Flávio Bolsonaro lost. His plan to end presidential reelection is back in Brazil's Senate
Senate leaders across the spectrum want a vote, but disagree on whether governors and mayors are covered and whether terms should grow to five years.

Brazil's Senate is reviving a proposal that looked finished on Oct. 25. Ending presidential reelection was a signature promise of Flávio Bolsonaro, the Liberal Party (PL) candidate who lost the runoff to Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva. Three weeks later, Senate party leaders from the left, center and right say they want to vote on the idea anyway, Folha de S.Paulo reported on Nov. 15.
The government's leader in Congress, Sen. Randolfe Rodrigues (PT-AP), told Folha there was "almost a consensus" on the need to end reelection and predicted a decision this month. What senators do not agree on is the part that matters most: who would lose the right to run again, and whether every elected official would get a longer term in exchange.
Why a losing campaign's idea came back#
The issue resurfaced through a different fight. In the Chamber of Deputies, Speaker Hugo Motta (Republicanos-PB) and Centrão parties have been looking for ways to slow the growth of the PL and Novo, two right-wing parties that took seats from center and center-right rivals in October with help from high-vote "vote-pullers." Their first plan, a switch to mixed district voting, stalled after a revolt by their own deputies.
When the Chamber's electoral-reform rapporteur, Deputy Domingos Neto (PSD-CE), briefed the Senate's party leaders in early November, Sen. Marcelo Castro (MDB-PI) proposed folding the end of reelection into the package, according to Folha and OsPoderes. Castro is not a newcomer to the topic. He wrote the version of the amendment that the Senate's Constitution and Justice Committee (CCJ) has already approved.
Senate President Davi Alcolumbre (União-AP) wants any change to travel inside the broader political reform being drafted in the Chamber, and plans to raise the subject with Lula and Motta, allies told SBT News columnist Túlio Amâncio on Nov. 16. SBT reported that the Senate is now testing whether there is enough support to bring a text to the floor before the year-end recess. No new text has been filed and no floor date has been set, OsPoderes reported.
Two amendments, very different reach#
Two proposals are on the table, and they are not the same reform.
The first, PEC 12/2022, was filed by Sen. Jorge Kajuru (PSB-GO) and rewritten by Castro. The CCJ approved it on May 21, 2025. It would bar presidents, governors and mayors from seeking a consecutive second term and lengthen every elected term, executive and legislative, to five years. It would hold all municipal, state and federal elections on the same day every five years starting in 2034. Under an amendment by Sen. Carlos Portinho (PL-RJ), senators' eight-year terms would also drop to five, and all 81 seats would be contested together from 2039, according to Agência Senado's account of the vote.
The transition is long. According to Congresso em Foco's summary of the committee report, the reelection ban would first bite on mayors in 2028 and on presidents and governors in 2030. Mayors and councillors elected in 2028 would serve an exceptional six-year term so that the calendars line up. Castro has also said he could accept 10-year Senate terms to keep the staggered renewal of the chamber, the outlet reported.
The second, PEC 4/2026, is Flávio Bolsonaro's. He filed it on March 2, 2026 with 30 senators' signatures, R7 reported. It amends Article 14 of the Constitution so that a president cannot run for the next term, and changes nothing else: governors and mayors keep reelection, terms stay at four years and elections are not unified. The Senate's own tracking page still lists it as awaiting referral.
| Feature | PEC 12/2022 | PEC 4/2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Who loses reelection | President, governors, mayors | President only |
| Term length | Five years for all offices | Unchanged (four years) |
| Unified elections | From 2034 | No |
| Status | Cleared CCJ May 2025 | Awaiting referral |
The table summarizes the texts as described by the Senate's pages, Agência Senado and Congresso em Foco.
Either version needs a constitutional supermajority: at least 49 of 81 senators and 308 of 513 deputies, each in two rounds of voting, as SBT News and Congresso em Foco note.
Where the senators split#
Folha identified three open questions. The first is reach: whether to end reelection only for the president, as Flávio proposed, or also for governors and mayors. The second is term length. The leaders of the MDB, Eduardo Braga (AM), and of the PP-Republicanos bloc, Dr. Hiran (PP-RR), said in the leaders' meeting that they oppose longer terms. "Whoever defends extending terms is disconnected from reality and from voters' feelings," Hiran told Folha (translated from Portuguese). The third is the transition, including how any rule would apply to presidents who have already served, SBT reported.
Sen. Tereza Cristina (PP-MS), the PP leader and a candidate for Senate president, said after a leaders' meeting that the opposition intends to include the end of reelection in the electoral reform but that the topic is not consensual even on her side. "There are sensitive points," she said, according to Folha. Her name appears among the co-signers of Flávio's narrower PEC 4/2026, as do those of Dr. Hiran and Rogério Marinho, according to the Senate record.
Sen. Rogério Marinho (PL-RN), Flávio's campaign coordinator and also a candidate to lead the Senate from February, has been the most emphatic. At the Nov. 4 launch of his candidacy, he said reelection "has become a cancer in our country" and said the PL would vote for the amendment, Folha reported.
The government side has been more guarded. The government's leader in the Senate, Teresa Leitão (PT-PE), would not say whether the Lula administration supports ending reelection. "The government has no position on matters that originate in the Senate," she told Folha, adding that "it is a consensus that the system as it is cannot continue."
What Lula has said#
Lula has not publicly backed the idea, and senators describe him as opposed. Castro said in November 2025 that he had discussed the amendment with the president, who favors keeping reelection. "I think Lula, on this particular point, is not right," Castro said, according to GP1. Congresso em Foco reported that the argument attributed to Lula is that four years is too short to carry out a government program. No direct statement from Lula on the current Senate talks was located for this story.
Flávio, by contrast, had made it a campaign promise. Folha reported that the pledge was partly aimed at São Paulo Governor Tarcísio de Freitas (Republicanos) and Centrão parties: if elected, Flávio would not seek a second term in 2030, leaving the field open to allies. Lula made no such promise and won the runoff.
That history gives the revived debate an unusual alignment. The PL is pushing a reform its candidate championed as a challenger. Lula's Workers' Party (PT) holds the presidency that would be affected, and its Senate leader is keeping the door open. Both camps are part of what Rodrigues called a near-consensus, but neither has yet endorsed a single text.
The arguments#
Supporters of PEC 12/2022 argue that reelection, introduced in 1997, did not deliver better government. In Castro's committee report, as summarized by Congresso em Foco, the chance of a second term pushed executives toward quick electoral payoffs over long-term projects, favored incumbents and kept governments in permanent campaign mode. CCJ chairman Otto Alencar (PSD-BA) called reelection "one of the worst evils for Brazil" when the committee voted, and in May 2026 argued that elections every two years strain the public purse, citing the R$4.9 billion public campaign fund in 2024. Kajuru argued that incumbents enjoy visibility and access to the state machine that make it hard for new leaders to break in.
Flávio's justification for PEC 4/2026 makes a narrower version of the same case: ending consecutive presidential reelection would "strengthen the decision-making independence" of the president and "reduce incentives for the strategic use of the public machine," according to the text quoted by R7.
Opponents make an accountability argument. Without reelection, voters lose the ability to reward a good administration or remove a poor one at the ballot box, and a governor or president in a final term has less electoral incentive to perform, as Congresso em Foco summarized the critics' case. Critics of PEC 12/2022 also say five-year terms prolong bad governments and that unified elections would let presidential politics swamp local races. Marília Arraes (PDT), campaigning for a Senate seat in Pernambuco in August, put it simply: "I don't see reelection as a problem in Brazil. Bolsonaro, for example, ran for reelection and didn't win, because the people didn't choose him. That is democracy," she told the Jornal do Commercio.
Neither side's causal claim has been settled by the evidence cited in these debates. The committee report's argument that reelection worsened governance and critics' argument that it improves accountability both rest on interpretation of Brazil's experience since 1997, not on a single agreed measure.
What voters say#
Representative polling shows a public almost evenly divided, with the answer depending on how the question is asked.
A Datafolha survey for Folha, conducted face to face on Oct. 13-14, 2026 with 2,520 people aged 16 and over in 153 municipalities (margin of error ±2 points, 95% confidence; registered with the electoral court as BR-00466/2026), offered three options for president and governors. Combined, 51% chose a model without reelection, but that majority was split between four-year and five-year single terms. The current four-year term with one reelection was the single most popular option.
Source: Datafolha via Poder360, Oct. 13-14, 2026
Show the numbers
| Model | Share |
|---|---|
| 4 years + one reelection (current) | 46% |
| 4 years, no reelection | 30% |
| 5 years, no reelection | 21% |
| Don't know | 2% |
Support for the current rule differed sharply by group. Among Lula's runoff voters, 59% backed the existing system, compared with 37% of Flávio Bolsonaro's voters. Younger respondents were the most attached to reelection: 69% of those aged 16 to 24 backed the current model, against 36% of those 60 and older.
Source: Datafolha via Poder360, Oct. 13-14, 2026
Show the numbers
| Group | Keep current rule |
|---|---|
| Ages 16-24 | 69% |
| Lula voters | 59% |
| Women | 49% |
| All respondents | 46% |
| Men | 43% |
| Flávio Bolsonaro voters | 37% |
| Ages 60+ | 36% |
An earlier Quaest poll published in July 2025 asked a simpler yes-or-no question about reelection for mayors, governors and president: 49% opposed it and 45% supported it, a technical tie at the edge of the 2-point margin of error, with 6% undecided. Only 49% said they knew a constitutional amendment on the subject was pending. The two polls used different questions and were taken 15 months apart, so they should not be read as a trend.
The decisions ahead for Alcolumbre#
The Senate's party leaders agreed to keep talking through November, according to Folha. The key decisions are Alcolumbre's: whether to put PEC 12/2022 on the floor, adapt it, or fold the issue into the Chamber's reform as he has suggested. The CCJ text has been ready for a floor vote since May 2025, and CCJ chairman Otto Alencar complained in May 2026 that Alcolumbre had not scheduled it despite promising to.
The timing also intersects with the race for the Senate presidency in February 2027, in which Marinho and Tereza Cristina are both candidates, and with the arrival of a new Congress in which the PL holds the largest bloc of deputies. Comparing where Brazil's parties sit on broader issues is possible on the Brazil party spectrum, though support for ending reelection has so far crossed those lines.
The unresolved questions are concrete: whether the ban covers only the president, whether terms grow to five years, and when any change would take effect. Until a text answers them, the near-consensus Rodrigues described is agreement on a goal rather than on a law.
- Constitutional change allows one consecutive reelection for executives
- May 21, 2025Senate CCJ approves PEC 12/2022, ending reelection and setting five-year terms
- Nov. 24, 2025Rapporteur Marcelo Castro says Lula opposes ending reelection
- Mar. 2, 2026Flávio Bolsonaro files PEC 4/2026 for the presidency only, with 30 signatures
- Oct. 13-14, 2026Datafolha finds 46% back the current rule, 51% a single term
- Oct. 25, 2026Lula defeats Flávio Bolsonaro in the runoff
- Nov. 4, 2026Rogério Marinho says the PL will vote to end reelection
- Nov. 15, 2026Folha reports Senate leaders want to revive the amendment
Source: Agência Senado, Senate record of PEC 4/2026, Folha de S.Paulo
Differing perspectives
Should Brazil end consecutive reelection for its president and other elected executives?
Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.
End reelection but keep four-year terms
Who holds it: MDB Senate leader Eduardo Braga and PP-Republicanos bloc leader Dr. Hiran (PP-RR), per their remarks in the leaders' meeting
This group is open to limiting reelection but opposes extending any mandate. They argue that lengthening terms to five years, or ten for senators, would amount to politicians granting themselves more time in office, which they say voters would reject. Dr. Hiran said anyone defending longer terms is disconnected from reality and from voters' feelings, and the group wants any reform to keep the four-year cycle.
In their words: Folha de S.Paulo ↗
End reelection for all executives, with five-year terms
Who holds it: Rapporteur Marcelo Castro (MDB-PI), author Jorge Kajuru (PSB-GO), CCJ chairman Otto Alencar (PSD-BA) and the Senate committee majority
Supporters argue that the reelection rule adopted in 1997 kept presidents, governors and mayors in permanent campaign mode, rewarded quick electoral payoffs over long-term projects and gave incumbents an advantage through visibility and control of the state machine. They say a single five-year term would free executives from the pressure of the next race, while unified elections every five years would cut the cost and disruption of voting every two years.
In their words: Agência Senado ↗
End reelection for the president only
Who holds it: Flávio Bolsonaro (PL-RJ) and the 29 other senators who co-signed PEC 4/2026, including Rogério Marinho (PL-RN)
Backers of the narrower amendment argue that the presidency is where the incumbent advantage is greatest, so barring a consecutive second presidential term would restore alternation in power and reduce incentives to use the public machine for reelection. They say it would make presidential decisions more independent, while leaving governors' and mayors' terms, the four-year cycle and the election calendar untouched, avoiding a wholesale redesign of the system.
In their words: Federal Senate of Brazil ↗
Keep the current one-reelection rule
Who holds it: PDT Senate candidate Marília Arraes; President Lula, according to rapporteur Marcelo Castro
Defenders of the current rule argue that voters, not a constitutional ban, should decide whether an executive stays. Reelection lets the electorate reward a well-run government or remove a poor one, and they point out that Jair Bolsonaro ran for reelection in 2022 and lost. Lula's camp is reported to argue that four years is too short to carry out a government program, and that a single term weakens electoral accountability.
In their words: Jornal do Commercio ↗
Cite this article
567 Politics staff. “Flávio Bolsonaro lost. His plan to end presidential reelection is back in Brazil's Senate.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-16. https://567politics.com/news/brazil-senate-end-reelection-pec-flavio-bolsonaro-lula-november-2026
Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Flávio Bolsonaro lost. His plan to end presidential reelection is back in Brazil's Senate |url=https://567politics.com/news/brazil-senate-end-reelection-pec-flavio-bolsonaro-lula-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-16 |language=en}}CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
"id": "https://567politics.com/news/brazil-senate-end-reelection-pec-flavio-bolsonaro-lula-november-2026",
"type": "article-newspaper",
"title": "Flávio Bolsonaro lost. His plan to end presidential reelection is back in Brazil's Senate",
"URL": "https://567politics.com/news/brazil-senate-end-reelection-pec-flavio-bolsonaro-lula-november-2026",
"container-title": "567politics",
"language": "en",
"author": [
{
"literal": "567 Politics staff"
}
],
"issued": {
"date-parts": [
[
2026,
11,
16
]
]
}
}Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.
Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.
Embed this article summary
Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.
<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/brazil-senate-end-reelection-pec-flavio-bolsonaro-lula-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Flávio Bolsonaro lost. His plan to end presidential reelection is back in Brazil's Senate by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe> <p style="font-size:14px">Flávio Bolsonaro lost. His plan to end presidential reelection is back in Brazil's Senate by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/brazil-senate-end-reelection-pec-flavio-bolsonaro-lula-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p> <script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
READ BEYOND 567POLITICS
Alternate sources & perspectives
Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.
- independent analysis
Senadores retomam debate sobre fim da reeleição à Presidência mesmo após derrota de Flávio Bolsonaro ↗
Folha de S.Paulo
The Nov. 15 report that broke the story: leaders' meeting, Randolfe Rodrigues's prediction of a November vote, Marinho's Nov. 4 remarks, Teresa Leitão's non-position and the split over term length.
- independent analysis
Fim da reeleição une rivais e ganha força no Senado ↗
SBT News
Nov. 16 column reporting that Alcolumbre wants to discuss the issue with Lula and Motta and fold it into the Chamber's political reform; explains the 49-senator and 308-deputy thresholds.
- independent analysis
Líderes do Senado querem debater fim da reeleição, mesmo após derrota de Flávio ↗
OsPoderes
Summary of the same leaders' meeting that notes no consolidated text, no floor date and no minutes of the meeting were found.
- primary evidence
CCJ aprova fim da reeleição, mandatos de cinco anos e eleições unificadas ↗
Agência Senado
The Senate news agency's account of the May 21, 2025 committee vote on PEC 12/2022, with the Portinho amendment, unified elections from 2034 and the arguments of Castro, Otto Alencar and Kajuru.
- primary evidence
Proposta de Emenda à Constituição n° 4, de 2026 ↗
Federal Senate of Brazil
Official record of Flávio Bolsonaro's presidency-only amendment: the 30 signatories, the author's stated rationale and its status as awaiting referral.
- right argument
Flávio reúne assinaturas e protocola PEC que acaba com reeleição para presidente ↗
R7
March 2, 2026 report on the filing of PEC 4/2026, quoting its justification on alternation in power and limiting use of the public machine.
- independent analysis
PEC do fim da reeleição trava há um ano no Senado; Otto cobra votação ↗
Congresso em Foco
May 2026 explainer of the transition rules, the committee report's case for ending reelection, critics' accountability arguments and the position attributed to Lula.
- other perspective
Senador Marcelo Castro diz que presidente Lula é contra o fim da reeleição ↗
GP1
The rapporteur's November 2025 account that Lula favors keeping reelection, and his disagreement with the president.
- left argument
Sabatina SJCC: Marília Arraes diz que atuará pela governabilidade de Lula ↗
Jornal do Commercio
A pro-government Senate candidate's case for keeping reelection: voters should decide whether an executive stays, citing Bolsonaro's 2022 defeat.
- other perspective
Datafolha: 51% apoiam fim da reeleição para presidente e governadores ↗
Poder360
Public-opinion evidence: full Datafolha results from Oct. 13-14, 2026 (n=2,520, ±2 points, TSE BR-00466/2026), with breakdowns by runoff vote, age, sex, income and region.
- other perspective
Quaest: 49% dos brasileiros são contra reeleição e 45%, a favor ↗
g1
Public-opinion evidence: July 2025 Quaest results on a yes-or-no reelection question, showing a technical tie and limited awareness of the pending amendment.
Reviewed 2026-11-16. discover_politics_sources returned only generic Brazil pages (Wikipedia, Britannica, visa and atlas sites), so these sources were hand-picked from pages opened for this story. No minutes of the Senate leaders' meeting and no new filed text were found; accounts of the meeting rely on Folha, SBT News and OsPoderes. No direct, current statement from President Lula on the Senate talks was located; his position is reported second-hand by Senator Marcelo Castro and Congresso em Foco. The full PEC 12/2022 text and CCJ report were not opened directly; their content is described through Agência Senado and Congresso em Foco. The Quaest article did not state the sample size. Brazilian campaign-finance disclosures were not reviewed because the story concerns constitutional rules rather than financial interests.