Chikli asks Sa'ar to strip activist Andrey X of Israeli citizenship over his posts
The Diaspora minister calls the activist's posts a smear campaign. He says he is punished for documenting abuses. Only a court can revoke citizenship.

Israel's minister for Diaspora affairs, Amichai Chikli, has asked Interior Minister Gideon Sa'ar to move to strip the citizenship of Andrey Khrzhanovskiy, a Russian-born activist known online as Andrey X. Chikli says the activist runs a "systematic" campaign on social media to defame Israel and its soldiers.
Khrzhanovskiy, 28, documents settler violence and army raids in the West Bank and has about 700,000 followers on social media, according to JNS. He moved to Israel from Russia in 2022 under the Law of Return. He answered on X on Monday by mocking the request and saying it was an attempt to punish him for "documenting your crimes."
The request, sent on Monday, November 16, is not a decision. Under Israeli law, only a court can revoke citizenship on the grounds of a breach of loyalty, at the interior minister's request and with the attorney general's written consent. Neither Sa'ar nor the Interior Ministry had publicly responded when this story was written.
What Chikli asked for#
Chikli serves as minister of Diaspora affairs and combating antisemitism. In his letter, reported by Walla (Hebrew), he asked Sa'ar "to use his authority" to act on Khrzhanovskiy's citizenship. He wrote that a preliminary check showed Khrzhanovskiy is a Russian-born citizen who came under the Law of Return, apparently in 2022, out of fear of political persecution in Russia.
Chikli alleged that Khrzhanovskiy uses his X account for "a systematic and extensive delegitimization campaign involving misinformation, distortion of facts and the dissemination of false and biased reports against Israel and its security forces," according to the Jerusalem Post. He said the activity goes beyond legitimate criticism and is meant to "damage Israel's international standing, defame its citizens and soldiers, and incite hatred and violence."
The letter attached examples of posts. In one, Khrzhanovskiy said Israel was founded through "murder, rape, and ethnic cleansing" and called it the least safe place in the world for Jews. In another, replying to a post about the death of an Israeli soldier, he accused the army of massacring Lebanese and Palestinian civilians, Walla reported.
The letter also noted that Khrzhanovskiy was arrested on October 28, 2026, over his alleged involvement in a violent incident in the West Bank. An order was then issued barring him from the area until January 1, 2027. The reports did not describe the incident in detail, and no charge had been reported.
"Israel is the home of the Jewish people, and it opened its doors to Khrzhanovskiy when he sought to leave Russia," Chikli said in a statement. "Freedom of expression allows everyone to voice criticism, but in this case, Khrzhanovskiy's activities constitute a systematic campaign to defame Israel and IDF soldiers and portray them as criminals. I will not stand idly by in the face of such activity."
Chikli said he had therefore asked the interior minister to act "in accordance with the law." Chikli confirmed the request to JNS.

How Andrey X responded#
Khrzhanovskiy answered in two posts on X on Monday morning. "Dozens of journalists are asking me for comment," he wrote in the first post. "Since Amichai Shikli is a Minister of Diaspora, I suggest that he immediately calls for instituting a Law of Return for the Palestinian refugees, living in the diaspora since 1948. And if that would result in overpopulation, we can revoke Amichai Shikli's citizenship to compensate, and put him on a plane straight to the Hague, together with his colleagues in the government."
In a second post, he rejected the way the request described his work. "I didn't 'accuse Israel of ethnic cleansing,' I documented Israel committing ethnic cleansing," he wrote. He said that was why the government wanted to revoke his citizenship and why it had banned him from the West Bank. He also accused Israel of killing hundreds of Palestinian journalists in Gaza and of jailing and torturing Palestinian journalists in the West Bank. "For documenting your crimes," he wrote.
Those are his allegations, which Israel's government rejects. Haaretz reported that he accused the government of trying to silence journalists.
- Arrives in Israel from Russia under the Law of Return
- Begins working with human rights groups in the West Bank
- Arrested for a sticker on a soldier's memorial in Sderot; released with a 30-day ban
- Tells NEWSru he will not give up Israeli citizenship
- Arrested over an alleged violent incident in the West Bank
- Chikli asks Sa'ar to act to revoke his citizenship
- Order barring him from the West Bank is due to end
Source: Walla (Hebrew), NEWSru.co.il (Russian), Jerusalem Post
Who Andrey Khrzhanovskiy is#
Khrzhanovskiy was born in St. Petersburg. He is the son of the Russian film director Ilya Khrzhanovsky and the grandson of the animation director Andrey Khrzhanovsky, Walla reported. He holds an anthropology degree from University College London. According to his author page on the Israeli-Palestinian site +972 Magazine, as cited by Walla, he worked with Russian opposition media and covered politics in the former Soviet Union.
He has said in interviews that he arrived in Israel in February 2022 after leaving Russia for fear of political harassment. He later told The New Arab that Russia's invasion of Ukraine pushed him to leave, and that Israeli citizenship was the most available option, according to Walla.
He began working with human rights groups in the West Bank in early 2023. He takes part in "protective presence," in which activists stay with Palestinian communities exposed to violence and the risk of displacement, and posts videos and reports from the field. JNS reported that he is based in Beit Jala, a town under Palestinian Authority control near Bethlehem.
He describes himself on X as an "independent journalist and human rights advocate based in the West Bank in occupied Palestine," the Jerusalem Post reported. He has called the Law of Return, under which he became a citizen, "colonial."
He has been detained before. In December 2024, he was arrested after placing a "Free Palestine" sticker on a memorial to a fallen soldier in Sderot, the Russian-language site NEWSru.co.il reported. A court released him and barred him from approaching memorial sites for 30 days. In a September 2025 interview with the same site, he said he did not intend to give up his Israeli citizenship despite rejecting the state's policies.
Chikli's letter also said Khrzhanovskiy's video material was used in an Amnesty International report on the West Bank, NEWSru reported.
What the law allows#
Section 11 of Israel's Nationality Law (Hebrew) sets out when citizenship can be revoked. The interior minister alone may cancel citizenship obtained through false information, but only within three years. In other cases, the decision belongs to an administrative court, at the minister's request.
The court may revoke citizenship for "a breach of loyalty to the State of Israel." The law defines that as one of three things: an act of terrorism, helping one, or taking an active part in a terrorist organization; treason or serious espionage under the Penal Code; or acquiring citizenship or permanent residency in one of several listed states, such as Iran, Syria or Lebanon. A request on these grounds cannot be filed without the attorney general's written consent. If revocation would leave the person with no citizenship or permanent status in the Palestinian territories, the law says the person must be given a permit to live in Israel.
A 2023 amendment added a faster track for people convicted of terrorism who received payments from the Palestinian Authority for their acts.
- Requestthe interior minister decides whether to seek revocation
- Consentthe attorney general must agree in writing before any filing
- Courtan administrative court hears the case, with the citizen present
- Groundsterrorism, treason, serious espionage, or citizenship in a listed state
- Limita person left stateless must be given a permit to live in Israel
Source: Nationality Law, Section 11 (Hebrew Wikisource), Jerusalem Post
The Jerusalem Post noted that the law does not allow revocation simply because someone changed their religion, political views or lifestyle after immigrating. In July 2022, Israel's Supreme Court upheld the power to revoke citizenship for breach of loyalty, but said it should be used only in exceptional and especially serious cases, the paper reported. It said it knew of no case in which an immigrant under the Law of Return had lost citizenship this way.
Chikli's public statements did not name which ground in Section 11 he believes applies. The posts quoted in his letter are speech. The October arrest has not led to a reported charge.
The wider debate#
Proposals to revoke citizenship over loyalty have come up in the Knesset many times. A policy study for the Israel Democracy Institute (Hebrew), a Jerusalem think tank, argued that the power to revoke citizenship for a breach of loyalty should be abolished. It said most democracies deal with treason and terrorism only through criminal law, and warned of selective enforcement against Arab citizens. It also addressed the "defensive democracy" argument made by supporters of such powers, that a state must act against those who use democratic freedoms against it, and said that argument did not justify them.
The request comes as Sa'ar takes on a new role. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu tapped Gideon Sa'ar, the foreign minister, to also run the Interior Ministry, as 567 Politics reported in its story on the 16-month vacancy at the ministry. Chikli and Netanyahu both belong to Likud.
The case also touches on the role of foreign and Israeli activists in the West Bank during this year's olive harvest. Israeli authorities arrested activists during the harvest, while the UN reported a record number of settler attacks, as covered in our report on the olive harvest. Questions of speech and security also arose in this week's conviction of journalist Saeed Hassanain, though that case involved criminal charges.
What is not yet known#
It is not known whether Sa'ar will act on the request, or whether the attorney general would consent to a court filing. No legal process to revoke Khrzhanovskiy's citizenship had been reported as of Monday, NEWSru said. Khrzhanovskiy has not said whether he would contest any filing in court, though he has said in the past that he wants to keep his citizenship.
Differing perspectives
Should Israel seek to revoke Andrey Khrzhanovskiy's citizenship over his social media posts and activism?
Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.
Repeal revocation for breach of loyalty
Who holds it: Authors of an Israel Democracy Institute policy study on citizenship revocation
The Israel Democracy Institute study argues that revoking citizenship for a breach of loyalty does not fit democratic practice, where treason and terrorism are handled through criminal law. It says the loyalty ground is vague, that international law bars revocation on political grounds, and that the power carries a real risk of selective enforcement. It finds little practical benefit, rejects the defensive-democracy argument for such powers, and recommends repealing them.
In their words: Israel Democracy Institute (Hebrew) ↗
Revoke his citizenship under the law
Who holds it: Diaspora Affairs and Combating Antisemitism Minister Amichai Chikli (Likud)
Chikli argues that Israel, as the home of the Jewish people, opened its doors to Khrzhanovskiy when he left Russia, and that his posts are not ordinary criticism. He says the activist runs a systematic and extensive campaign on X that spreads false and biased reports, accuses Israel of genocide, apartheid and ethnic cleansing, and portrays soldiers as criminals, with the aim of damaging Israel's standing and inciting hatred and violence. He says the interior minister should act under the law.
In their words: The Jerusalem Post (Chikli's statement and letter) ↗
The request punishes him for documenting abuses
Who holds it: Andrey Khrzhanovskiy (Andrey X)
Khrzhanovskiy argues that he did not merely accuse Israel of ethnic cleansing but documented it as a journalist and human rights advocate in the West Bank. He says the request to revoke his citizenship, like the order banning him from the West Bank, is a response to that documentation. He links it to what he describes as the killing and jailing of Palestinian journalists, and says the government wants to silence those who record what he calls its crimes.
In their words: Andrey Khrzhanovskiy on X ↗
Cite this article
567 Politics staff. “Chikli asks Sa'ar to strip activist Andrey X of Israeli citizenship over his posts.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-16. https://567politics.com/news/israel-chikli-asks-saar-revoke-citizenship-andrey-x-khrzhanovskiy-nationality-law-november-2026
Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Chikli asks Sa'ar to strip activist Andrey X of Israeli citizenship over his posts |url=https://567politics.com/news/israel-chikli-asks-saar-revoke-citizenship-andrey-x-khrzhanovskiy-nationality-law-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-16 |language=en}}CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
"id": "https://567politics.com/news/israel-chikli-asks-saar-revoke-citizenship-andrey-x-khrzhanovskiy-nationality-law-november-2026",
"type": "article-newspaper",
"title": "Chikli asks Sa'ar to strip activist Andrey X of Israeli citizenship over his posts",
"URL": "https://567politics.com/news/israel-chikli-asks-saar-revoke-citizenship-andrey-x-khrzhanovskiy-nationality-law-november-2026",
"container-title": "567politics",
"language": "en",
"author": [
{
"literal": "567 Politics staff"
}
],
"issued": {
"date-parts": [
[
2026,
11,
16
]
]
}
}Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.
Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.
Embed this article summary
Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.
<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/israel-chikli-asks-saar-revoke-citizenship-andrey-x-khrzhanovskiy-nationality-law-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Chikli asks Sa'ar to strip activist Andrey X of Israeli citizenship over his posts by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe> <p style="font-size:14px">Chikli asks Sa'ar to strip activist Andrey X of Israeli citizenship over his posts by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/israel-chikli-asks-saar-revoke-citizenship-andrey-x-khrzhanovskiy-nationality-law-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p> <script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
READ BEYOND 567POLITICS
Alternate sources & perspectives
Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.
- independent analysis
Israel seeks to revoke citizenship of Russian-born citizen over anti-IDF posts ↗
The Jerusalem Post
Chikli's statement, the activist's reply and an explainer on Section 11 and the 2022 Supreme Court ruling.
- independent analysis
Israeli diaspora minister moves to strip 'Andrey X' of citizenship ↗
JNS
Chikli's confirmation of the request; the activist's age, base in Beit Jala and follower count.
- independent analysis
Israeli Minister Seeks to Revoke Andrey X's Citizenship Over Online Criticism of Israel ↗
Haaretz
Report on the request and the activist's charge that the government seeks to silence journalists; paywalled.
- independent analysis
Against the background of statements against Israel and the IDF: request filed to revoke a social media figure's citizenship (Hebrew) ↗
Walla
Most detailed account of Chikli's letter and Khrzhanovskiy's background.
- other perspective
Chikli to Sa'ar: revoke the citizenship of the activist who accuses Israel of genocide (Hebrew) ↗
Channel 14
Report supportive of the request, citing the October arrest and West Bank order.
- independent analysis
Request filed to revoke an Israeli's citizenship over his activity against IDF soldiers (Hebrew) ↗
Kol Rega
Hebrew report quoting the letter's examples of posts.
- independent analysis
Appeal filed to the interior minister demanding Andrey Khrzhanovsky be stripped of Israeli citizenship (Russian) ↗
NEWSru.co.il
Background on his December 2024 arrest and September 2025 interview; says no legal process had begun.
- other perspective
Andrey X: comment on the demand to revoke my citizenship ↗
Andrey Khrzhanovskiy on X
His first public response, November 16, 2026.
- other perspective
Andrey X: 'I documented Israel committing ethnic cleansing' ↗
Andrey Khrzhanovskiy on X
His second post, rejecting the request's description of his work.
- primary evidence
Nationality Law, 1952, Section 11: revocation of citizenship (Hebrew) ↗
Hebrew Wikisource
Current text of the grounds, the court process and the attorney general's consent requirement.
- other perspective
Revoking citizenship for breach of loyalty: policy study findings (Hebrew) ↗
Israel Democracy Institute
Study recommending repeal of revocation for breach of loyalty.
- independent analysis
Revocation of citizenship for breach of loyalty: opinion (Hebrew) ↗
Israel Democracy Institute
2010 critique of proposals to widen revocation powers and of the 2008 amendment.
Reviewed 2026-11-16. Compiled 2026-11-16 from pages opened and read; discover_politics_sources was not useful for this story (it returned only generic homepages on other stories in this run), so every source was chosen by hand. Chikli's letter itself was not published; its contents are cited through Walla, the Jerusalem Post, NEWSru and JNS, which agree on its main points. Khrzhanovskiy's response is cited from his own two X posts of November 16. Neither Interior Minister Sa'ar nor the Interior Ministry had responded publicly. No charge from the October 28 arrest had been reported. The law is cited from the current Hebrew text of Section 11 of the Nationality Law. Hebrew and Russian sources are labeled.