Skip to content
567politics.

Germany

Germans rush to secure care grades before stricter rules: assessment requests up 20% in October

The Medical Services logged 419,000 requests as a Linnemann bill would tighten grades 1 to 3 from January. The care commissioner says the filing date counts.

By 567 Politics staffPublished 9 min read

The Haus St. Ulrich retirement and nursing home, run by Caritas, in the Mönchfeld district of Stuttgart, Baden-Württemberg, in December 2023.
The Haus St. Ulrich retirement and nursing home, run by Caritas, in the Mönchfeld district of Stuttgart, Baden-Württemberg, in December 2023. · Photo: MSeses via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 ↗

Requests for official care assessments in Germany jumped by a fifth in October, and early figures show the rush speeding up in November. People in need of care are trying to get a care grade before stricter rules take effect on January 1, 2027. The data come from the federal association of the Medical Services, the bodies that assess whether someone qualifies for long-term care insurance. They were released to the Augsburger Allgemeine, which published them early on Tuesday, November 17, German time.

The Medical Services received 419,000 requests for care assessments nationwide in October, the paper reported. That is 20 percent, or 69,000 cases, more than a year earlier. The Medical Service in Bavaria warned of longer waits. It said the rise "goes beyond the expected scale" and probably cannot be fully absorbed even with extra staff.

The rush follows a bill from Health Minister Carsten Linnemann of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU). It would make it harder to qualify for the three lowest of Germany's five care grades. The federal government's own care commissioner, Katrin Staffler of the Christian Social Union (CSU), said the day a person applies is what counts. "Anyone who files their application in 2026 will be assessed under the previous criteria, even if the assessment only takes place in 2027," she told the paper.

Care assessment requests received by Germany's Medical Services in OctoberNationwide requests in the month. The October 2025 figure is derived from the reported October 2026 total and its reported rise of 69,000.

Source: Augsburger Allgemeine, tagesschau

Show the numbers
MonthRequests
October 2025350,000
October 2026419,000
Share this chartPost

The surge, state by state#

The pace differs by state, but the direction is the same, the Augsburger Allgemeine reported. In Bavaria, 50,000 people asked for an assessment in October. That was 13 percent more than the roughly 44,300 in September. In the first two weeks of November, requests were a third above the average of recent months.

Baden-Württemberg recorded 45,000 requests in October, a record and 17 percent more than a year earlier. Hesse reported a 46 percent rise in November so far, the paper said.

An assessment is the step that decides whether someone gets a care grade at all. The grade sets how much money and help a person receives from long-term care insurance. Not every request succeeds. In Bavaria, more than one in four first applications is turned down, the paper reported.

Claudia Wöhler, who heads the Medical Service in Bavaria, urged people to seek care advice before they apply. Such advice "can help to better assess the individual situation," she said. It can show whether a person already has limits on their independence that count under the law.

How a care grade is set today#

Under Section 15 of the Social Code, Book XI, an assessor scores how independent a person still is in six areas. The areas are mobility; mental and communication skills; behavior and psychological problems; self-care, such as washing, dressing and eating; coping with the demands of an illness or treatment; and organizing daily life and social contacts. Self-care carries the most weight, at 40 percent. Mental skills and behavior count together for 15 percent, with only the higher of the two scores used.

The weighted points are added up to a total between 0 and 100. That total decides the grade. A person needs at least 12.5 points for grade 1, which brings limited benefits. Grade 2 starts at 27 points, grade 3 at 47.5, grade 4 at 70 and grade 5 at 90. The bill would change how points are scored so that grades 1 to 3 are harder to reach.

Points needed for each care grade under current lawMinimum total points out of 100 for adults under Section 15 of Book XI of the Social Code. The reform would change the scoring for grades 1 to 3.

Source: Social Code, Book XI, Section 15

Show the numbers
GradeMinimum points
Grade 112.5
Grade 227
Grade 347.5
Grade 470
Grade 590
Share this chartPost

What the bill would change#

The cabinet approved the bill, the Care Reorganization Act (Pflegeneuordnungsgesetz), on September 30. The Bundestag held its first debate on November 5. The bill is now before the health committee, and a final vote is expected in mid-December. 567 Politics covered that first debate and the coalition's promise to make changes.

In its announcement, the Health Ministry said the bill would put care insurance "back on a more stable financial footing." It said the rules for assessments would be adjusted toward the values that scientists first recommended, so that grades 1 to 3 are "awarded more precisely." People who already have a care grade keep it. A new scientific advisory board is to review the assessment tool over time.

A ministry explanation of the measures, dated June 4, 2026, sets out the reasoning. Germany changed how it defines the need for care on January 1, 2017, partly to cover more people with dementia. In passing that law, the paper says, lawmakers departed from the scoring that an expert panel had recommended. Since then, it says, the yearly number of people needing care has been "well above the values actually expected." It now exceeds 6 million.

The ministry document estimates the savings from the assessment change alone. They rise from 1.3 billion euros in 2027 to 4.2 billion euros in 2030. The cabinet version may differ in detail from the June paper.

Projected savings from stricter care assessmentsBillions of euros a year, as estimated in the Health Ministry's explanation of the draft dated June 4, 2026. Later changes to the bill may alter these figures.

Source: Federal Ministry of Health

Show the numbers
YearSavings
20271.3
20282.5
20293.4
20304.2
Share this chartPost

The bill also changes benefits. The relief payment of up to 131 euros a month for people in grade 1 is to end, tagesschau reported. So is respite care as a separate benefit. Families can use that benefit when the relative who usually provides care cannot. The ministry says home-care benefits in grades 2 to 5 will be combined into new budgets and raised. A "social space budget" replaces the old relief payment from grade 2.

On the revenue side, the surcharge paid by childless members rises by 0.3 points to 0.9 percent in January 2027. The income ceiling for contributions rises by 300 euros a month. From 2028, a 0.52 percent surcharge would apply for covering a spouse or partner, with exceptions.

The Haus St. Ulrich retirement and nursing home, run by Caritas, in the Mönchfeld district of Stuttgart, Baden-Württemberg, in December 2023.

Why the fund is under pressure#

The number of people drawing benefits has more than doubled in a decade. About 2.6 million people got help from long-term care insurance in 2015, tagesschau reported. In 2025 it was more than 6 million. The federal government lent the fund 500 million euros in 2025 and 3.2 billion euros in 2026 as emergency support, the broadcaster said.

Federal loans to long-term care insuranceBillions of euros, emergency loans from the federal budget as reported by tagesschau.

Source: tagesschau

Show the numbers
YearLoans
20250.5
20263.2
Share this chartPost

Linnemann presents the bill as a first step. "Supporting people in need of care and their relatives is a central task of our community of solidarity," he said in the ministry's announcement. "So that we can fulfill it today and in the future, we must reform the system of social long-term care insurance." He said the pension contributions paid for family carers would not be cut. A separate commission is to propose deeper changes.

A run on the old rules, and calls to slow down#

The rush did not come out of nowhere. Several groups openly urged people to apply before the new year. The Social Association VdK, which says it has 2.3 million members, called on members who have no care grade to file a first application by December 31. "Hesitating is exactly the wrong way now," said its president, Verena Bentele. The VdK warned people who already have a grade to think hard before asking for a higher one, because a review can also lead to a lower grade. Heinz Rothgang, a care expert at the University of Bremen, had also advised people to apply by the end of the year, the Augsburger Allgemeine reported.

The VdK estimated when the draft was first published that under the new rules about 120,000 fewer people a year would get a care grade. Another 155,000 would be placed in a lower grade, it said. "The fact that the need for care is denied on paper changes nothing about the actual need for care," Bentele said.

Staffler, the care commissioner, has asked for longer transition periods. "It cannot be that the Bundestag passes a law, probably in mid-December, and people in need of care, their relatives and home-care services then have only two weeks to adjust," she told the Schwäbische Zeitung. Tagesschau carried the quote. She told the Augsburger Allgemeine that care must not be disrupted "despite the tight timetable."

Inside the coalition, the Social Democrats (SPD) want changes too. Christos Pantazis is the SPD parliamentary group's health spokesperson. He said the fund's problems must not be solved solely at the expense of people in need of care and their relatives, the trade journal Häusliche Pflege reported, citing dpa. Two SPD state premiers, Manuela Schwesig of Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania and Anke Rehlinger of Saarland, have asked the federal government to revise the bill, the journal reported in October.

The Greens oppose the cuts. "They are cutting benefits and still not solving the funding problem," the party's care spokesperson, Simone Fischer, told rbb24 Inforadio on the day of the first debate. She said the fund would still be short by more than a billion euros next year. She wants the federal government to repay pandemic costs to the fund and to share costs with private care insurance. In the long run, she said, Germany needs a care insurance "into which everyone pays according to their financial means."

The care reform and the deadline for applications
  1. January 1, 2017Germany adopts its current definition of the need for care
  2. June 2026Government presents its draft care reform
  3. September 30, 2026Cabinet approves the bill
  4. October 2026Care assessment requests reach 419,000, up 20 percent
  5. November 5, 2026First Bundestag debate
  6. Mid-December 2026Final Bundestag vote expected
  7. December 31, 2026Last day to apply under current rules, per the care commissioner
  8. January 1, 2027Stricter assessment rules due to take effect

Source: Federal Ministry of Health, tagesschau, Augsburger Allgemeine

The weeks ahead#

For now, the bill is in the health committee. Changes there could affect the transition rules, the end of the grade 1 relief payment and the fate of respite care. The Medical Services say they will keep extra staff on hand. But with requests still rising, people who apply in the last weeks of the year may wait well into 2027 for their assessment. Under Staffler's reading of the bill, they would still be judged by the old rules.

Differing perspectives

Should Germany tighten access to the lower care grades from January 2027 to stabilize long-term care insurance?

Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.

  • Allow longer transition periods

    Who holds it: Katrin Staffler (CSU), the federal government's commissioner for care

    Staffler, the federal care commissioner, says people who file an application in 2026 will be assessed under the old criteria even if the assessment comes in 2027. She argues the timetable is too tight. If the Bundestag passes the law in mid-December, families and home-care services would have only two weeks to adjust. She wants reliable and sufficient transition periods written into the bill so that care is not disrupted.

    In their words: Augsburger Allgemeine interview with Katrin Staffler ↗

  • Do not raise the bar for care grades

    Who holds it: Social Association VdK and its president, Verena Bentele

    The VdK says raising the thresholds for grades 1 to 3 would leave about 120,000 people a year without a care grade and push another 155,000 into a lower one. It argues that denying the need for care on paper does not make that need go away. Instead it wants society-wide costs, such as pandemic spending and carers' pension contributions, paid back from taxes. It also wants cost sharing with private care insurance on the way to a single insurance that everyone pays into.

    In their words: Sozialverband VdK Deutschland ↗

  • Fix the funding instead of cutting benefits

    Who holds it: The Greens, through their care spokesperson Simone Fischer

    Fischer, the Greens' care spokesperson, argues the government is cutting benefits without solving the funding problem, since the fund would still be short by more than a billion euros next year. She wants the federal government to repay pandemic costs to the fund and to share costs with private care insurance. In the long run she wants a care insurance into which everyone pays according to their means, including lawmakers, civil servants and people with high rental and investment income.

    In their words: rbb24 Inforadio interview with Simone Fischer ↗

  • Tighten the scoring to stabilize the fund

    Who holds it: Health Minister Carsten Linnemann (CDU) and the Federal Ministry of Health

    The Health Ministry says long-term care insurance must be reformed so it can keep supporting people in need of care and their families. Since the 2017 change in how need is defined, the number of people with a care grade has been well above expected values and now tops 6 million. Bringing the scoring back toward the values scientists first recommended would award grades 1 to 3 more precisely and save billions a year. People who already have a grade keep it, and home-care benefits in grades 2 to 5 rise.

    In their words: Federal Ministry of Health ↗

Cite this article

567 Politics staff. “Germans rush to secure care grades before stricter rules: assessment requests up 20% in October.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-17. https://567politics.com/news/germany-care-assessment-requests-surge-419000-october-pflegeneuordnungsgesetz-staffler-linnemann-november-2026

Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Germans rush to secure care grades before stricter rules: assessment requests up 20% in October |url=https://567politics.com/news/germany-care-assessment-requests-surge-419000-october-pflegeneuordnungsgesetz-staffler-linnemann-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-17 |language=en}}
CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
  "id": "https://567politics.com/news/germany-care-assessment-requests-surge-419000-october-pflegeneuordnungsgesetz-staffler-linnemann-november-2026",
  "type": "article-newspaper",
  "title": "Germans rush to secure care grades before stricter rules: assessment requests up 20% in October",
  "URL": "https://567politics.com/news/germany-care-assessment-requests-surge-419000-october-pflegeneuordnungsgesetz-staffler-linnemann-november-2026",
  "container-title": "567politics",
  "language": "en",
  "author": [
    {
      "literal": "567 Politics staff"
    }
  ],
  "issued": {
    "date-parts": [
      [
        2026,
        11,
        17
      ]
    ]
  }
}

Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.

Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.

Embed this article summary

Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.

<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/germany-care-assessment-requests-surge-419000-october-pflegeneuordnungsgesetz-staffler-linnemann-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Germans rush to secure care grades before stricter rules: assessment requests up 20% in October by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:14px">Germans rush to secure care grades before stricter rules: assessment requests up 20% in October by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/germany-care-assessment-requests-surge-419000-october-pflegeneuordnungsgesetz-staffler-linnemann-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p>
<script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>

READ BEYOND 567POLITICS

Alternate sources & perspectives

Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.

Reviewed 2026-11-17. Compiled 2026-11-17 from pages opened and read in full. discover_politics_sources returned only general explainers from insurers and care-advice sites, so every source was chosen by hand. German-language sources are labeled. The October and November assessment figures come from the federal association of the Medical Services as released to the Augsburger Allgemeine; 567 Politics did not find a public Medical Services release with the same numbers. The ministry's savings estimates come from its June 4, 2026 explanation of the draft and may differ from the cabinet version. The VdK impact estimate was made on the June draft. No on-record AfD or Left Party reaction to the new figures was found.

All 567politics news →