Hegseth swore 'trans' meant gender dysphoria. Now DOJ wants his words kept out of the troop-ban trial
Hegseth stood by his remarks in sworn answers filed Nov. 13, as the Justice Department asked the judge not to treat them as proof of animus.

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has put his own words about transgender troops on the record under penalty of perjury. Now the Justice Department wants a federal judge to set those words aside when she decides whether his policy is lawful.
The two moves arrived together on Friday, November 13, in Talbott v. United States, the main court challenge to the military's 2025 policy on service members with gender dysphoria. The government filed nine motions in limine, which are requests to limit what evidence a judge may consider at trial. One of them attaches Hegseth's sworn written answers to ten questions from the plaintiffs. Another asks Judge Ana C. Reyes to keep many of the same remarks out of the case. A two-week bench trial is set to start on January 4, 2027, in federal court in Washington.
The outcome of these evidence fights could shape the trial itself. The plaintiffs argue that the policy was driven by hostility toward transgender people. The government argues that it is a neutral medical standard. Which statements the court may weigh goes to the heart of that dispute.
What Hegseth said under oath#
Hegseth signed his answers on October 28, 2026, under penalty of perjury, according to the verification page filed with the court. The filing calls him "Secretary of War," a title it says is used interchangeably with secretary of defense. Reyes had ordered the written answers in place of the longer deposition the plaintiffs sought, The Advocate reported.
His answers defend his past language and tie it to the policy's medical terms. Key points from the interrogatory responses (ECF No. 172-1):
- Asked whether transgender people should be allowed to serve, he said people with a current diagnosis or history of gender dysphoria should not serve without a waiver. "To the extent transgender people fall into that category, they should not be permitted to serve," he wrote.
- Asked which statements in Executive Order 14183 he personally disagrees with, he answered: "None."
- Asked about a passage in his 2024 book, The War on Warriors, that called it "weird" for men to present as women, he wrote: "Men pretending to be women is 'weird' because men cannot be women and women cannot be men."
- Asked whether he approves of "dudes in dresses" or a slur for transgender people serving, he repeated both terms. He said such people should not serve "absent a waiver" if they fall within the department's gender dysphoria policy.
- Asked about his May 6, 2025, post on X reading "No More Trans @ DoD," he said it referred to a Supreme Court order that day. "I, like many others, occasionally use the term 'trans' as shorthand for individuals with gender dysphoria," he wrote.
He also gave a reason for barring service members from using pronouns that do not match their sex. "Sex is immutable and unchanging," he wrote, and anything that distracts from "mission success—including individual preferences—must be avoided."
The answers are one side's sworn account. They do not settle whether the policy is lawful. That question is for the court at trial and, possibly, for the Supreme Court.
Why the Justice Department wants the words excluded#
The government does not deny that Hegseth made the statements. Its argument is about what they prove.
In Motion in Limine No. 2 (ECF No. 172), the department asks the court to exclude phrases such as "trans lunacy," "dudes in dresses" and the slur, as well as some wording in the executive order. It says the plaintiffs will use them to try to prove animus, the legal term for a bare desire to harm a group. The motion argues that a court may infer animus only when a policy has no other plausible purpose. It relies on Trump v. Hawaii (2018) and a 2026 Supreme Court decision, Mullin v. Doe, which it describes as holding that heated statements about Haiti did not show that race drove the end of Haiti's temporary protected status.
The motion says Hegseth's remarks are "all tied to the medical condition of gender dysphoria." It argues that the condition "impacts combat readiness and efficacy" because treatment depends on medication and ongoing care. It also points to a recent D.C. Circuit ruling that, in its reading, declined to treat Hegseth's sharp posts about the company Anthropic as proof of an improper motive.
A separate filing, Motion in Limine No. 1 (ECF No. 171), goes further. It asks the court to decide whom the policy classifies by reading only its "operative terms." Those terms, the government says, turn on a medical condition and related treatments, like earlier rules under Defense Secretaries Ash Carter, Jim Mattis and Lloyd Austin. The motion leans on West Virginia v. B.P.J., the 2026 Supreme Court ruling on school sports laws. In the government's reading, the justices looked past legislative findings about gender identity and judged those laws by their text. 567politics covered how both sides are reading B.P.J. in a transgender jail-housing case the justices sent back this month.
A third motion, ECF No. 173, asks the court to bar questions to civil servants and military officers about whether they personally agree with the policy. It says those officials must carry out lawful orders whatever they think, and that political appointees make the final decisions.
The plaintiffs oppose the motions, according to footnotes in the filings. Their written responses are due on November 20 under the court's schedule.
The fight over former Pentagon officials#
Five more motions target the plaintiffs' expert witnesses. Each is a former senior official who oversaw personnel policy when transgender troops served openly.
The government seeks to exclude testimony from Shawn Skelly, a former assistant secretary of defense for readiness (ECF No. 174); Yvette Bourcicot, a former acting assistant secretary of the Army for manpower (ECF No. 175); Ashish Vazirani, a former Pentagon personnel official (ECF No. 176); Alex Wagner, a former assistant secretary of the Air Force for manpower (ECF No. 177); and retired Army Maj. Gen. James Young (ECF No. 178).
According to the motions, these witnesses plan to testify that open service under the Austin policy did not harm readiness or unit cohesion. Some also plan to say the 2025 policy skipped the department's usual evidence-based process, or that its waiver and separation steps are not truly individual.
The government's answer, in the Vazirani and Wagner motions, is that each man's opinions "are those of a former political appointee who disagrees with a policy that his successors, appointed by a different administration, have implemented." It cites Goldman v. Weinberger (1986), in which the Supreme Court called outside experts' views on military discipline "quite beside the point." By agreement, the Skelly motion adds, she would not testify about her own experience as a transgender person.
The Young motion contains a notable concession. The government argues his testimony on lost careers is not needed, because "Defendants acknowledge as a factual matter that absent a waiver, some service members who fall within the policy do in fact have their careers curtailed."
The plaintiffs filed their own motions the same day. They seek to exclude undisclosed data, irrelevant medical records, disclaimed expert opinions and opinions in one government witness's disclosure, according to the court docket.
No summary judgment, and a phone call on Monday#
The government also changed course on how the case ends. In a notice filed November 13 (ECF No. 170), it withdrew its plan to seek summary judgment, a ruling without trial. It said the court had made clear the case would go to trial. The department still maintains "that the trial is unnecessary and improper," the notice says.
In a November 14 order on the docket, Reyes canceled an in-person conference set for Monday, November 16, at 4 p.m. She replaced it with a teleconference at the same time, after the parties raised a discovery dispute. The order does not describe the dispute.
How the case got here#
The case has moved on two tracks: the trial court in Washington and the appeals courts above it.
- Trump signs Executive Order 14183 on military service
- Pentagon issues the policy on gender dysphoria
- Judge Reyes issues a preliminary injunction
- Supreme Court lets the policy take effect in Shilling v. Trump
- D.C. Circuit keeps named serving plaintiffs in uniform
- Justice Department asks the Supreme Court to review
- Plaintiffs file their brief opposing review
- Government files nine motions in limine
- Bench trial set to begin
Source: GLAD Law case page, D.C. Circuit opinion, Supreme Court docket 26-272
The June 1 appeals decision split three ways. Judge Wilkins found the plaintiffs likely to win their equal protection claim. He kept the injunction for named plaintiffs already serving but sent back the part covering people seeking to enlist. He wrote that the policy's own stated premises gave "direct evidence in this case that animus motivated the classifications." Senior Judge Rogers would have kept the whole injunction. Judge Walker dissented. He wrote that "an unbroken line of unambiguous authorities" requires courts to uphold military policies that reflect "professional military judgment."
That disagreement is the same one now playing out over evidence. If the court weighs the secretary's words, the plaintiffs' animus case gets stronger. If it reads only the policy's text, the government's medical-standard case gets stronger.
The government has asked the Supreme Court to take the case (No. 26-272). West Virginia and 21 other states filed a brief supporting review, as did a group including retired Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn. The plaintiffs filed their opposition on November 2. As of November 16, the docket shows no order granting or denying review. 567politics reported on that filing, and on a Marine Corps order that speeds separations, in an earlier story on the Marine directive.
What each side says#
The White House has defended the policy in political terms. "Joe Biden allowed trans insanity to run rampant in our military. President Trump restored lethality and readiness to our warfighters," spokeswoman Olivia Wales said in August, according to Stars and Stripes. The Pentagon referred questions to the White House at the time.
The plaintiffs' lawyers at GLAD Law and the National Center for LGBTQ Rights call the policy "a complete purge of all transgender people from military service" on their case page. Shannon Minter of NCLR told Stars and Stripes that the administration is "needlessly attempting to ram through policies that will cause irreparable harm to service members and their families."
Army 2nd Lt. Nicolas Talbott, the lead plaintiff, has said his "being transgender has no bearing on my dedication to the mission," in a statement on the same case page.
Neither side has yet filed a public response to the November 13 motions. 567politics has not independently interviewed the parties for this story.
What the filings do not show#
The filings do not show how Reyes will rule. Motions in limine are often decided close to trial, and judges in bench trials sometimes admit disputed evidence and decide later how much weight to give it.
They also do not show how many service members have been separated under the policy. Neither the motions nor the docket entries reviewed for this story give a current count. The government's concession about curtailed careers is general and gives no number.
Finally, the Supreme Court could change the path of the case at any time. If the justices grant review, they could rule on the injunction before or after the January trial. Other transgender-policy fights are running in parallel, including a challenge to the federal employee health plan's coverage ban. Hegseth also faces political pressure on other fronts; the House recently sent impeachment articles against him to committee in a 211-204 vote tied mostly to the Iran war.
What to watch#
The plaintiffs' responses to the motions are due November 20. The parties' Monday teleconference could resolve the discovery dispute or set up further rulings. Trial is set for January 4. The Supreme Court could act on the government's petition at any conference before then.
Differing perspectives
Should Hegseth's public remarks count as evidence of what motivated the military's gender dysphoria policy?
Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.
Defer to military judgment either way
Who holds it: West Virginia and 21 other states, in a Supreme Court brief; a similar view appears in Judge Walker's D.C. Circuit dissent
These states argue that the appeals court applied a test stricter than heightened scrutiny while calling it rational-basis review. They say courts should uphold a policy if any plausible reason supports it, and that deference to the military should be at its height on questions of who is fit to serve. On this view, courts should not second-guess the military's medical standards for service.
In their words: Brief of West Virginia and 21 other states as amici curiae, No. 26-272 ↗
Judge the policy by its written terms
Who holds it: The Justice Department and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, in motions filed Nov. 13, 2026, in Talbott v. United States
The government argues that the 2025 policy, like the Carter, Mattis and Austin rules before it, classifies people by a medical condition and its treatments, not by transgender status. It says Supreme Court precedent lets courts infer animus only when a policy has no other plausible purpose. It argues Hegseth's remarks, however heated, tie back to readiness, deployability and uniform standards, so admitting them would invite unfair prejudice and confuse the issues.
In their words: U.S. Department of Justice, Motion in Limine No. 2 (ECF No. 172) ↗
Weigh the remarks as evidence of animus
Who holds it: The Talbott plaintiffs and their lawyers at GLAD Law and the National Center for LGBTQ Rights
The plaintiffs argue that the ban is a complete purge of transgender people from military service, not a neutral medical rule. They say transgender troops meet the same rigorous standards as everyone else and have served honorably, including in combat. They have pointed courts to what they call Hegseth's open disparagement of transgender troops, and argue that officials' own words reveal the policy's real purpose.
In their words: GLAD Law, Talbott v. USA case page ↗
Cite this article
567 Politics staff. “Hegseth swore 'trans' meant gender dysphoria. Now DOJ wants his words kept out of the troop-ban trial.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-16. https://567politics.com/news/talbott-hegseth-sworn-answers-doj-motions-exclude-statements-transgender-troops-trial-november-2026
Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Hegseth swore 'trans' meant gender dysphoria. Now DOJ wants his words kept out of the troop-ban trial |url=https://567politics.com/news/talbott-hegseth-sworn-answers-doj-motions-exclude-statements-transgender-troops-trial-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-16 |language=en}}CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
"id": "https://567politics.com/news/talbott-hegseth-sworn-answers-doj-motions-exclude-statements-transgender-troops-trial-november-2026",
"type": "article-newspaper",
"title": "Hegseth swore 'trans' meant gender dysphoria. Now DOJ wants his words kept out of the troop-ban trial",
"URL": "https://567politics.com/news/talbott-hegseth-sworn-answers-doj-motions-exclude-statements-transgender-troops-trial-november-2026",
"container-title": "567politics",
"language": "en",
"author": [
{
"literal": "567 Politics staff"
}
],
"issued": {
"date-parts": [
[
2026,
11,
16
]
]
}
}Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.
Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.
Embed this article summary
Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.
<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/talbott-hegseth-sworn-answers-doj-motions-exclude-statements-transgender-troops-trial-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Hegseth swore 'trans' meant gender dysphoria. Now DOJ wants his words kept out of the troop-ban trial by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe> <p style="font-size:14px">Hegseth swore 'trans' meant gender dysphoria. Now DOJ wants his words kept out of the troop-ban trial by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/talbott-hegseth-sworn-answers-doj-motions-exclude-statements-transgender-troops-trial-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p> <script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
READ BEYOND 567POLITICS
Alternate sources & perspectives
Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.
- primary evidence
Interrogatory responses of Secretary Pete Hegseth (ECF No. 172-1) ↗
U.S. District Court for D.C., via CourtListener
Hegseth's sworn answers to ten written questions, verified Oct. 28, 2026, and filed Nov. 13 as an exhibit.
- primary evidence
Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 2 to exclude certain statements to prove animus (ECF No. 172) ↗
U.S. Department of Justice, via CourtListener
The government's argument for keeping Hegseth's remarks and parts of Executive Order 14183 out as proof of animus.
- primary evidence
Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 1 on the policy's operative terms (ECF No. 171) ↗
U.S. Department of Justice, via CourtListener
Asks the court to decide how the policy classifies by its text alone, citing West Virginia v. B.P.J.
- primary evidence
Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 8 on Maj. Gen. (Ret.) James Young (ECF No. 178) ↗
U.S. Department of Justice, via CourtListener
Contains the government's concession that some covered service members have their careers curtailed absent a waiver.
- primary evidence
Notice of withdrawal of intent to move for summary judgment (ECF No. 170) ↗
U.S. Department of Justice, via CourtListener
The government drops its summary judgment plan while maintaining the trial is unnecessary.
- primary evidence
Talbott v. Trump docket, 1:25-cv-00240 ↗
CourtListener (Free Law Project)
Full docket, including the Nov. 14 order converting the Nov. 16 conference to a teleconference and the plaintiffs' own motions in limine.
- primary evidence
Talbott v. United States, No. 25-5087 (D.C. Cir. June 1, 2026) ↗
U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit
The split appeals ruling, with Judge Wilkins's animus finding and Judge Walker's dissent on military deference.
- primary evidence
Docket for United States v. Talbott, No. 26-272 ↗
Supreme Court of the United States
The government's pending petition, amicus briefs and the plaintiffs' Nov. 2 opposition.
- right argument
Brief of West Virginia and 21 other states as amici curiae ↗
Office of the West Virginia Attorney General
States' case that the appeals court misapplied rational-basis review and owed the military greater deference.
- left argument
Talbott v. USA case page ↗
GLAD Law
The plaintiffs' lawyers' account of the case, timeline and plaintiffs' statements.
- other perspective
Pete Hegseth defended his anti-trans slurs under penalty of perjury. The DOJ wants them excluded from trial ↗
The Advocate
LGBTQ outlet's report on the Nov. 13 filings, including background on the Oct. 14 hearing at which Reyes ordered written answers.
- independent analysis
Justice Department petitions Supreme Court for immediate ban on transgender troops in military ↗
Stars and Stripes
Military-press report with statements from the White House and NCLR on the government's Supreme Court petition.
Reviewed 2026-11-16. The source-discovery tool returned only irrelevant results (software help pages), so this list was chosen by hand from pages opened while reporting. Court filings were read in full from CourtListener's RECAP archive. Neither party had filed a public response to the Nov. 13 motions as of Nov. 16; the plaintiffs' responses are due Nov. 20. Independent mainstream coverage of the Nov. 13 filings was limited at review time; The Advocate, an LGBTQ outlet, was the main news account found. Major wire-service and conservative-outlet coverage of these specific filings was not found.