Skip to content
567politics.

New York City

Mamdani's plan to close Rikers has room for 4,500 people. The jail holds about 6,600

The mayor wants the legal deadline moved from 2027 to 2032 and is betting faster courts will cut the jail population by about a third.

By 567politics AI DeskPublished 9 min read

File photo: Rikers Island seen from the air in August 2008, looking south from over the Bronx, with LaGuardia Airport beyond. Photo: Cdogsimmons via Wikimedia Commons, released into the public domain; cropped.
File photo: Rikers Island seen from the air in August 2008, looking south from over the Bronx, with LaGuardia Airport beyond. Photo: Cdogsimmons via Wikimedia Commons, released into the public domain; cropped. · Photo: Cdogsimmons, Wikimedia Commons, public domain ↗

New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani asked the City Council on Friday to move the legal deadline for closing the Rikers Island jails from August 2027 to the end of 2032. His plan replaces the complex with four smaller jails and hospital units that together hold about 4,500 people. Rikers holds about 6,600 today.

That gap of roughly 2,100 people is the center of the fight. The administration says faster courts, more supervised release and new treatment beds can close it without a rise in crime. The correction officers' union says it cannot be closed safely. Some Council members want benchmarks written into the law before they vote.

"I am proud that New York City will close Rikers Island once and for all," Mamdani said at City Hall, according to the official transcript. He blamed the missed deadline on delays under the previous administration.

What the plan changes#

City Hall calls the document released Friday the city's first comprehensive plan to close Rikers. The Council passed the closure law in 2019 and set a deadline of Aug. 31, 2027. No replacement jail will be open by then. The administration closed one Rikers facility earlier this year, but the rest of the complex remains in use.

The new schedule opens the Brooklyn jail in 2029, the Bronx and Queens jails in 2031 and the Manhattan jail in 2032. A dedicated women's facility is planned in Queens. The four buildings would have 4,160 beds. Another 340 beds would sit in secure units inside public hospitals for people with serious medical or mental health needs. A 104-bed unit of that kind opened at Bellevue Hospital in April. Units at Woodhull and North Central Bronx hospitals are due in 2028, amNewYork reported.

The replacement system holds about 2,100 fewer people than Rikers does nowPeople in custody or beds. The 2029 figure is City Hall's interim goal

Source: NYC Mayor's Office transcript, CBS New York

Show the numbers
MeasurePeople
Rikers population now6,600
City goal for 20295,500
New jails and hospital units4,500
Share this chartPost

Each new jail is designed with individual cells, program rooms and outdoor space on every housing unit. Each sets aside at least 20,000 square feet for community use. The plan also restarts an advisory committee on the future of the roughly 400-acre island and calls for renewable energy projects there.

The city put new money behind the plan. The press release lists $146 million for the next fiscal year. That includes $50 million for classes, job training and treatment inside the jails, $76 million for community services such as housing help, and about $16 million for crime victims. An online bail payment system that has been offline since 2023 is due back in 2027.

Housing is part of the design. The plan funds emergency stabilization housing and points to Just Home, a supportive housing project in the Bronx, as a place for people leaving custody.

The math the plan depends on#

The plan works only if the jail population falls by about a third in six years. City Hall's interim goal is 5,500 people by 2029, when the Brooklyn jail opens, CBS New York reported.

The main lever is time. People wait in New York City jails far longer than elsewhere. The median indicted felony case took 431 days from arrest to outcome last year, 115 days longer than in the rest of the state, according to figures cited by amNewYork. Council Speaker Julie Menin said half of the felony cases in the first six months of 2025 took more than a year.

The plan creates a task force of courts, prosecutors and defense lawyers to cut those delays. It also promises faster sharing of evidence by the police, the fire department and the medical examiner.

The second lever is who is jailed at all. The plan expands supervised release, diversion to treatment and supportive housing. Asked where the extra 2,000 or so people would go, Mamdani pointed to those programs and said the city had reached similar jail populations before. No official offered a backup if the count stays above 4,500. No extra beds were announced.

Mamdani also made a public safety argument. In the early 1990s, he said, the city jailed about 22,000 people and recorded more than 2,000 murders a year. It recorded 230 murders in the first 10 months of 2026 with less than a third as many people in jail. "We know that detaining more New Yorkers does not make us safer," he said.

Those are the mayor's figures. They show that murders and the jail population fell together over three decades. They do not show which one caused the other.

The Rikers closure schedule, old and new
  1. City Council passes the law requiring Rikers to close
  2. Mamdani releases the plan and asks for a 2032 deadline
  3. Online bail payment returns; the original Aug. 31 deadline passes
  4. Hospital units at Woodhull and North Central Bronx are due
  5. Brooklyn jail opens
  6. Bronx and Queens jails open
  7. Manhattan jail opens; Rikers closes by year's end

Source: NYC Mayor's Office of Criminal Justice, amNewYork

What it costs#

The price of the four jails is not in the plan's summary. The city's Board of Correction listed projected budgets for each one in its January 2026 report. They add up to $13.4 billion, as the chart below shows.

A reporter at Friday's event put the total at about $16 billion. Mamdani did not confirm a number or name a cost-control step. He said the prior administration had neglected costs and timelines.

The bills land on a budget with other demands. Voters this month weighed a rainy-day reserve target for the city. The closure plan now joins the rent freeze among the signature promises of the mayor's first year.

The four borough jails carry projected budgets of $13.4 billionProjected budget per jail in billions of dollars, as listed in January 2026

Source: NYC Board of Correction, January 2026

Show the numbers
JailProjected budget
Queens$3.9B
Manhattan$3.7B
Brooklyn$2.9B
Bronx$2.9B
Share this chartPost

Who supports it#

Menin, whose chamber must change the law, said the city is "finally getting back on track," the Associated Press reported. Council Member Sandy Nurse plans to introduce the deadline bill this year. No vote has been scheduled.

Jonathan Lippman, the former chief judge who leads the Independent Rikers Commission, said the plan "adopts so many of our recommendations." The Legal Aid Society blamed the delay on the last mayor. It said the Adams administration "abandoned the City's commitment to closure, allowing the jail population to grow." Public Advocate Jumaane Williams called Rikers a "moral blight."

The district attorneys of the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan and Queens welcomed the plan in a joint statement that also warned of "many obstacles." Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards, who was once held at Rikers himself, said the goal is "a system grounded in dignity."

Supporters ground their case in conditions on the island. Mamdani said assaults at Rikers happen at eight times the rate of similar jails and that people are held there nearly four times longer than the national average. A federal judge who called conditions "abnormal and unacceptable" has appointed an outside manager to carry out reforms. The city says it wrote the plan with the court's monitor. In the meantime, the plan promises to repair more than 2,000 broken cell doors.

Who opposes it, and why#

Opposition comes from three directions.

The officers' union. Benny Boscio, president of the Correction Officers' Benevolent Association, said that "building a new system that puts an arbitrary cap on the City's available jail beds is ill-conceived." By his count the city would need to shed 40% of its jail population by 2032, which he said would require releasing violent felons. He also credited the plan as the first of its kind to stress better working conditions for officers.

Lawmakers who want to rebuild on the island. Council Member Frank Morano of Staten Island said the city should build modern jails on Rikers itself. "I have never understood how changing the zip code of a jail is supposed to fix the way it's run," he told CBS New York.

File photo: Rikers Island seen from the air in August 2008, looking south from over the Bronx. Photo: Cdogsimmons via Wikimedia Commons, public domain, cropped.

Neighbors of the new sites. Jan Lee, a founder of Neighbors United Below Canal in Chinatown, said the plan "still allows nighttime drilling, still sends heavy trucks through our narrow streets after dark."

A fourth group backs closure but doubts the safeguards. Elizabeth Glazer, who ran the mayor's criminal justice office under Bill de Blasio, told CBS the plan has no failsafe if the population does not fall. She wants the law to allow building on Rikers while the borough jails go up. Council Member Selvena Brooks-Powers said the Council's oversight will need realistic milestones.

Each side leans on a claim that deserves a second look. Boscio's warning assumes the count can fall only if people accused of violence are released. The plan's stated method is shorter case times, which would lower the daily count without changing who is arrested or charged. Whether the courts can deliver that is unproven.

City Hall, for its part, puts the delay on the previous administration alone. Nurse said the pandemic also slowed the work. She added that the date depends on the jail count falling, not only on construction.

We found no recent representative poll of New Yorkers on the 2032 date. The reactions quoted here are statements from officials and organized groups. They are not a measure of public opinion.

Three tests for the 2032 date#

Three things will show whether the new deadline holds.

  • The bill. The Council must pass the new deadline. Members are negotiating benchmarks that could tie the date to progress.
  • The count. The daily jail population needs to reach 5,500 by 2029. In its January report, the Board of Correction put the fiscal 2026 average to date at 7,247.
  • The first building. Brooklyn's jail is the first test of the construction schedule and of the budget.

Mamdani opposed the Council's borough-jail plan in 2019 and changed his position during his campaign, The Marshall Project reported in February. He now owns its hardest phase. His 567politics profile tracks his record as mayor. Our report on the NYPD force review covers another part of his public safety agenda.

"What will make this chapter different is our commitment to see it through," Mamdani said, according to the AP.

Differing perspectives

Should New York City extend the Rikers closure deadline to 2032 and replace the complex with four smaller borough jails?

Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.

  • Build the jails with firmer limits on construction

    Who holds it: Neighbors United Below Canal in Chinatown and residents near the Brooklyn site

    Residents near the new sites argue that the plan asks their blocks to absorb years of demolition and building without relief. They point to work that runs late into the night, drilling after dark and heavy trucks on narrow streets. They say the city should set and enforce stricter hours, truck routes and noise limits before the next towers rise, and should answer the concerns that neighborhood groups have raised since the sites were chosen.

    In their words: CBS New York, quoting residents ↗

  • Close Rikers by 2032 with four borough jails

    Who holds it: Mayor Zohran Mamdani, Council Speaker Julie Menin, the Independent Rikers Commission and the Legal Aid Society

    Supporters argue that Rikers is too isolated and too violent to repair, and that smaller jails next to the courthouses will be safer for staff and for people held there. They say the extra five years reflects construction time lost under earlier mayors. They point to long case delays as the reason the jail count is high, and say faster courts, supervised release and hospital treatment beds can lower it without added risk to the public.

    In their words: NYC Mayor's Office of Criminal Justice ↗

  • Keep enough jail beds and drop the population cap

    Who holds it: The Correction Officers' Benevolent Association and its president, Benny Boscio; Council Member Frank Morano

    Opponents argue that a system built for about 4,500 people sets a fixed cap on jail beds that the city cannot safely meet. They say reaching it would require cutting the jail population by about 40 percent and releasing people accused of violent felonies. Some say the city should build modern jails on Rikers Island, which it already owns, and point out that moving a jail does not by itself change how it is run.

    In their words: amNewYork, quoting the union's statement ↗

  • Tie the new deadline to milestones and a fallback

    Who holds it: Council Members Selvena Brooks-Powers and Sandy Nurse; former criminal justice office director Elizabeth Glazer

    This group backs closing Rikers but argues that a new date alone will fail the way the 2027 date did. They say the law should set realistic benchmarks for construction, spending and the jail count, so the Council can check progress each year. Some want a fallback written in, such as permission to build on Rikers while the borough jails go up, in case the population does not fall to the level the new buildings can hold.

    In their words: NYC Mayor's Office, event transcript ↗

Cite this article

567politics AI Desk. “Mamdani's plan to close Rikers has room for 4,500 people. The jail holds about 6,600.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-21. https://567politics.com/news/mamdani-rikers-closure-plan-2032-deadline-4500-beds-city-council-november-2026

Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Mamdani's plan to close Rikers has room for 4,500 people. The jail holds about 6,600 |url=https://567politics.com/news/mamdani-rikers-closure-plan-2032-deadline-4500-beds-city-council-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567politics AI Desk |date=2026-11-21 |language=en}}
CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
  "id": "https://567politics.com/news/mamdani-rikers-closure-plan-2032-deadline-4500-beds-city-council-november-2026",
  "type": "article-newspaper",
  "title": "Mamdani's plan to close Rikers has room for 4,500 people. The jail holds about 6,600",
  "URL": "https://567politics.com/news/mamdani-rikers-closure-plan-2032-deadline-4500-beds-city-council-november-2026",
  "container-title": "567politics",
  "language": "en",
  "author": [
    {
      "literal": "567politics AI Desk"
    }
  ],
  "issued": {
    "date-parts": [
      [
        2026,
        11,
        21
      ]
    ]
  }
}

Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.

Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.

Embed this article summary

Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.

<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/mamdani-rikers-closure-plan-2032-deadline-4500-beds-city-council-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Mamdani's plan to close Rikers has room for 4,500 people. The jail holds about 6,600 by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:14px">Mamdani's plan to close Rikers has room for 4,500 people. The jail holds about 6,600 by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/mamdani-rikers-closure-plan-2032-deadline-4500-beds-city-council-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p>
<script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
All 567politics news →