Senate deletes 2027 pension indexation cap and votes to restore the 2023 reform
First-reading votes overnight, 329-0 and 200-129, are not final. A solemn vote on the Social Security bill is set for Wednesday, November 18.

France's Senate took two pension votes in the night of November 16-17, as it continued work on the 2027 Social Security financing bill (PLFSS). Senators first deleted, with no votes against, a government article that would have limited automatic inflation indexation of pensions in 2027. Minutes later, the right-and-center majority voted 200 to 129 to restore the timetable of the 2023 pension reform, against the government's advice.
Neither result is final. Both were first-reading votes. The Senate's solemn vote on the whole bill is set for Wednesday, November 18, from 4:30 p.m. Paris time, according to the chamber's agenda. Public Sénat wrote that the move to restart the 2023 reform has "peu de chances de survivre," given the makeup of the National Assembly and the government's opposition.
The votes come as six unions have called a public-sector strike for November 17. The Senate still has to finish the Social Security bill after earlier adopting its first part.

Source: Sénat, scrutin n°111, Sénat, scrutin n°112
Show the numbers
| Ballot | For | Against | Abstain |
|---|---|---|---|
| Delete the 2027 indexation cap | 329 | 0 | 15 |
| Restore the 2023 reform timetable | 200 | 129 | 13 |
Senators delete the 2027 indexation cap, 329-0#
Article 35 of the government's bill would have departed from the usual rule that pensions are raised in line with inflation. According to Public Sénat, it would have limited automatic indexation in 2027 to pensions of up to €1,260 a month, a measure worth €4 billion to the Social Security accounts. A decree mechanism would have let a future government reverse the freeze quickly.
The official record of scrutin n°111 shows 344 senators voting, 329 for deletion, none against and 15 abstentions. Four senators did not vote. All 14 members of Les Indépendants – République et Territoires abstained, as did Benjamin Huin of the RDPI group, which includes Renaissance senators. Six identical deletion amendments were put to the vote, tabled by the social affairs committee and by senators from the Ecologist, communist (CRCE-K), Socialist and National Rally-affiliated (UNT) groups, and by Gabriel Amard.
In the groups that published a position, Les Républicains (122), Union Centriste (63), the Socialists (62), CRCE-K (18), RDSE (18), 15 RDPI senators, the UNT group (15) and the Ecologists (15) voted for deletion.
- The government's article 35 would have limited automatic 2027 pension indexation to pensions of up to €1,260 a month
- Senators deleted that article, 329-0, on first reading
- The deletion is not finala solemn vote on the whole bill is due on Nov. 18, and the National Assembly still has to act
- Public Sénat noted that if the government later used Article 49.3, it could keep its own version, including the freeze
Source: Sénat, scrutin n°111, Public Sénat
"Dans un contexte d'inflation soutenue, il était insupportable de laisser faire, et de pénaliser les deux tiers des pensions de retraités," said rapporteur Marie-Do Aeschlimann (Les Républicains), as quoted by Public Sénat. In a setting of sustained inflation, it was unbearable to let the measure stand and to penalize two-thirds of retirees' pensions. Public Sénat reported that the Senate majority plans to offset the cost in the 2027 finance bill, which it debates from November 20, by abolishing the 10% income-tax allowance for retirees. The government's bill would instead lower the cap on that allowance from €4,439 to €3,000. Finance committee rapporteur Christine Lavarde (Les Républicains) called the combination "un équilibre socialement plus juste," a socially fairer balance, Public Sénat reported. Communist senator Céline Brulin, in the Senate's official abridged record, called the swap "un cadeau empoisonné," a poisoned gift: what looked like a gift tonight would, she said, make retirees pay more once the tax allowance was removed.
The government gave a "sagesse" opinion on the committee's deletion amendment, leaving the decision to senators. "Si le Sénat, dans sa sagesse, souhaite utiliser les deux véhicules selon ce qui lui paraît le mieux pour les Françaises et les Français, nous sommes prêts, bien sûr, à suivre l'avis du Sénat," Labor and Solidarity Minister Jean-Pierre Farandou said, according to Public Sénat. If the Senate, in its wisdom, wished to use the two bills as it thought best, the government was ready to follow. In the official record he also said that, since 2020, "le seul coût de l'indexation s'élève à 50 milliards d'euros — 4 milliards d'euros de plus, rien que pour 2027." He added that it had always been for lawmakers to take up the two instruments, combine them or amend the draft.
Ecologist senator Anne Souyris told the chamber the measure was unjust because only the basic pension would be under-indexed, so a retiree on €1,300 a month would lose proportionally more than a retiree on €5,000 protected by a complementary pension, Public Sénat reported. Socialist senator Monique Lubin said she could not understand how such a provision could even be presented. The vote is not the last word. Public Sénat noted that if the government later used Article 49.3 of the Constitution, it could keep its own version of the bill, including the pension freeze. The National Assembly has already rejected the revenue section of the 2027 budget. The Social Security bill itself is being examined in the Senate as a text the Assembly is treated as having rejected.

The majority then votes to restart the 2023 reform, 200-129#
Shortly after 12:30 a.m., the Senate took a second vote, on three identical amendments from the social affairs committee, Emmanuel Capus (Horizons, for Les Indépendants) and Martin Lévrier (Renaissance). They added a new article after article 35. According to Public Sénat, it restores a faster timetable for raising the minimum retirement age to 64 and the insurance period to 172 quarters for a full pension. That undoes the suspension of the 2023 reform that Parliament voted last year as part of a deal between the Lecornu government and the Socialists.
The official record of scrutin n°112 shows 342 senators voting, 200 for, 129 against and 13 abstentions. Six senators did not vote. Les Républicains (122) and Les Indépendants (14) voted for, along with 59 Union Centriste senators and 5 RDPI senators. Against were the Socialist (62), CRCE-K (18), Ecologist (15) and UNT (15) groups, 17 RDSE senators and 2 Union Centriste senators. Eleven RDPI senators and 2 Union Centriste senators abstained. Bruno Retailleau, the Les Républicains presidential candidate and a senator, voted for both the deletion of article 35 and the amendment restoring the 2023 timetable.
Source: Sénat, scrutin n°112
Show the numbers
| Group | For | Against | Abstain |
|---|---|---|---|
| Les Républicains | 122 | 0 | 0 |
| Union Centriste | 59 | 2 | 2 |
| Les Indépendants | 14 | 0 | 0 |
| RDPI | 5 | 0 | 11 |
| Socialists | 0 | 62 | 0 |
| CRCE-K | 0 | 18 | 0 |
| RDSE | 0 | 17 | 0 |
| UNT | 0 | 15 | 0 |
| Ecologists | 0 | 15 | 0 |
"Nous rétablissons la réforme des retraites de 2023, suspendue l'an dernier," Aeschlimann told the chamber, according to the Senate's official abridged record: we are restoring the 2023 pension reform, suspended last year. The record has her saying that, over 2026-2032, the suspension would cost "près de 13 milliards d'euros," nearly €13 billion, and that it ran against the need to raise the employment rate in order to finance social protection and the pay-as-you-go system. Public Sénat reported her cost figure as "pas moins de dix milliards d'euros," not less than €10 billion, and said the social affairs committee estimated the change would improve the 2027 Social Security accounts by €600 million. This article uses the official record for her words in the chamber and notes Public Sénat's different wording of the cost.
Lévrier argued for intergenerational solidarity at a time when, he said, there are fewer and fewer working people for more and more people who are not in work. "Nous demandons le dégel du gel," he said, according to the official record. We ask that the freeze be unfrozen.
Farandou opposed the amendment. "Je ne suis pas d'accord pour qu'on suspende la suspension. Un peu de constance dans nos positions…," he said, according to the official record. I do not agree that we should suspend the suspension. A little consistency in our positions. He added that the times may call for a new pension reform, and that almost every presidential candidate has one, including a plan Marine Le Pen presented the same day. He pointed to a conference on work, employment and pensions that, he said, had brought the social partners together for 10 months.
Left-wing senators objected. "La parole a été donnée l'année dernière, avec quelque chose qui doit tenir jusqu'aux prochaines élections présidentielles," Lubin, who sits on the pensions advisory council (COR), said, according to Public Sénat. A commitment was given last year, and it must hold until the next presidential election. She cited the COR's projected €6.8 billion deficit in 2030 to argue that the system has weaknesses but is fundamentally sound. Socialist group leader Patrick Kanner, who took part in last year's talks with the government, said that reopening a major political agreement at that late hour was "une forme d'irresponsabilité," a form of irresponsibility, according to the official record. The general rapporteur, Olivier Henno (Union Centriste), replied: "Nous ne sommes en rien concernés avec cet accord et donc nous suspendons la suspension." The Senate majority, he said, had no part in that agreement, and so was suspending the suspension.
CRCE-K senator Marianne Margaté called the 2023 reform unjust and said it hit first those who started work early or had broken careers. She said the suspension was a slim delay that was still worth preserving, according to the official record.
- The Borne reform raises the legal retirement age toward 64 and the full-rate period toward 172 quarters
- Parliament suspends that timetable in the previous Social Security law, after a deal between the Lecornu government and the Socialists
- Senators delete the 2027 indexation cap, 329-0, then vote 200-129 to restore the 2023 timetable
- The Senate is due to hold a solemn vote on the whole 2027 Social Security bill, from 4:30 p.m. Paris time
Source: Public Sénat, Nov. 17, 2026, Sénat agenda
What is not settled#
The two votes do not enact a new pension law on their own. They amend the Senate's first-reading text of the Social Security bill. That text still has to pass a solemn vote, then a later stage with the Assembly, unless the government rewrites the outcome by using Article 49.3. Public Sénat wrote that the government has left its intentions unclear, and that 49.3 would let it keep the indexation freeze. The same uncertainty hangs over the attempt to restart the 2023 timetable, which the government opposes.
An earlier 567 Politics report described article 35 as still pending after the Senate adopted the first part of the 2027 Social Security budget. That section is now out of date: article 35 has been deleted at first reading, and a new article would restart the 2023 reform. A residence rule in article 37 was still awaiting a vote when that earlier story was reported.
The cost debate is also unfinished. Aeschlimann, in the official record, put the cost of the suspension at nearly €13 billion over 2026-2032. Public Sénat reported a committee estimate of €600 million for the 2027 accounts if the timetable is restored, and a separate €4 billion figure for the indexation freeze that senators rejected. Those figures come from the committee and from official and Public Sénat reporting. They have not been independently recalculated here. The Cour des comptes has separately priced a wider menu of 2027 savings, some of them overlapping with the government's budget.
Hours after the Senate votes, Marine Le Pen presented the National Rally's own pension plan, which would repeal the 2023 law from January 1, 2028 and set a retirement age of 60 to 62. Rival campaigns will have more to say as the presidential race continues. For now, the Senate has recorded two first-reading decisions: it refused to cap inflation indexation in 2027, and its majority tried to put the 2023 reform back on the clock, over the government's objection.
Differing perspectives
Should the Senate restore the 2023 pension timetable and drop the 2027 indexation cap?
Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.
Keep last year's suspension in place
Who holds it: Labor and Solidarity Minister Jean-Pierre Farandou and the government
The government opposes restoring the 2023 timetable in this bill. Farandou told senators he did not agree with suspending the suspension and asked for consistency. He said the times may call for a new pension reform, and that a conference of the social partners had already run for 10 months. On the indexation cap, he gave a 'sagesse' opinion and said the government was ready to follow the Senate if it used the Social Security bill and the finance bill as it thought best.
In their words: French Senate official abridged record ↗
Keep the 2023 timetable frozen
Who holds it: Socialist, communist, Ecologist and National Rally-affiliated senators who voted against restoring the timetable
Opponents say a political agreement last year froze the 2023 timetable until the next presidential election and should be kept. Patrick Kanner, who took part in those talks, called reopening the deal at that late hour a form of irresponsibility. Monique Lubin said a commitment was given last year and must hold, and she cited the pensions council's projected deficit to argue that the system is under strain but fundamentally sound. They voted to delete the indexation cap, then voted against restoring the 2023 timetable.
In their words: French Senate public ballot, scrutin n°112 ↗
Restore the 2023 reform timetable
Who holds it: The Senate's right-and-center majority, including social affairs rapporteur Marie-Do Aeschlimann and general rapporteur Olivier Henno
Supporters say last year's suspension of the 2023 reform is costly and works against a higher employment rate needed to fund pay-as-you-go pensions. Aeschlimann told the chamber the Senate is restoring the 2023 reform, which she said would cost nearly €13 billion over 2026-2032 if left suspended. Henno said the Senate majority was not a party to last year's deal with the Socialists, and so was suspending the suspension. They also voted to drop the 2027 indexation cap.
In their words: Public Sénat ↗
Cite this article
567 Politics staff. “Senate deletes 2027 pension indexation cap and votes to restore the 2023 reform.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-17. https://567politics.com/news/france-senate-pension-votes-indexation-cap-2023-reform-november-2026
Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Senate deletes 2027 pension indexation cap and votes to restore the 2023 reform |url=https://567politics.com/news/france-senate-pension-votes-indexation-cap-2023-reform-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-17 |language=en}}CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
"id": "https://567politics.com/news/france-senate-pension-votes-indexation-cap-2023-reform-november-2026",
"type": "article-newspaper",
"title": "Senate deletes 2027 pension indexation cap and votes to restore the 2023 reform",
"URL": "https://567politics.com/news/france-senate-pension-votes-indexation-cap-2023-reform-november-2026",
"container-title": "567politics",
"language": "en",
"author": [
{
"literal": "567 Politics staff"
}
],
"issued": {
"date-parts": [
[
2026,
11,
17
]
]
}
}Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.
Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.
Embed this article summary
Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.
<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/france-senate-pension-votes-indexation-cap-2023-reform-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Senate deletes 2027 pension indexation cap and votes to restore the 2023 reform by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe> <p style="font-size:14px">Senate deletes 2027 pension indexation cap and votes to restore the 2023 reform by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/france-senate-pension-votes-indexation-cap-2023-reform-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p> <script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
READ BEYOND 567POLITICS
Alternate sources & perspectives
Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.
- primary evidence
Public ballot n°111 on deleting PLFSS article 35 ↗
French Senate
Official result: article 35 deleted 329-0, with recorded abstentions.
- primary evidence
Public ballot n°112 on restoring the 2023 pension timetable ↗
French Senate
Official result: 200 for, 129 against, against the government's opinion.
- primary evidence
Abbreviated Senate record, sitting of Nov. 16, 2026 ↗
French Senate
Includes Labour Minister Farandou's remarks on the two amendments.
- primary evidence
Senate agenda ↗
French Senate
Lists the Nov. 18 solemn vote from 4:30 p.m.
- independent analysis
Senate votes complete pension indexation in 2027 ↗
Public Sénat
Report of the article 35 deletion and Farandou's 'sagesse' opinion.
- independent analysis
Senate votes to reactivate the 2023 pension reform, against the government ↗
Public Sénat
Report of the 200-129 vote and the chamber's political arithmetic.
Reviewed 2026-11-17. Hand-picked on Nov. 17, 2026, from pages opened for the Senate overnight pension-vote story. Official Senate ballot pages and the abbreviated record were opened in full. Public Sénat reports were opened. discover_politics_sources was not used for this list.