England and Wales wipe women's abortion records. Opponents say the pardon reaches the gravest late cases
Section 242 of the Crime and Policing Act took effect on November 16, covering convictions, cautions, arrests and investigations; supporters call it overdue justice, while opponents say it erases records in late-term cases.

Women in England and Wales who were convicted of or cautioned for an abortion offense relating to their own pregnancy were automatically pardoned on Monday, November 16. The same provision orders police and courts to delete records of their arrests and investigations, even where no charge followed.
Supporters call it the end of a decades-long injustice for women who faced police over a pregnancy loss or a late abortion. Opponents say the pardon wipes records in the most serious late-term cases and completes a legal change that Parliament made without an impact assessment.
- Commons backs Tonia Antoniazzi's decriminalization clause, 379 to 137
- Lords keep the clause, 185 to 148, and add Baroness Thornton's pardons, 180 to 58
- Commons accepts the Lords pardon amendment without a formal vote
- Crime and Policing Act 2026 receives Royal Assent; decriminalization takes effect
- Commencement regulations set the pardon date
- Section 242 pardons and record deletions take effect
Source: UK Parliament Commons votes, UK Parliament Lords votes, legislation.gov.uk, UK Fact Check (commencement regulations), GOV.UK
What changed on Monday#
Section 242 of the Crime and Policing Act 2026 inserts a new section into the Policing and Crime Act 2017. It applies to a woman, "whether living or deceased", who "when acting in relation to her own pregnancy" was convicted of, cautioned for, arrested for, or investigated on suspicion of an abortion offense. Women who were convicted or cautioned are pardoned. legislation.gov.uk records that the section came into force on November 16, 2026, under S.I. 2026/1090.
The offenses covered are sections 58 and 59 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861, which deal with procuring a miscarriage, and section 1 of the Infant Life (Preservation) Act 1929, the offense of child destruction, according to Ministry of Justice guidance published Monday. Attempts are included.
Women do not need to apply. The guidance says police and courts have already carried out "reasonable searches" and aim to delete or annotate the records they are aware of within one month. Deleted convictions and cautions will not appear on Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) checks, the background checks many employers use, and deleted arrests and investigations will not be disclosed on an enhanced check.
- Pardonautomatic for convictions and cautions from November 16, 2026
- Searchpolice and courts look for records they hold, with no application needed
- Delete or annotatewithin about a month; court records marked "treated as deleted"
- Disclosuredeleted details no longer appear on DBS checks
- Checkwomen can ask the Ministry of Justice casework team to confirm
There are limits written into the law and the guidance:
- The pardon does not cover men, or women who acted in relation to another woman's pregnancy.
- Court records are public and cannot be fully erased, so they will be annotated to show the details are "treated as deleted." The statute itself defines deletion that way for prescribed records.
- Where an abortion offense is tied to another offense outside the section, such as concealing a birth under section 60 of the 1861 Act, police may only be able to amend the record.
- Police will review whether they still have a legal basis to hold fingerprints, DNA or photographs taken during an investigation.
- Authorities will not contact women to tell them; a Ministry of Justice casework team will confirm deletions on request.
The guidance adds that trans men who were acting in relation to their own pregnancy are covered whether or not they hold a Gender Recognition Certificate. The provision applies only in England and Wales.
The pardon follows a broader change. Since Royal Assent on April 29, section 241 of the Act has meant that a woman acting in relation to her own pregnancy commits no abortion offense. The government's announcement stresses that the Abortion Act 1967 still governs access to abortion, and that it remains an offense for medical professionals or anyone else to act outside it. As the BBC noted, abortion with an authorized provider remains legal up to 24 weeks, with narrow exceptions after that, and women can take prescribed pills at home before 10 weeks.
How Parliament voted#
The change began as backbench amendments rather than a government bill clause. On June 17, 2025, MPs approved Labour MP Tonia Antoniazzi's new clause by 379 votes to 137.
In the House of Lords on March 18, 2026, peers rejected Conservative Baroness Monckton of Dallington Forest's amendment to remove the clause by 185 votes to 148. They also rejected Baroness Stroud's amendment to require an in-person consultation before abortion pills are prescribed, by 191 to 119. They then backed Labour peer Baroness Thornton's pardon amendment by 180 to 58.
Source: UK Parliament Commons votes, UK Parliament Lords votes, Lords division 3581, Lords division 3582
Show the numbers
| Motion | For | Against |
|---|---|---|
| Commons: decriminalise (Jun 2025) | 379 | 137 |
| Lords: remove clause (Mar 2026) | 148 | 185 |
| Lords: in-person consultation (Mar 2026) | 119 | 191 |
| Lords: pardons (Mar 2026) | 180 | 58 |
Thornton's explanatory statement, recorded in Hansard, set out the case: because abortion offenses are classed as violent crimes, it said, they "will permanently be disclosed as part of a DBS check." She acknowledged in the chamber that her amendment was "defective" as drafted and said the government would need to fix it before Third Reading. The enacted text differs from her draft; it places the deletion duty directly on data controllers rather than requiring the Secretary of State to issue a notice.
According to SPUC's account of the April debate, the Commons accepted the Lords amendment without a formal vote, and the government remained officially neutral, with minister Sarah Jones saying its role was to make the law workable. Votes on abortion at Westminster are traditionally conscience matters, so the tallies cut across the Labour and Conservative benches.
The case for the pardons#
The government frames the change as finishing what Parliament decided. Pardoning women for offenses related to their own pregnancy "has been a priority and I'm pleased to be able to commence the change that Parliament voted for," said Alex Davies-Jones, the minister for victims and tackling violence against women and girls, in the Ministry of Justice announcement. The ministry said some affected women had spoken about not realizing they were past 24 weeks, or about being victims of domestic abuse or coercive control.
Heidi Stewart, chief executive of the abortion provider BPAS, said in the same release that "no pardon can undo the distress and trauma these women have experienced," but that the change acknowledges the harm their prosecution caused and is "a meaningful step towards justice."
Humanists UK, which backed Thornton's amendment, said around 100 women faced police investigation between 2020 and the change in law, six went to court and one was imprisoned, and that some had suffered miscarriages or stillbirths. Those are the group's figures, not official statistics. "Abortion is healthcare, not a crime," said Karen Wright, its head of policy.
The BBC reported that Antoniazzi says the change will clear the names of more than 100 women "unnecessarily harmed" by an "outdated" law. The BBC cited the case of Nicola Packer, who took pills prescribed over the phone during a Covid lockdown in 2020 and was later found to be around 26 weeks pregnant. Prosecutors alleged she knew she was past 10 weeks, which she denied. A jury acquitted her after a case that, the BBC reported, took five years to reach a verdict.
How many women are affected#
No one knows exactly. The Ministry of Justice equalities impact assessment, published after Royal Assent, counts 26 prosecutions under the relevant offenses from 2017 to 2024, 10 of which ended in convictions. Of the 24 cases where the defendant's sex was recorded, 17 involved men. The assessment says it cannot tell how many of the seven women were acting in relation to their own pregnancy, and that published data does not show how many arrests or investigations there were.
Source: Ministry of Justice equalities impact assessment
Show the numbers
| Defendant's sex | Prosecutions |
|---|---|
| Male | 17 |
| Female | 7 |
The two sets of numbers measure different things. Prosecutions are rare, but the pardon also covers arrests and investigations, which the official data does not count. Humanists UK's figure of about 100 investigations since 2020 and the ministry's seven prosecutions of women since 2017 are therefore not in conflict, though neither gives a complete count.
The case against#
Opponents object to the pardons and to the decriminalization behind them. In April, SPUC chief executive John Deighan said: "This law disgraces the children who have been needlessly destroyed in the past." SPUC reported that Conservative MP Sir Edward Leigh warned the amendment grants "free pardons" in very late cases, citing Sarah Catt, who was jailed after inducing labor at around 40 weeks. Shadow Home Office minister Matt Vickers said the pardon had been "slipped" into the bill without proper scrutiny, SPUC reported.
Right To Life UK argues that the campaign was built on a misleading picture of who was prosecuted. It points to the ministry figures above, which show most prosecutions involved men, and says the extent of the record deletion cannot be quantified. Its spokesperson, Catherine Robinson, called the decriminalization clause "one of the most extreme pieces of legislation ever introduced in Parliament," passed "after just 46 minutes of backbench debate." It says 79 MPs and peers asked ministers to delay commencement until impact assessments were published.
Christian charity CARE opposed the Lords votes in March. Its director of advocacy, Caroline Ansell, said peers had "endorsed a dangerous principle" that "may prove truly terrible in practice," with "more, not fewer, women taking desperate and risky steps to end late term pregnancy." CARE also quoted the Archbishop of Canterbury, Dame Sarah Mullally, who said the change "risks eroding the safeguards and enforcement of those legal limits." Supporters, including Humanists UK and MSI Reproductive Choices UK, say the reform does not change time limits or when clinicians can provide abortions, UK Fact Check reported.
What remains unresolved#
Two questions are still open. The first is reach: officials do not know how many records will be deleted, and the guidance concedes that some paper records may take longer and some details may never be found. The second is effect: the ministry's economic impact assessment assumes "no change in the incidence of abortions post a gestation of 24 weeks" while acknowledging "limited evidence" on the question, and opponents argue removing the criminal deterrent will increase late self-managed abortions. No data yet exists to settle that.
No representative poll on the pardons themselves was located; polls Right To Life UK cites cover related questions such as time limits.
The debate in England and Wales sits alongside other recent fights over abortion law. In Poland, Senate committees backed two bills easing abortion rules as President Karol Nawrocki weighs a veto. In the United States, NBC this month projected passage of Virginia's reproductive freedom amendment and Missouri voters rejected the Amendment 3 abortion ban, while in Idaho a judge paused his ruling on health-based abortions.
Differing perspectives
Should women convicted or investigated over their own pregnancies in England and Wales be pardoned and have records deleted?
Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.
Keep records in late-term cases
Who holds it: SPUC, Sir Edward Leigh MP and shadow Home Office minister Matt Vickers
Opponents argue the pardon removes accountability in the gravest cases, including very late abortions such as the Sarah Catt case, where a judge described the offense as between manslaughter and murder. SPUC says erasing those convictions denies justice to the unborn children involved, and critics in the Commons say the change was added to a government bill without proper scrutiny or a recorded vote.
In their words: SPUC ↗
Pardon the women and delete the records
Who holds it: Ministry of Justice minister Alex Davies-Jones, Baroness Thornton, Tonia Antoniazzi MP, BPAS and Humanists UK
Supporters argue that once Parliament decided women acting over their own pregnancies should not be criminals, past convictions and police records should not keep harming them. They point to women investigated after miscarriages, stillbirths or late abortions, some of them victims of coercive control, and to records that surface on DBS checks for jobs and travel. They say abortion is healthcare and that the 24-week limit for providers is unchanged.
In their words: Humanists UK ↗
Pause and restore safeguards first
Who holds it: Right To Life UK, CARE, Baroness Monckton, Baroness O'Loan and 79 MPs and peers who asked for a delay
This group argues Parliament changed abortion law and wiped records without a prior impact assessment, consultation or evidence sessions. Right To Life UK notes that official figures show most prosecutions involved men and that the scale of record deletion cannot be measured. They say removing the legal deterrent risks more dangerous late self-managed abortions and want the change reassessed, with safeguards such as in-person consultations, before it takes full effect.
In their words: Right To Life UK ↗
Cite this article
567 Politics staff. “England and Wales wipe women's abortion records. Opponents say the pardon reaches the gravest late cases.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-17. https://567politics.com/news/england-wales-abortion-offense-pardons-section-242-records-deleted-november-2026
Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=England and Wales wipe women's abortion records. Opponents say the pardon reaches the gravest late cases |url=https://567politics.com/news/england-wales-abortion-offense-pardons-section-242-records-deleted-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-17 |language=en}}CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
"id": "https://567politics.com/news/england-wales-abortion-offense-pardons-section-242-records-deleted-november-2026",
"type": "article-newspaper",
"title": "England and Wales wipe women's abortion records. Opponents say the pardon reaches the gravest late cases",
"URL": "https://567politics.com/news/england-wales-abortion-offense-pardons-section-242-records-deleted-november-2026",
"container-title": "567politics",
"language": "en",
"author": [
{
"literal": "567 Politics staff"
}
],
"issued": {
"date-parts": [
[
2026,
11,
17
]
]
}
}Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.
Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.
Embed this article summary
Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.
<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/england-wales-abortion-offense-pardons-section-242-records-deleted-november-2026?theme=auto" title="England and Wales wipe women's abortion records. Opponents say the pardon reaches the gravest late cases by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe> <p style="font-size:14px">England and Wales wipe women's abortion records. Opponents say the pardon reaches the gravest late cases by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/england-wales-abortion-offense-pardons-section-242-records-deleted-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p> <script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
READ BEYOND 567POLITICS
Alternate sources & perspectives
Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.
- primary evidence
Crime and Policing Act 2026, section 242 ↗
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives)
Statutory text of the pardon and deletion duty, its England and Wales extent and its commencement on 16 November 2026 under S.I. 2026/1090.
- primary evidence
Section 242 of the Crime and Policing Act 2026: abortion offence pardons ↗
Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK)
Official guidance on scope, offenses covered, record annotation, DBS effects, biometric data and the casework team.
- primary evidence
Women pardoned for abortion offences relating to their own pregnancy ↗
Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK)
Government announcement with quotes from minister Alex Davies-Jones and BPAS chief executive Heidi Stewart.
- primary evidence
Equalities impact assessment: abortion and pardons ↗
Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK)
Source of the 26 prosecutions (2017-2024), 10 convictions and the 17-male, 7-female split, plus the stated data gaps.
- primary evidence
Crime and Policing Act: abortion economic impact assessment ↗
Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK)
States the assumption of no change in abortions after 24 weeks and acknowledges limited evidence.
- primary evidence
Crime and Policing Bill, Lords division on Amendment 426B (pardons) ↗
UK Parliament
Official tally of 180 to 58 for Baroness Thornton's pardon amendment on 18 March 2026.
- other perspective
Humanists UK hails 'landmark day' as women criminalised over abortion offences are pardoned ↗
Humanists UK
Supporters' case in their own words, including their estimate of about 100 women investigated since 2020.
- other perspective
House of Commons votes to pardon all women prosecuted for past illegal abortions ↗
SPUC
Opponents' case against the pardons, with remarks attributed to Sir Edward Leigh and Matt Vickers and SPUC's account of the April Commons stage.
- other perspective
No longer a crime for women to lie to doctors to obtain abortion pills at any stage of pregnancy up to birth, Government admits ↗
Right To Life UK
Opponents' reading of the impact assessments and their call to delay commencement.
- other perspective
Lords move to decriminalise abortion up to birth ↗
CARE
Christian charity's objections to the March Lords votes and the Archbishop of Canterbury's quoted concerns.
- independent analysis
Women's criminal records wiped for abortion offences ↗
BBC News
News report on the pardons, the Nicola Packer case and Tonia Antoniazzi's comments.
- independent analysis
Women convicted of abortion offences over own pregnancies automatically pardoned in England and Wales ↗
UK Fact Check
Legislative history including commencement regulations, Commons Library quotations and the competing estimates of how many women are affected.
Reviewed 2026-11-16. Hand-picked from pages opened on November 16, 2026; the automated source-discovery tool returned only generic abortion explainers. The Commons Library briefing (CBP-10970) could not be retrieved, so its quotations are cited via UK Fact Check. The April 2026 Commons consideration of the Lords amendment is described from SPUC's account; no recorded division was found. Official data do not count arrests or investigations, so no complete count of affected women exists. No representative poll on the pardons was located.