Skip to content
567politics.

Israel

At first draft-law hearing, Liberman says no framework exists as reservists and Haredi lawmakers balk

A reservist accused the new committee chair of dropping his core cause. UTJ figures said Yashar!'s plan for 90,000 draft evaders would not pass their rabbis.

By 567 Politics staffPublished 9 min read

Avigdor Liberman, now chairman of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, speaks at a rally in Haifa in March 2023. Photo: Hanay, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Avigdor Liberman, now chairman of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, speaks at a rally in Haifa in March 2023. Photo: Hanay, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. · Photo: Hanay via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0) ↗

Avigdor Liberman, now chairman of the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, speaks at a rally in Haifa in March 2023. Photo: Hanay, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Avigdor Liberman opened his first debate on a new military draft law on Tuesday by telling the Knesset's Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee that no plan yet exists. "There is currently no framework," he said, a day after he was named the committee's chairman. "Everyone is rushing to criticize the new framework. I'm not aware of any framework. Right now it simply doesn't exist."

His remarks, reported by JFeed, came hours after Ynet published details of a plan from Gadi Eisenkot's Yashar! party. The plan would clear the records of about 90,000 ultra-Orthodox, or Haredi, men whom the army lists as draft evaders. The session drew sharp words from a reservist who said Liberman had dropped his signature cause. Haredi lawmakers, for their part, said the plan would not win their rabbis' approval.

The draft is the hardest issue standing between Eisenkot and a majority. His bloc can pass procedural votes with support from Arab parties, but the two Haredi parties hold 13 seats that could give him a stable coalition. Their price is a law that protects full-time yeshiva study. Reservist groups, and parties inside his own bloc, have campaigned for the opposite.

A reservist confronts the chairman#

Yitzhaki Glick of the El HaDegel reservists' movement asked to speak at the start of the session. "I think the committee chairman also knows that there is no law that will pass both Rabbi Landau and the High Court of Justice," he said, according to JFeed. He was referring to Rabbi Dov Landau, a senior leader of the non-Hasidic Haredi community. "The truth is that the State of Israel has no time on this issue. This issue has been rolling along for thirty years."

He then turned to Liberman, whose Yisrael Beytenu party has campaigned for years on drafting Haredi men. "You, honorable chairman, were the voice that carried this banner and was not willing to make any compromises on this issue. And the moment power reaches your hands, this is the first issue you give up on," Glick said.

Glick said reservists had long been told that Benjamin Netanyahu had to be removed because he was advancing a "draft-evasion law." He said the new bloc was now doing the same. "You are lying to the public: 100 percent for those who serve, zero percent for draft dodgers," he said. "You are advancing a draft-evasion law, or concessions that will mean we have to extend our reserve duty."

Haredi men protest outside a Tel Aviv detention facility in May 2024 after a yeshiva student was arrested at a demonstration against compulsory military service. Photo: Nizzan Cohen, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Liberman: 'The ruling of the public'#

Liberman answered by pointing to the election result. "The most important ruling is the ruling of the public," he said. "Unfortunately, the entire change bloc, with all the push for those who serve and all our desire to lead a maximalist law, we received 40 percent of the entire Israeli public. Sixty percent of the Israeli public did not support us."

He said any law would have to clear three hurdles, and that the first was the army's chief of staff. "The chief of staff must approve that the law meets the IDF's needs," Liberman said. He recalled a bill he submitted in 2018. "I didn't touch it. I gave it to the chief of staff at the time, Gadi Eisenkot, and said: Gadi, you draft the law that will meet the IDF's requirements. And only after that the High Court and everything else."

On Monday, Liberman had named the third hurdle. It would be a law "that will pass the chief of staff, the High Court and Rabbi Landau," he said then, as 567 Politics reported in its story on the Yashar! plan. He added: "It will not be a draft for everyone, but the fairest law."

On Tuesday he described the committee's work as an early survey. "We, as always, are trying to approach this thoroughly, to map all the problems, so we are currently at the mapping stage," he said.

Yair Golan of the Democrats urged the bloc to move. "First of all, we have a majority and we need to use it," he said. "Even a law won't produce masses of combat soldiers tomorrow. If we want to reduce the burden on reservists immediately, we need to start closing fronts."

What the Yashar! plan proposes#

Yashar! lawmakers Inbar Giti and Elazar Stern presented the plan to partners in Eisenkot's bloc, Ynet reported. It targets what the army calls the "pool," about 90,000 Haredi men over 18 who already face desertion or evasion proceedings. Men in the pool cannot leave the country, which puts heavy pressure on Haredi lawmakers.

Under the plan, those men would have their status reset and get several months to settle it with the army through one of three tracks set by age. Men aged 26 and over would be exempt. Others would defer service for a time and then enlist, or serve in a short reserve track guarding border communities. A quota of up to 3 percent of each year's recruits would be exempt as top yeshiva scholars. Men who fail to sign up would face personal sanctions under a new law.

Liberman told his party on Monday that he is not leading the talks with the Haredi parties, Ynet reported. He said Eisenkot is handling them for the whole bloc.

The draft fight in the new Knesset
  1. Liberman submits a draft bill written to the army's requirements
  2. Mandatory service for new conscripts is cut to 30 months
  3. Liberman becomes interim committee chairman; Zamir says the army is short of combat soldiers
  4. Ynet publishes the Yashar! plan; Liberman holds the first draft debate and says no framework exists
  5. Shas and UTJ back Likud's Ofir Katz in the speaker vote

Source: JFeed, Ynet, Ynet

Haredi parties: not good enough#

The plan stirred strong reactions inside United Torah Judaism, Ynet reported on Tuesday. One party source said dealing with Liberman was easier. "We feel that it is simpler to reach understandings with Liberman on the draft law than with Eisenkot," the source told Ynet.

Several Haredi officials said the plan would not pass their rabbis, who want any young man who wishes to study Torah to keep doing so, without enlistment targets or sanctions. A lawmaker from Agudat Yisrael, one of UTJ's two factions, told journalist Yishai Cohen that the plan "will not pass the Council of Torah Sages, and we will vote against it and against such a government." He added: "We said we would support regulating the status of yeshiva students, and this is the opposite of regulation."

UTJ's official response went further. "We are not familiar with any framework by Giti and Stern. Such a framework was not presented to us, and neither was any other framework on the subject," the party said. Its chairman, Yaakov Asher, said in an interview on Monday that talks are taking place but that no drafts have been exchanged, Ynet reported.

Others in the debate pushed from the opposite side. "There is not a single politician in the State of Israel who wants to see 30,000 Haredim sitting in prison," Democrats lawmaker Gilad Kariv told Reshet Bet radio. "We also don't want to destroy the Torah world or close the yeshivas." The question, he said, "is not whether Eisenkot or Liberman will change, but whether Yaakov Asher will agree to change."

The Religious Reservists Forum called the plan "destructive to Israel's security and to reservists' families." Uri Keidar, head of the group Israel Hofshit, which fought the draft bill pushed by the committee's previous chairman, said the plan had "good things and bad things." He said it would not pass the Haredi parties "in any scenario" unless they come down from "a lot of trees they have climbed in recent years."

Reserve duty: what the army planned and what reservists serveDays of reserve service per reservist per year, as described by a security official to Ynet. The army had planned to reach about 42 days within two years; reservists now serve 80 to 100.

Source: Ynet

Show the numbers
MeasureDays per year
Army's planned level42
Current, low end80
Current, high end100
Share this chartPost

The army's numbers#

The army has pressed its own case. On Monday, military chief Lt. Gen. Eyal Zamir said: "The IDF must expand, and the IDF is short of combat soldiers. That has not changed." Expanding service to all groups "will make it possible to distribute the operational burden more evenly," he said, according to Ynet, and would "significantly reduce the burden on reservists."

Data the army gave the committee over the past year showed an immediate shortage of about 12,000 soldiers, including 6,000 to 7,000 combat troops, Ynet reported. Since July 2024, new conscripts have served 30-month terms, which is expected to add a shortfall of about 2,500 combat soldiers. A security official told Ynet that the army had planned to cut reserve duty to about 42 days a year over two years. Instead, reservists are serving 80 to 100 days a year because of the war on several fronts.

Netanyahu, now leading a caretaker government, has staked out the Haredi parties' side. "In any government that is formed, we will work together with our ultra-Orthodox partners and regulate the status of Torah scholars through legislation agreed upon with them," he said on Monday, Ynet reported.

The same day, a speaker vote#

The draft fight hung over the Knesset's other big vote on Tuesday. Likud nominated Ofir Katz to run against Yashar!'s Matan Kahana for speaker, after Kahana refused Likud's support on the condition that he not name deputies from Arab parties, JFeed reported. Shas said it would back Katz. United Torah Judaism also backed Katz after Rabbi Moshe Hillel Hirsch told its Degel HaTorah lawmakers to support him, despite the party's contacts with Eisenkot's bloc.

Kahana was still expected to win with Arab party votes. The debate began on Tuesday afternoon and was expected to run late into the evening, Ynet reported. Netanyahu's bloc planned to drag it out. The background is set out in our report on the bid to replace Speaker Amir Ohana.

What comes next#

Liberman's committee has begun what he calls a mapping stage, with no bill before it. UTJ wants a law to stop the arrests of yeshiva students before any new government is sworn in, and an agreed full draft law approved by its Council of Torah Sages, according to earlier reports. Eisenkot's bloc says its core demands, including the 3 percent cap, are not up for trade.

Without a deal on the draft, the Haredi parties' 13 seats stay out of Eisenkot's reach.

Differing perspectives

What kind of Haredi draft law should Israel's next government pass?

Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.

  • A fair law the army, court and rabbis can live with

    Who holds it: Avigdor Liberman, chairman of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee

    Liberman says the election limits what his camp can do: the change bloc "received 40 percent of the entire Israeli public." Any law must first be approved by the chief of staff as meeting "the IDF's needs," then pass the High Court. He says there is "currently no framework" and the committee is "at the mapping stage," studying the problems before writing a bill.

    In their words: JFeed ↗

  • No concessions on equal service

    Who holds it: Reservist activist Yitzhaki Glick of El HaDegel

    Glick says reservists "have no time" and that no law can satisfy both Rabbi Landau and the High Court. He accuses Liberman of giving up the issue "the moment power reaches your hands" and says the bloc is now doing what it blamed Netanyahu for: "advancing a draft-evasion law, or concessions that will mean we have to extend our reserve duty."

    In their words: JFeed ↗

  • Protect full-time Torah study

    Who holds it: United Torah Judaism lawmakers and officials

    UTJ figures say the Yashar! plan will not pass their rabbis, who want any young man who wishes to study Torah to keep doing so without targets or sanctions. An Agudat Yisrael lawmaker said it "will not pass the Council of Torah Sages, and we will vote against it and against such a government," calling it "the opposite of regulation" of yeshiva students' status.

    In their words: Ynet (Hebrew) ↗

  • The army needs more soldiers now

    Who holds it: IDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Eyal Zamir

    Zamir says a people's army is "first and foremost" an operational need. "The IDF must expand, and the IDF is short of combat soldiers. That has not changed," he said. Expanding service to all groups would "distribute the operational burden more evenly" and "significantly reduce the burden on reservists," who are serving far more days than planned.

    In their words: Ynet News ↗

Cite this article

567 Politics staff. “At first draft-law hearing, Liberman says no framework exists as reservists and Haredi lawmakers balk.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-17. https://567politics.com/news/israel-liberman-first-draft-law-hearing-no-framework-reservist-glick-utj-yashar-plan-november-2026

Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=At first draft-law hearing, Liberman says no framework exists as reservists and Haredi lawmakers balk |url=https://567politics.com/news/israel-liberman-first-draft-law-hearing-no-framework-reservist-glick-utj-yashar-plan-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-17 |language=en}}
CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
  "id": "https://567politics.com/news/israel-liberman-first-draft-law-hearing-no-framework-reservist-glick-utj-yashar-plan-november-2026",
  "type": "article-newspaper",
  "title": "At first draft-law hearing, Liberman says no framework exists as reservists and Haredi lawmakers balk",
  "URL": "https://567politics.com/news/israel-liberman-first-draft-law-hearing-no-framework-reservist-glick-utj-yashar-plan-november-2026",
  "container-title": "567politics",
  "language": "en",
  "author": [
    {
      "literal": "567 Politics staff"
    }
  ],
  "issued": {
    "date-parts": [
      [
        2026,
        11,
        17
      ]
    ]
  }
}

Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.

Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.

Embed this article summary

Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.

<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/israel-liberman-first-draft-law-hearing-no-framework-reservist-glick-utj-yashar-plan-november-2026?theme=auto" title="At first draft-law hearing, Liberman says no framework exists as reservists and Haredi lawmakers balk by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:14px">At first draft-law hearing, Liberman says no framework exists as reservists and Haredi lawmakers balk by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/israel-liberman-first-draft-law-hearing-no-framework-reservist-glick-utj-yashar-plan-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p>
<script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>

READ BEYOND 567POLITICS

Alternate sources & perspectives

Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.

Reviewed 2026-11-17. Compiled 2026-11-17 from pages opened and read; discover_politics_sources returned only unrelated results, so every source was chosen by hand. No Knesset transcript of Tuesday's committee session was available, so quotes from the hearing come from JFeed's two reports and an Israel National News flash, which match. Haredi reactions come from Ynet's Hebrew report, which quotes unnamed UTJ and Agudat Yisrael figures as well as UTJ's official statement; Hebrew quotes were translated by 567 Politics. Army manpower figures are as reported by Ynet from data given to the committee and a security official.

All 567politics news →