Skip to content
567politics.

Brazil

Poll: 92% of Brazilian voters back lowering the criminal age to 16 as a Chamber vote nears

The Quaest survey also finds support for the death penalty and for jailing abortion has fallen since 2023, while the camps split sharply on guns.

By 567 Politics staffPublished 10 min read

Brazil's National Congress in Brasília, January 2024. The Chamber of Deputies is weighing PEC 32/2015, which would lower the age of criminal responsibility to 16.
Brazil's National Congress in Brasília, January 2024. The Chamber of Deputies is weighing PEC 32/2015, which would lower the age of criminal responsibility to 16. · Photo: Agência Senado via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 ↗

Nine in 10 Brazilian voters say they back lowering the age of criminal responsibility from 18 to 16, a Quaest survey released on November 16 found. The result lands about two weeks before the deputy in charge of the Chamber's version of the idea plans to present his report. The same survey found 64% support for the death penalty in cases such as murder and rape, a measure Brazil's Constitution bars in peacetime.

The poll was commissioned by the newspaper O Globo and fielded in person from October 30 to November 2. Quaest interviewed 2,004 voters aged 16 and older. It reports a margin of error of 2 percentage points at a 95% confidence level, according to g1, which also belongs to the Globo group.

The headline number is large, but it answers a narrower question than the one before Congress. Lawmakers are not choosing between 16 and 18 alone. They are weighing whether a lower age should apply to every crime, to a list of the gravest crimes, or not at all, and whether teenagers would serve time apart from adults.

What the survey found#

Quaest asked whether people agree or disagree with a set of statements on security and social values. Support for a lower criminal age tied with support for body cameras on police uniforms, at 92% each. Clear majorities rejected easier access to guns and the legalization and regulation of marijuana sales.

Brazilians back a lower criminal age and police cameras, but reject easier gunsShare of Brazilian voters 16 and older who agree with each proposal, Oct. 30 to Nov. 2, 2026 (n=2,004, margin of error ±2 points)

Source: g1, Nov. 16, 2026, Valor Econômico, Nov. 16, 2026

Show the numbers
ProposalAgree
Lower criminal age to 1692%
Body cameras on police92%
Death penalty for murder, rape64%
Jail women who have abortions45%
Privatize public health, schools28%
Make guns easier to buy28%
Legalize, regulate marijuana26%
Share this chartPost

The views on abortion were split. Some 45% agreed that a woman who has an abortion should be jailed, while 49% disagreed. On privatizing public health and education, 64% disagreed.

The survey also asked people where they place themselves. Some 39% said they are at the center, 34% on the right and 24% on the left. Valor reported that the center share is the highest in a series that starts in 2007. Quaest built the early years from the Latin American Public Opinion Project's surveys, using the same method. On values, 48% called themselves conservative, 23% progressive and 28% neither.

The poll is part of Quaest's post-election series, "O Brasil depois das urnas." CNN Brasil's report and an Estadão wire story on UOL carried the same core figures. Quaest had not posted the full report on its reports page when this article was written. So the exact question wording and full tables could not be checked.

Where support has fallen#

Support remains high for several hard-line measures, but it has slipped since late 2023. Valor compared the new results with Quaest's December 2023 survey. Backing for the death penalty fell from 77% to 64%. Support for jailing women who have abortions fell from 52% to 45%. Support for privatizing public health and schools fell from 45% to 28%.

Support for the death penalty and for jailing abortion has fallen since 2023Share of Brazilian voters who agree, Quaest surveys, December 2023 vs. Oct. 30 to Nov. 2, 2026

Source: Valor Econômico, Nov. 16, 2026

Show the numbers
ProposalDec. 2023Nov. 2026
Death penalty for murder, rape77%64%
Jail women who have abortions52%45%
Privatize public health, schools45%28%
Share this chartPost

Quaest's director, Felipe Nunes, said these shifts help explain the growth of voters who call themselves neither conservative nor progressive. That group made up 19% of voters in December 2023 and 18% in August 2026, before the campaign. It now stands at 28%. That is his reading. The survey alone cannot prove what caused the change.

How the political camps differ#

Quaest split voters into five groups. Independents were the largest, at 32%. Next came the non-Bolsonaro right at 21%, supporters of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva at 19%, the non-Lula left at 14% and Bolsonaro supporters at 12%. The country's recent vote shows why those groups matter: Lula won the October runoff 51.8% to 48.2%.

On the criminal age, the gap between camps was small. Support ranged from 98% among Bolsonaro supporters to 86% on the non-Lula left, g1 reported. Guns split the camps far more. Some 49% of Bolsonaro supporters backed easier gun purchases, compared with 13% of Lula supporters and 13% of the non-Lula left.

Abortion produced an unusual pattern. More Lula supporters than members of the non-Bolsonaro right agreed that women who have abortions should be jailed.

Half of Lula's own supporters say women who have abortions should be jailedShare who agree a woman who has an abortion should be jailed, by political group, Oct. 30 to Nov. 2, 2026

Source: Valor Econômico, Nov. 16, 2026

Show the numbers
GroupAgree
Bolsonaro supporters64%
Lula supporters52%
Non-Bolsonaro right48%
Non-Lula left28%
Share this chartPost

Nunes wrote, in Portuguese, that the Lula electorate "should not be confused with the left," Valor reported. Some 41% of Lula supporters called themselves conservative and 29% progressive. Among Bolsonaro supporters, 69% said they were conservative. These are subgroup figures, so their margins of error are wider than the 2 points for the full sample. The published reports do not give them.

The fight in Congress#

The poll arrives as the Chamber of Deputies works on PEC 32/2015, a constitutional amendment that would set the age of criminal responsibility at 16. Its rapporteur, Deputy Mendonça Filho of the Liberal Party, or PL, told a hearing on November 11 that "every opinion poll" shows average support above 80%. He will take his report to party leaders and Chamber President Hugo Motta on December 1, the Chamber's news agency reported. A committee vote could follow in early December.

Mendonça Filho has said teenagers convicted under a new rule should serve time in units separate from adult prisons. He has also floated a referendum in 2028 to confirm the change, CNN Brasil reported. Committee chair Aluísio Mendes favors 16 as a general rule.

How Brazil's criminal-age debate reached December
  1. Senate committee sends PL 1,473/2025 on longer youth detention to the Chamber
  2. Senate splits the age question from its security amendment, 38 to 36
  3. Alcolumbre says the Senate will wait for the Chamber's PEC 32/2015
  4. Rapporteur Mendonça Filho moves his report to December 1
  5. Quaest poll shows 92% support for an age of 16
  6. Report due to party leaders; Braga's proposed Senate deadline

Source: Agência Senado, Agência Câmara

The Senate took up the issue first and then set it aside. On November 3 it split the age question from its public security amendment by a vote of 38 to 36, as 567 Politics reported at the time. The split produced two separate proposals. PEC 19/2026, from PL Senator Rogério Marinho, would set 16 as the general age and 14 for heinous crimes. PEC 20/2026, from Senator Camilo Santana of the Workers' Party, or PT, would lower the age to 16 only for heinous crimes.

Senate President Davi Alcolumbre agreed to wait for the Chamber. Senator Eduardo Braga of the MDB proposed December 1 as a deadline, after which the Senate would vote on its own texts.

The case against#

Opponents say the poll measures frustration with crime, not the best policy. UNICEF Brazil argued in a June statement that adult prisons would expose teenagers to organized crime. It cited a National Justice Council study that found reoffending among adults about double the rate in the juvenile system. It also noted that Brazil already holds children accountable from age 12 under its youth law.

Youths reoffend at half the rate of adults, UNICEF saysShare who are apprehended or jailed again, juvenile system vs. adult prisons, per a 2019 National Justice Council study cited by UNICEF Brazil

Source: UNICEF Brazil, June 12, 2026

Show the numbers
SystemReoffend
Juvenile system20%
Adult prisons40%
Share this chartPost

At the November 11 hearing, prosecutor Danielle Tuoto said juvenile units have open places while adult prisons are overcrowded. A member of the national children's rights council, Conanda, called for prevention and gun control instead. Retired judge Ludmila Lins Grilo argued the other side. She said 16-year-olds can vote and work, so they can understand that a crime is a crime.

A third route would toughen youth sentences without changing the Constitution. PL 1,473/2025, passed by the Senate in 2025, would raise the maximum juvenile detention from three years to five, and to 10 for violent or heinous acts. The bill came from PT Senator Fabiano Contarato, and PL Senator Flávio Bolsonaro was its rapporteur, so it drew support across the divide. It now sits in the Chamber. Senator Alessandro Vieira of the MDB argues it would survive court challenges that an amendment might not.

A legal question as well as a political one#

Brazil's National Congress in Brasília, January 2024. Photo: Agência Senado via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

The age of 18 is written into Article 228 of the Constitution. Article 60 says no amendment may even be considered if it tends to abolish individual rights and guarantees. Some jurists argue the age rule is one of those guarantees, which would put it beyond the reach of Congress. Others argue it is an ordinary rule that an amendment can change, as the Senate's news service summarized during the November debate.

That dispute shapes strategy. If the Supreme Court later struck down an amendment, a law changing juvenile detention would still stand. That is the reasoning behind the youth-law route. Supporters of an amendment answer that only a constitutional change can treat older teenagers as adults, and that public opinion strongly favors doing so. Mendonça Filho's referendum idea is partly an answer to the legal objection: he said popular approval would "end this discussion" about whether the change is constitutional.

Timing matters too. A new Congress takes office in February 2027. It is expected to be less friendly to the government, and 567 Politics has reported that Lula begins his fourth term with the smallest core of allies since Fernando Collor. A vote this year would be cast by the outgoing Congress.

What the numbers cannot settle#

A 92% result shows broad support for the idea, not for any one text. The published reports do not say whether respondents were asked about all crimes or only serious ones, or about where teenagers would be held. Those details divide Congress.

The sample also has limits worth stating. It covers Brazilian voters aged 16 and older, not all residents. The 2-point margin applies to the full sample only. Single polls can also differ from others because of wording and order of questions. Mendonça Filho's own figure, an average above 80%, suggests other surveys have found lower but still strong support. This article did not review those other polls, so it does not compare them.

The death penalty finding is also separate from the age debate. The Constitution bans capital punishment except in a declared war. That ban sits in Article 5, the chapter on individual rights that Article 60 shields from amendments that would abolish them. A poll result does not change that.

For how Brazil's parties line up on these issues, see the Brazil party spectrum, shown as dated editorial estimates.

Photo: Agência Senado, January 2024, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped for this article; licensed CC BY 2.0.

Differing perspectives

Should Brazil lower the age of criminal responsibility from 18 to 16?

Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.

  • Keep 18 and strengthen the youth system

    Who holds it: UNICEF Brazil; Conanda, the national children's rights council; prosecutor Danielle Tuoto

    UNICEF argues that adolescents are not driving violence and are far more often its victims, noting that police apprehensions of adolescents fell by more than 35% from 2019 to 2024. It cites a National Justice Council study finding that about 2 in 10 youths reoffend after the juvenile system, versus 4 in 10 adults. Putting teenagers in adult prisons, it says, exposes them to organized crime. Brazil already holds children accountable from age 12.

    In their words: UNICEF Brazil ↗

  • Lengthen youth detention instead

    Who holds it: Senators Fabiano Contarato (PT) and Flávio Bolsonaro (PL), author and rapporteur of PL 1,473/2025; Senator Alessandro Vieira (MDB)

    This camp would change the Child and Adolescent Statute rather than the Constitution. The Senate-passed bill raises the maximum juvenile detention from three to five years, and up to 10 for violent or heinous acts, adds custody hearings within 24 hours and keeps young adults out of adult prisons. Vieira argues that an ordinary law delivers a result, while an amendment touching a clause some jurists consider protected could be struck down.

    In their words: Agência Senado ↗

  • Lower it only for heinous crimes

    Who holds it: Senator Camilo Santana (PT), author of PEC 20/2026, and government-aligned lawmakers

    This camp would amend Article 228 so that 16- and 17-year-olds answer as adults only for crimes the law classifies as heinous, while 18 remains the age for every other offense. Santana's proposal was split off from the public security amendment on November 3 and was seen in the Senate as the version most likely to reach consensus. It offers a tougher response to the gravest crimes without moving most young offenders into the adult prison system.

    In their words: Agência Senado ↗

  • Lower it to 16 for all crimes

    Who holds it: Deputy Mendonça Filho (PL), rapporteur of PEC 32/2015; committee chair Aluísio Mendes; retired judge Ludmila Lins Grilo

    Supporters argue that 16- and 17-year-olds can vote, work and testify, so they can understand that violent acts are crimes. Mendonça Filho says polls show average support above 80% and that society has matured on the issue. He proposes that teenagers serve sentences in units separate from adult prisons, with stronger protection for victims and tougher punishment for serious crimes. Grilo argues the three-year cap on juvenile detention makes teenagers attractive recruits for criminal factions.

    In their words: Agência Câmara de Notícias ↗

Cite this article

567 Politics staff. “Poll: 92% of Brazilian voters back lowering the criminal age to 16 as a Chamber vote nears.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-16. https://567politics.com/news/brazil-quaest-poll-92-percent-criminal-age-16-pec-32-death-penalty-november-2026

Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Poll: 92% of Brazilian voters back lowering the criminal age to 16 as a Chamber vote nears |url=https://567politics.com/news/brazil-quaest-poll-92-percent-criminal-age-16-pec-32-death-penalty-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-16 |language=en}}
CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
  "id": "https://567politics.com/news/brazil-quaest-poll-92-percent-criminal-age-16-pec-32-death-penalty-november-2026",
  "type": "article-newspaper",
  "title": "Poll: 92% of Brazilian voters back lowering the criminal age to 16 as a Chamber vote nears",
  "URL": "https://567politics.com/news/brazil-quaest-poll-92-percent-criminal-age-16-pec-32-death-penalty-november-2026",
  "container-title": "567politics",
  "language": "en",
  "author": [
    {
      "literal": "567 Politics staff"
    }
  ],
  "issued": {
    "date-parts": [
      [
        2026,
        11,
        16
      ]
    ]
  }
}

Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.

Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.

Embed this article summary

Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.

<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/brazil-quaest-poll-92-percent-criminal-age-16-pec-32-death-penalty-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Poll: 92% of Brazilian voters back lowering the criminal age to 16 as a Chamber vote nears by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:14px">Poll: 92% of Brazilian voters back lowering the criminal age to 16 as a Chamber vote nears by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/brazil-quaest-poll-92-percent-criminal-age-16-pec-32-death-penalty-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p>
<script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>

READ BEYOND 567POLITICS

Alternate sources & perspectives

Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.

Reviewed 2026-11-16. Hand-picked from pages opened on Nov. 16, 2026; discover_politics_sources returned unrelated pages. Quaest's own reports page did not yet carry the full survey report, so figures come from g1, Valor, Estadão and CNN Brasil accounts of it. The survey was commissioned by O Globo per Valor. UNICEF is listed as an advocacy source; Agência Câmara is listed for the rapporteur's argument it reports.

All 567politics news →