paid back while they wait. Manuel Domergue, research director at the Fondation pour le logement des défavorisés, told France 2 last spring that the tenant of a home that fails the decency rules should get a rent cut, "for example of 30%."
Left-wing senators made similar points in July. "You refuse to subject landlords to the slightest constraint," Communist senator Ian Brossat said, according to Banque des Territoires. "They will be able to keep renting thermal sieves and boilers, while tenants are left to pay, endure and keep quiet." On the mayors' veto, Ecologist senator Yannick Jadot warned: "From local preference, we risk moving to national preference."
- G-rated homes barred from new leases
- F-rated homes due to be barred
- E-rated homes due to be barred
Source: Assembly amendment CE36, citing the Climate and Resilience law
The candidates' plans#
The bill comes months before the 2027 presidential election, and several candidates have their own housing plans.
In an interview with Le Parisien on Sunday, Philippe said that "the worst enemy of the purchasing power of the French today is housing," franceinfo reported. The Horizons leader wants to "build more and rent much more," with "simplified standards and favorable taxes." He aims for four million more homes in ten years. Reports differ on whether that means four million in total or four million above current levels. Four hundred thousand homes a year would be close to the level of 2018 and well above 2025.
Philippe would also abolish "the taxes we call notary fees" for buyers under 35, offer a zero-rate loan with each new child and pay a family allowance of about €350 a month from the first child. As BFMTV noted, most of those fees are taxes paid to the state, départements and towns. As prime minister, rival candidate Gabriel Attal had backed scrapping the fees for first-time buyers of homes up to €250,000. Lecornu's 2027 budget already widens the zero-rate loan to families expecting a child, BFMTV said. The budget itself remains stalled, with the Assembly having rejected its revenue section. Philippe's campaign gave no cost for the plan in the reports reviewed.
Marine Le Pen, the RN candidate, set out her housing plan in September. She would give French citizens "priority access to social housing" and reserve housing benefits for them, 20 Minutes reported. She would repeal the SRU law, which requires many towns to have a share of social housing. She would also scrap the "zero net land take" rule and end what she called the "absurd policy" of energy ratings that set a home's value. Emmanuelle Cosse, who speaks for the social landlords' federation USH, called the citizens-first plan a "xenophobic whim," 20 Minutes reported. "Foreigners are not favored in entering social housing," she said. The USH says foreign households make up 15% of social housing tenants.
What comes next#
- Assembly voteformal vote on the whole bill, set for November 24
- Joint committeeseven deputies and seven senators seek one text
- Final votesboth chambers vote on the agreed text, which the government hopes to finish by year end
The floor session opened at 4 p.m. Paris time on Monday and resumes Wednesday, NosParlementaires reported. The rental exemption, Article 6, and the tax break, Article 4, drew the most amendments. Some 25 floor amendments seek to restore renting to family members. Any measure the committee removed, such as the mayors' veto, returns only if deputies vote it back in.
Several questions remain open. The government has not published an independent estimate of how many owners would take up the renovation route. It is also unclear how the state would check that promised works get done. And the joint committee will have to reconcile a Senate text that gave mayors more power with an Assembly text that took most of it away.
Differing perspectives
Should France let owners keep renting F- and G-rated homes if they commit to renovation work?
Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.
Keep the bans on schedule and protect tenants
Who holds it: The Plateforme logement pour tou.te.s coalition, including tenant unions CNL, CGL and DAL and the Solidaires union, and left-wing groups in Parliament
Tenant groups argue that the people living in these homes are often the poorest households, who pay the highest energy bills and have the least power to demand repairs. Delaying the bans shifts the cost of the climate rules from owners to tenants. They say the bill hands tax breaks to investors instead of funding low-rent social housing, raising housing benefits and lowering rents, which they see as the real answers to a crisis of expensive housing.
In their words: Plateforme logement pour tou.te.s, call to rally on November 16 ↗
Let owners rent while they renovate
Who holds it: Housing Minister Vincent Jeanbrun, Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu's government and the Senate's center-right majority
The government argues that rental bans tied to energy ratings are pushing about 700,000 homes off the market just as renters struggle to find anything. Owners who cannot rent lose the income that would pay for insulation, so the home stays both empty and cold. Letting an owner rent once a builder is hired and a deposit paid keeps families housed, funds the works and gives tradespeople steady jobs. In the minister's words, a wave of renovations beats a wave of bans.
In their words: French Senate, official record of the July 7, 2026 sitting ↗
Postpone the bans until after the 2027 election
Who holds it: National Rally deputies on the Assembly's economic affairs committee
RN deputies argue that France chose one of Europe's strictest timetables, which EU law does not require. They cite surveys in which most landlords in shared buildings want a delay and find the remaining costs and paperwork too heavy, and say some owners will sell or stop renting. They add that the energy rating ignores summer heat. They want the deadlines pushed back so the majority elected in 2027 can decide whether to keep, reform or scrap them.
In their words: National Assembly, amendment CE36 to bill no. 3058 ↗
Cite this article
567 Politics staff. “Rent now, insulate later: France's Assembly debates letting 700,000 drafty homes back on the market.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-16. https://567politics.com/news/france-housing-bill-jeanbrun-assembly-f-g-rated-rentals-700000-philippe-four-million-homes-november-2026
Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Rent now, insulate later: France's Assembly debates letting 700,000 drafty homes back on the market |url=https://567politics.com/news/france-housing-bill-jeanbrun-assembly-f-g-rated-rentals-700000-philippe-four-million-homes-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-16 |language=en}}CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
"id": "https://567politics.com/news/france-housing-bill-jeanbrun-assembly-f-g-rated-rentals-700000-philippe-four-million-homes-november-2026",
"type": "article-newspaper",
"title": "Rent now, insulate later: France's Assembly debates letting 700,000 drafty homes back on the market",
"URL": "https://567politics.com/news/france-housing-bill-jeanbrun-assembly-f-g-rated-rentals-700000-philippe-four-million-homes-november-2026",
"container-title": "567politics",
"language": "en",
"author": [
{
"literal": "567 Politics staff"
}
],
"issued": {
"date-parts": [
[
2026,
11,
16
]
]
}
}Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.
Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.
Embed this article summary
Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.
<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/france-housing-bill-jeanbrun-assembly-f-g-rated-rentals-700000-philippe-four-million-homes-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Rent now, insulate later: France's Assembly debates letting 700,000 drafty homes back on the market by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe> <p style="font-size:14px">Rent now, insulate later: France's Assembly debates letting 700,000 drafty homes back on the market by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/france-housing-bill-jeanbrun-assembly-f-g-rated-rentals-700000-philippe-four-million-homes-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p> <script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
READ BEYOND 567POLITICS
Alternate sources & perspectives
Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.
- primary evidence
Projet de loi visant la relance et la décentralisation du logement — dossier législatif ↗
Sénat
Official record of the bill's path: tabled June 25, 2026 under the fast-track procedure, adopted by the Senate July 8, sent to the Assembly July 9, committee report no. 3188 filed Sept. 23.
- primary evidence
La relance et la décentralisation du logement — dossier législatif ↗
Assemblée nationale
The Assembly's file listing the Senate-adopted text no. 3058, Annaïg Le Meur's report and the committee text now on the floor.
- primary evidence
Examen du projet de loi visant la relance et la décentralisation du logement ↗
Assemblée nationale
Official agenda notice: first-reading floor debate from Monday Nov. 16 to Friday Nov. 20, 2026.
- other perspective
Compte rendu intégral de la séance du 7 juillet 2026 ↗
Sénat
Housing Minister Vincent Jeanbrun's opening speech, including the 700,000-home estimate and his case for letting owners rent while they renovate.
- right argument
Amendement n° CE36 au projet de loi n° 3058 ↗
Assemblée nationale
Rejected committee amendment to postpone the F-, G- and E-rating rental bans until after the 2027 elections; the exposé sets out the argument that France's timetable is among Europe's strictest.
- left argument
Le projet de loi logement attaque les quartiers populaires… — appel au rassemblement du 16 novembre ↗
Plateforme logement pour tou.te.s (via Union syndicale Solidaires)
The tenant-union coalition's case against the bill and its demands for lower rents, higher housing benefits and more low-rent social housing.
- independent analysis
Crise du logement : le projet de loi examiné à l'Assemblée nationale ↗
France 24 / AFP
Wire account of the opening day: 1,100-plus amendments, Nov. 24 vote, Lecornu's X post, the rapporteur's concerns and industry and tenant-group reactions.
- independent analysis
Projet de loi logement : ce que les députés ont réécrit avant la séance ↗
NosParlementaires
Data-based count of the 70 committee amendments adopted out of 744, by group, and of what changed on mayors' powers, ordinances, the Jeanbrun tax break and the rental exemption.
- independent analysis
Le Sénat adopte le projet de loi Logement et donne du pouvoir aux maires ↗
Banque des Territoires
Detailed account of the July Senate debate, with quotes from the minister, rapporteurs and left-wing opponents, and the list of Senate amendments.
- primary evidence
Logements mis en chantier — données annuelles de 2000 à 2025 ↗
INSEE (data from SDES, Sitadel2)
Official annual series of housing starts, the basis for the chart; provisional estimates as of end-May 2026.
- other perspective
Présidentielle 2027 : Edouard Philippe veut bâtir quatre millions de logements supplémentaires en dix ans ↗
franceinfo / AFP
Philippe's housing and family proposals from his Nov. 15 Le Parisien interview, quoted at length.
- right argument
Présidentielle 2027 : Marine Le Pen veut mettre la « priorité nationale » au cœur de sa politique de logement ↗
20 Minutes
Le Pen's September housing program: priority for French citizens in social housing, repeal of the SRU law and the end of rating-based rental rules.
Reviewed 2026-11-16. Hand-picked from pages opened in full on Nov. 16, 2026: Senate and Assembly legislative files and records, the tenant coalition's own call, an RN committee amendment, INSEE housing data, wire and independent parliamentary reporting, and two candidates' housing proposals. discover_politics_sources returned only generic France pages, none used.