Skip to content
567politics.

Palestinian Territories

Israel names 3 Hamas men killed in Nasser Hospital strike but not the commander it said it targeted

Gaza's Health Ministry says six died, including a surgeon. Israel says Hamas ran a command post on a hospital floor; Hamas calls that a cover for a crime.

By 567 Politics staffPublished 10 min read

File photo: the intensive care unit at Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis, in an image shared online in 2009.
File photo: the intensive care unit at Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis, in an image shared online in 2009. · Photo: RafahKid Kid via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0 ↗

Israel's military and the Shin Bet security agency said on Monday that three Hamas members were among those killed when Israel struck Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis last Thursday. One of them, they said, helped abduct Israeli hostage Adina Moshe on October 7, 2023. Gaza's Hamas-run Health Ministry says the strike killed six people, among them a senior surgeon, and wounded about 30. The UN considers the ministry's casualty figures reliable, the BBC noted.

The new statement is Israel's most detailed account yet of a strike on the largest hospital in southern Gaza, carried out during the ceasefire that began in October 2025. It also leaves a key question open. On the day of the strike, the army said it had targeted the commander of Hamas's Khan Younis Brigade. Monday's statement did not confirm that he was killed.

Hamas says the hospital is a civilian site and calls Israel's account a cover for a crime. Israel does not allow international reporters into Gaza, so neither side's account can be checked on the ground.

What Israel says now#

The joint statement named the three men as Murad Tawfiq Mahmoud Abu Zarifa, Khaled Osama Abu Anza and Muhammad Nafed Abu Awad, Ynet News reported. It said Abu Zarifa led a squad in a Hamas engineering unit that crossed into Israel on October 7 and took part in seizing Moshe from Kibbutz Nir Oz. Abu Anza headed a liaison section in Hamas's military intelligence, and Abu Awad was a member of the group's Nukhba force in the Khan Younis Brigade, the statement said.

NameRole, according to the IDF and Shin Bet
Murad Tawfiq Mahmoud Abu ZarifaEngineering unit squad leader; took part in Adina Moshe's abduction
Khaled Osama Abu AnzaHead of a liaison section, Hamas military intelligence
Muhammad Nafed Abu AwadNukhba force member, Khan Younis Brigade
Share this tablePost

The army said it hit "a room and a floor" of the hospital that Hamas's armed wing had turned into a command center. Senior commanders worked there, the area was heavily guarded and civilians were barred from it, the army said. It said it had warned many times, "including recently," that Hamas must stop using the hospital for military purposes. "The IDF operates in accordance with international law," it said.

The army posted the findings on X under the heading "EXPOSED: Hamas terrorists presented as civilians were among those eliminated."

View on X ↗

File photo: the intensive care unit at Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis, in an image shared online in 2009.

The statement did not say whether Muhammad Abu Ismail, the Khan Younis Brigade commander, was killed. On November 12, the army had said the strike targeted Abu Ismail and "additional terrorists hiding inside" the hospital, in a post on X. The Israeli news site WireIsrael reported on Monday that Israeli officials were still awaiting final confirmation of the result for him. Ynet News noted that earlier Palestinian reports had named Abu Anza as the brigade commander. The army's list instead describes him as an intelligence official.

How the army's account has shifted#

The army's public account has grown over five days. Each step added a detail.

How Israel's account of the Nasser Hospital strike developed
  1. Strike hits the hospital's surgery building after midnight
  2. Army says it struck "a senior Hamas terrorist" inside the hospital
  3. Army names Khan Younis Brigade commander Muhammad Abu Ismail as the target
  4. Army says the second floor was a Hamas headquarters closed to civilians
  5. Army publishes seized documents it says show Hamas use of hospitals
  6. Army and Shin Bet name three Hamas members among the dead

Source: IDF on X, Ynet News, BBC

The army's November 12 post went further. It said "dozens of hostages were held captive at the Nasser Hospital" during the war and that Abu Ismail was responsible for holding many of them. It named seven, including Edan Alexander, Matan Zangauker and Capt. Omer Neutra. The army said the strike "was specifically directed at the room" from which the commander and another man were working, in a post on X.

The next day, the army published what it said were Hamas and Islamic Jihad documents seized by troops. One, which it dated to 2019 and attributed to the brigade's deputy commander, named Nasser, the Red Crescent Hospital and the European Hospital as places to take suspects for interrogation, the army said. The documents have not been released in full or checked independently.

Israeli security officials gave Ynet News more detail. They said a drone fired two or three missiles, guided by Shin Bet and military intelligence. They said the hospital had been watched for a long time, and that Hamas members used parts of it at night, when fewer civilians were present. Officials had earlier said the targeted area held a Hamas interrogation and torture site, Ynet News reported. Hamas has not addressed that claim directly.

The competing accounts of the Nasser Hospital strike
  1. Israel's army and Shin Beta hospital room and floor were a Hamas command center; three Hamas members were killed
  2. Gaza's Health Ministrysix people killed, including a senior surgeon, and about 30 wounded
  3. Hamasthe hospital is a civilian site and Israel's claims justify "a documented crime"
  4. MSFNasser must be spared from attack and kept free of military use by any armed group
  5. Not establishedwhether the brigade commander was killed, and the roles of the other three dead

Source: IDF on X, BBC, MSF

The army also released what it said was a recording of a warning given to a senior Gaza health official before the strike, the BBC reported. The hospital's director said no warning was received.

What Gaza officials and medics say#

The Health Ministry said medical staff, patients and people caring for them were killed, among them surgeon Dr. Rizq Abu Shaira. It called the strike a "flagrant violation of international laws and conventions," the BBC reported. Ynet News said Palestinian reports also listed a teenager among the dead.

The hospital's director, Dr. Ahmed al-Fara, told a news conference that two missiles hit the al-Yasin surgery building, which holds surgical wards and intensive care units. Only one exploded, he said, according to the BBC. "What's happened in Nasser Medical Complex is targeting the health sector mainly. We are talking about doctors, we are talking about civilians, we are talking about patients," he said.

A wounded surgeon, Dr. Mohammed Qdeih, told the BBC he and other staff had just finished work and were getting ready to sleep. "My whole body was trapped under the rubble," he said. He said patients in nearby rooms were killed. Of Abu Shaira, he said: "He was the kindest person in this department."

Hamas rejected Israel's claims as "a blatant attempt to justify a documented crime targeting a civilian medical facility whose function and purpose are well known," the BBC reported. It called the strike a "war crime," Al Jazeera reported. Hamas had presented those killed as civilians, Ynet News said. Al Jazeera's correspondent said most of the dead and wounded were patients. Palestinian Islamic Jihad accused the Trump administration of giving Israel "political and military cover," Al Jazeera reported.

Monday's statement does not settle the gap between the two accounts. Israel says three of the dead were Hamas fighters. Gaza officials say the dead included a surgeon and patients. The two claims do not rule each other out, and neither side has released a full list of the dead with their roles.

Israel says half of those killed in the Nasser strike were Hamas membersPeople killed in the Nov. 12, 2026 strike, by source. The two counts come from opposing parties and have not been independently verified.

Source: Gaza Health Ministry via BBC, IDF and Shin Bet via Ynet News

Show the numbers
CountPeople
Killed, according to Gaza's Health Ministry6
Named as Hamas members by Israel3
Share this chartPost

A hospital at the center of a long dispute#

Nasser Medical Complex serves almost one million people, the BBC said. Al-Fara said it was the seventh time the hospital had been hit during the war. In August 2025, a double Israeli strike there killed 22 people, including journalists and health workers, the BBC reported.

Israel has long accused Hamas of using hospitals across Gaza for military purposes. In January 2024, Israel's military liaison office for the territories said Hamas was operating from Nasser and al-Amal hospitals, Ynet News noted. Hamas denies using hospitals this way.

Nasser Hospital during the war and ceasefire
  1. Israel's liaison office says Hamas is operating from Nasser and al-Amal hospitals
  2. A double Israeli strike at Nasser kills 22, including journalists and health workers
  3. The Gaza ceasefire takes effect
  4. MSF suspends non-critical work, citing armed men and arbitrary arrests of patients
  5. MSF resumes that work after what it calls concrete improvements
  6. A strike on the surgery building kills six, according to the Health Ministry

Source: Ynet News, BBC, MSF

Doctors Without Borders, known as MSF, has its own record of the hospital. It suspended non-critical work at Nasser on January 20, 2026, after its staff saw "masked armed men," intimidation, "arbitrary arrests of patients" and one case of the suspected movement of weapons. It resumed that work on April 13, after what it called "concrete improvements," including limits on weapons and armed people, MSF said.

MSF has also objected to Israel's use of such reports. In the same statement, the group said its findings should not be turned into a tool, and that it had seen Israel "obliterating the health system in Gaza" on the grounds that hospitals were command centers or used for military purposes, "which we never witnessed." "Nasser must be spared from Israeli attacks, and it must not be used for any military purposes by Hamas or any other armed groups."

The World Health Organization says it has recorded 1,056 attacks on health care in Gaza over three years, with 1,010 deaths, according to the BBC. "Gaza's health facilities are lifelines for its people. They must be protected. They must never be militarized or attacked," WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said.

The ceasefire backdrop#

The strike came during a ceasefire in place since October 2025. Gaza's Health Ministry says more than 1,600 people have been killed since then. Israeli officials say Hamas is trying to rebuild its command in southern Gaza, and the army says it will keep acting against it. On Sunday, the army and Shin Bet also confirmed the killing of Samir Abu Younis, whom they called the commander of Hamas's Rafah Brigade, Ynet News reported. Earlier this month, six Gaza police officers died after a strike in Khan Younis that Israel said hit militants.

The hospital strike also landed amid a wider fight over Gaza's future. Israel says rebuilding must wait for Hamas to disarm, while Hamas and UN agencies blame Israeli limits on aid, as 567 Politics reported on the strikes that killed seven last week. Flooding has left tens of thousands of families in wet tents, a dispute covered in our report on Gaza's fourth winter in tents. Both sides have also traded counts over who was a fighter and who was a civilian, as in the clash over Gaza journalists' death counts.

What is not yet known#

The names and roles of the other three people killed have not been confirmed by both sides. It is not known whether Abu Ismail was in the building, or whether he survived. The army has not released the intelligence behind its claim that the floor was a command center, beyond the documents it published on November 13. Gaza health officials have not responded in detail to the names Israel released on Monday.

Independent checks are limited while foreign reporters cannot enter Gaza. The WHO and MSF have both called for Nasser to be protected from attack and kept free of armed use. No independent inquiry into the strike has been announced.

Differing perspectives

Was Israel's November 12 strike on Nasser Hospital aimed at a Hamas command post or at a civilian medical site?

Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.

  • A crime against a civilian hospital

    Who holds it: Hamas

    Hamas calls the strike a war crime and says Israel's claims of targeting Hamas members are a blatant attempt to cover up a crime against a civilian medical facility protected under international law. It says mediators and the US administration must act to halt Israel's ongoing violations and make it keep to the ceasefire.

    In their words: Al Jazeera, reporting Hamas statements ↗

  • Hamas ran a command post inside

    Who holds it: Israel Defense Forces and the Shin Bet

    The army says it struck a room and a floor of the hospital that Hamas's armed wing used as a military command center. It says three Hamas members were killed, including a man who took part in the October 7 abduction of Adina Moshe. It says it warned repeatedly that military activity at the hospital must stop, and that Hamas kept operating there anyway.

    In their words: IDF on X ↗

  • Health care must never be attacked

    Who holds it: World Health Organization and Gaza's Health Ministry

    Gaza's Health Ministry says the strike killed six people, including senior surgeon Dr. Rizq Abu Shaira, and wounded about 30. The WHO says it has recorded more than 1,000 attacks on health care in Gaza over three years. Its director-general says Gaza's health facilities are lifelines that must be protected and must never be militarized or attacked.

    In their words: BBC, reporting the Health Ministry and WHO ↗

  • Spare the hospital and keep arms out

    Who holds it: Doctors Without Borders (MSF)

    MSF says Nasser is one of the last partly working public hospitals in Gaza and a lifeline that must be protected under international law. It suspended some work there in January after seeing armed men and arrests of patients, and resumed in April after improvements. It says Nasser must be spared from Israeli attacks and must not be used for military purposes by Hamas or any armed group.

    In their words: Doctors Without Borders (MSF) ↗

Cite this article

567 Politics staff. “Israel names 3 Hamas men killed in Nasser Hospital strike but not the commander it said it targeted.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-17. https://567politics.com/news/palestine-nasser-hospital-strike-idf-names-three-hamas-abu-zarifa-surgeon-abu-shaira-november-2026

Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Israel names 3 Hamas men killed in Nasser Hospital strike but not the commander it said it targeted |url=https://567politics.com/news/palestine-nasser-hospital-strike-idf-names-three-hamas-abu-zarifa-surgeon-abu-shaira-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-17 |language=en}}
CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
  "id": "https://567politics.com/news/palestine-nasser-hospital-strike-idf-names-three-hamas-abu-zarifa-surgeon-abu-shaira-november-2026",
  "type": "article-newspaper",
  "title": "Israel names 3 Hamas men killed in Nasser Hospital strike but not the commander it said it targeted",
  "URL": "https://567politics.com/news/palestine-nasser-hospital-strike-idf-names-three-hamas-abu-zarifa-surgeon-abu-shaira-november-2026",
  "container-title": "567politics",
  "language": "en",
  "author": [
    {
      "literal": "567 Politics staff"
    }
  ],
  "issued": {
    "date-parts": [
      [
        2026,
        11,
        17
      ]
    ]
  }
}

Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.

Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.

Embed this article summary

Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.

<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/palestine-nasser-hospital-strike-idf-names-three-hamas-abu-zarifa-surgeon-abu-shaira-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Israel names 3 Hamas men killed in Nasser Hospital strike but not the commander it said it targeted by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:14px">Israel names 3 Hamas men killed in Nasser Hospital strike but not the commander it said it targeted by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/palestine-nasser-hospital-strike-idf-names-three-hamas-abu-zarifa-surgeon-abu-shaira-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p>
<script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>

READ BEYOND 567POLITICS

Alternate sources & perspectives

Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.

Reviewed 2026-11-16. Compiled 2026-11-16 from pages opened and read; every source was chosen by hand. Israel's account comes from IDF posts on X and Israeli outlets; Gaza casualty figures come from the Hamas-run Health Ministry, whose figures the UN considers reliable, as reported by the BBC and Al Jazeera. The IDF's seized documents have not been released in full or independently verified, and neither side has published a full list of the dead with their roles. idf.il and Times of Israel pages were blocked to our fetcher.

All 567politics news →