Skip to content
567politics.

Policy

Supreme Court won't hear Colorado's misgendering-rule case as a pronoun law fight reaches the 10th Circuit

The justices left in place a ruling that lawmakers are immune from suit over hearing decorum rules; the same day, businesses argued Colorado's chosen-name law chills their speech.

By 567 Politics staffPublished 11 min read

The dome of the Colorado State Capitol in Denver, where House and Senate judiciary committees heard testimony on the 2024 name-change bill at the center of the case.
The dome of the Colorado State Capitol in Denver, where House and Senate judiciary committees heard testimony on the 2024 name-change bill at the center of the case. · Photo: Colorado Senate GOP via Wikimedia Commons (public domain) ↗

The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a challenge to the Colorado legislature's rules against misgendering and deadnaming people during public testimony. The order leaves in place a federal appeals ruling that state lawmakers cannot be sued over how they set and enforce decorum rules in their own committee hearings, whatever the rule says.

The same morning in Denver, a federal appeals court heard a separate fight over Colorado's 2025 law that adds a person's chosen name and "how the individual chooses to be addressed" to the state's anti-discrimination statute. Together, the two cases test how far a state can go in setting the terms people use for transgender people, first inside the Capitol and then at a shop counter.

What the Supreme Court did#

The justices denied review in Gays Against Groomers v. Garcia, No. 26-120, without explanation and with no noted dissent, according to the Court's Nov. 16 order list and the case docket. The case had been set for the justices' Nov. 6 conference, was rescheduled, and was considered on Nov. 13.

The petitioners are Gays Against Groomers, a national nonprofit; the Rocky Mountain Women's Network; and two Coloradans, Rich Guggenheim and Christina Goeke. The respondents are five Democratic legislators: Reps. Lorena Garcia, Mike Weissman and Leslie Herod, and Sens. Julie Gonzales and Dafna Michaelson Jenet. Four groups filed friend-of-the-court briefs urging the Court to take the case: Women's Declaration International USA, the LGB Courage Coalition and others, the Foundation for Moral Law, and the Women's Liberation Front. No amicus brief supporting the legislators appears on the docket.

A denial is not a ruling on the merits. It means the Tenth Circuit's March decision stays binding in the six states of that circuit, and that the First Amendment question the challengers raised was never decided by any court.

From a 2024 hearing to the Supreme Court
  1. House Judiciary hearing on HB 24-1071; Goeke's testimony is cut short
  2. Senate Judiciary hearing; Goeke and Guggenheim are interrupted
  3. District court dismisses the suit on legislative immunity
  4. Tenth Circuit affirms, 3-0
  5. Tenth Circuit denies rehearing en banc
  6. Challengers petition the Supreme Court
  7. Legislators file their brief in opposition
  8. Supreme Court denies review

Source: Supreme Court docket No. 26-120, Tenth Circuit opinion

The hearings behind the case#

The dispute began in 2024, when the legislature took up House Bill 24-1071, which supporters called Tiara's Law. Colorado law had barred people with felony convictions from changing their legal names except for "good cause." The bill, as described in the Tenth Circuit's opinion, said good cause includes conforming a name to a person's gender identity. It was named for Tiara Kelley, a transgender woman with past convictions who sought a name change. Gov. Jared Polis signed it, and it is now codified at section 13-15-101 of the Colorado Revised Statutes.

At the House Judiciary Committee hearing on Jan. 30, 2024, Garcia thanked colleagues for "not using derogatory language or misgendering witnesses, or using a witness's deadname," and asked witnesses to follow suit, according to the appeals court's account of the complaint. Guggenheim chose not to testify under those terms. Goeke testified, referred to Kelley with male pronouns, and was interrupted. After cross-talk in the room, the committee recessed and her testimony ended.

At the Senate Judiciary Committee on March 27, 2024, Gonzales, the chair, warned that witnesses would be removed "if they failed to exhibit decorum, dignity, or respect," the opinion says. When Goeke again used male pronouns and Kelley's former name, Gonzales cut her off. Goeke alleges her remarks were later removed from the official audio recording. Guggenheim was interrupted while arguing that the Stonewall-era activists Marsha P. Johnson and Sylvia Rivera were gay men, not transgender women.

The legislators' brief in opposition describes the same events differently. It says the rules were "designed to promote respectful discourse and avoid personal references that would be disparaging to persons in attendance," and that Goeke "refused to comply" after being urged to follow them.

The dome of the Colorado State Capitol in Denver against a blue sky

The Colorado State Capitol in Denver, where both judiciary committees heard the 2024 testimony. Photo: Colorado Senate GOP via Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Why the challengers lost without a ruling on speech#

U.S. District Judge Regina M. Rodriguez dismissed the suit in November 2024, and a Tenth Circuit panel affirmed on March 10, 2026. Neither court decided whether the rules violate the First Amendment. Both held that the legislators have absolute legislative immunity, a doctrine that shields lawmakers from suits over their legislative acts.

"The legislative process is inherently political, and therefore not easily amenable to federal judicial inquiry," Judge Richard E.N. Federico wrote for the panel, as quoted by The Gazette. He added: "The legislature's time is its own." Interrupting or ending a witness's testimony, he wrote, no more exceeds the legislative function than a judge cutting off counsel at oral argument. The panel said the result might differ if lawmakers barred someone from ever addressing the legislature again.

Judge Joel M. Carson III agreed with the outcome but wrote separately to describe its cost. "The opinion allows legislative bodies to create rules under the guise of decorum that essentially silence opposition in legislative hearings," he wrote. "Are the people whose opinions are excluded in such an instance left with the ballot box as their only remedy? Likely so." He also noted that the same immunity would protect a legislature that "flips the script" and permits only the opposite viewpoint.

How legislative immunity ended the case before the speech question
  1. Adopting rulescommittee decorum rules are a legislative act
  2. Enforcing theminterrupting or ending testimony is part of running a hearing
  3. Immunity applieslawmakers cannot be sued for legislative acts, in either capacity
  4. No merits rulingthe First Amendment claim is never decided

Source: Tenth Circuit opinion, No. 24-1473

The two sides at the Supreme Court#

The petition, filed by the Institute for Free Speech, asked two questions. The first was whether legislative immunity, which it calls a personal defense, can block claims against officials in their official capacity that seek only an injunction. The petition argues that such suits are really against the government itself, and that federal appeals courts are divided on the point. The second was whether enforcing what it called a "facially viewpoint-discriminatory public comment policy" counts as legislating at all. The ruling, it warned, "will invite other legislative bodies to enforce speech rules that silence dissenting or minority viewpoints."

The legislators answered that "the petition asks this Court to resolve a circuit split that does not exist." They cited Tenney v. Brandhove, the 1951 decision tracing legislative immunity to parliamentary struggles of the 16th and 17th centuries, and argued that adopting and enforcing hearing rules is a policymaking act "in a field where legislators traditionally have power to act." They stressed the limits of what they did: they could not "seek civil damages from violators, prosecute violators, or ban violators" from future hearings. Judging the challengers' claims, they argued, would require inquiry into lawmakers' motives and "would require intrusion into the legislative process."

After Monday's order, Institute for Free Speech senior attorney Endel Kolde said that Coloradans who want to weigh in on transgender-related bills "must still choose between using government-mandated gender terminology and being silenced." He called the Tenth Circuit's ruling "a roadmap for censoring criticism by citizens who hold dissenting views, with no court able to stop them."

The two sides describe the same rules in different terms. The challengers call them censorship of one viewpoint. The legislators call them ordinary rules of order for a hearing, and the Tenth Circuit compared them to long-standing rules that bar a member of Congress from calling a colleague a liar. The courts never resolved which description fits, because immunity ended the case first.

The second fight: chosen names in public accommodations#

Monday's other hearing concerns a law with a wider reach. House Bill 25-1312, the Kelly Loving Act, amended the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act. It now defines "gender expression" to include "chosen name, and how the individual chooses to be addressed." The act bars places of public accommodation from denying anyone "the full and equal enjoyment" of their services because of gender expression, among other traits. Garcia was a prime House sponsor; Gonzales, Michaelson Jenet and Weissman are listed among its Senate co-sponsors in the signed bill.

Polis signed it on May 16, 2025, after it passed the House 38-20 and the Senate 20-14, according to the LGBTQ advocacy group One Colorado's 2025 legislative report. The group says the law "strengthens dignity, safety, and legal recognition for LGBTQIA+ people in Colorado" and helps ensure that transgender and nonbinary people "are respected in schools, courts, workplaces, and everyday life."

Colorado's chosen-name law passed the House 38-20 and the Senate 20-14Final passage votes on HB25-1312, 2025 session

Source: One Colorado, 2025 Legislative Report

Show the numbers
ChamberYesNo
House3820
Senate2014
Share this chartPost

Three suits followed. Defending Education, a parents' advocacy group, sued along with others. Alliance Defending Freedom represents XX-XY Athletics, a Denver apparel company, and Born Again Used Books, a Christian bookstore in Colorado Springs. They say the law exposes them to complaints for referring to customers by their sex, and compels them to use pronouns that conflict with their beliefs.

On March 31, 2026, Rodriguez, the same judge who dismissed the legislative case, denied all three requests for a preliminary injunction. Her order adopted a magistrate judge's finding that the challengers had not shown a credible threat of enforcement, so they lacked standing for now. The Colorado Civil Rights Division had received no complaints against any business over a misgendering or deadnaming policy, the order says. The state also gave sworn testimony that misgendering and deadnaming alone are not a per se violation; the conduct "must rise to the level of harassment." The order noted that the state "has not completely disavowed" enforcement, and said the court had not reached the merits.

What Colorado says a chosen-name complaint must show
  1. Different treatmentthe business intentionally treats a customer differently because of a protected trait
  2. Customer's experiencethe customer experiences it as a denial of full and equal enjoyment
  3. Reasonable personthe Division finds a reasonable person would see it the same way
  4. Outcomeper the state, misgendering alone is not a violation unless it rises to harassment

Source: Order denying preliminary injunctions, D. Colo., March 31, 2026

On Monday, a Tenth Circuit panel heard the consolidated appeals. The judges focused on whether the plaintiffs have standing, Bloomberg Law reported. Janna Fischer, arguing for state officials, told the court the plaintiffs' intended conduct does not violate the law. Before the argument, Alliance Defending Freedom senior counsel Hal Frampton said the state "continues to place itself on the wrong side of the law by threatening Coloradans who speak in accordance with biological reality." No ruling date has been set.

How Chiles changes the backdrop#

The business challengers lean on Chiles v. Salazar, decided March 31, 2026. In that case the Supreme Court ruled 8-1 that Colorado's ban on conversion therapy for minors, applied to a counselor's talk therapy, regulates speech based on viewpoint and must face strict scrutiny, SCOTUSblog reported. Justice Elena Kagan, concurring, wrote that a "mirror image" law favoring the opposite view would raise the same concerns.

That reasoning cuts in more than one direction. The challengers in both Colorado cases describe the rules as viewpoint discrimination. The state's answer in the business case is not mainly about viewpoint. It argues that the law reaches discriminatory treatment, and that speech alone does not trigger enforcement. In the legislative case, the viewpoint question never arrived, because immunity is a threshold bar.

The cases sit inside a broader set of Colorado disputes over LGBTQ policy and religious or speech claims. The Supreme Court heard arguments on Nov. 3 in a Catholic preschool challenge to the state's universal pre-K rules, where justices pressed both sides on the LGBTQ nondiscrimination requirement. Earlier this month the Court also sent back a transgender jail-housing case from Colorado for another look. Gays Against Groomers, one of the petitioners here, is part of a wider movement of LGB-only advocacy groups whose influence and filings 567politics examined earlier this month.

What remains unknown#

Several questions remain open. Courts have not decided whether a legislature may bar specific terms for transgender people during public comment, and no court is likely to reach that question in the Tenth Circuit while the immunity ruling stands. Other circuits could still split on official-capacity immunity, which the legislators conceded could bring the issue back.

In the business cases, the Tenth Circuit could decide only standing and send the cases back without addressing the First Amendment. Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser is a named defendant in the Defending Education suit, alongside the civil rights division director and commissioners. Whatever the panel decides, the losing side could seek rehearing or Supreme Court review.

No representative poll measuring public views on legislative decorum rules or on Colorado's chosen-name law was found, so it is not possible to say what Coloradans or Americans think about these specific measures. 567politics has no verified campaign-finance snapshot for the state officials named here; their filings sit in Colorado's state disclosure system and were not reviewed for this story, and nothing in either case concerns campaign money.

Differing perspectives

Should courts be able to review Colorado's rules on misgendering and chosen names, in legislative hearings and in businesses?

Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.

  • Block the chosen-name law as compelled speech

    Who holds it: XX-XY Athletics and Born Again Used Books, represented by Alliance Defending Freedom

    These businesses argue that the 2025 amendment exposes them to complaints, investigations and penalties for referring to customers by their sex in conversation, advertising and publications. They say the law compels them to use pronouns and titles that conflict with their beliefs. Citing the Supreme Court's Chiles v. Salazar ruling, they argue that the state cannot dictate which view people express on a contested question.

    In their words: Alliance Defending Freedom ↗

  • Enforce the law only against discriminatory treatment

    Who holds it: Colorado Civil Rights Division and state officials defending HB25-1312

    State officials argue that the challengers lack standing because their planned speech does not violate the law. In sworn testimony they say a violation requires intentional different treatment that a customer, and a reasonable person, would experience as a denial of equal service, and that misgendering alone must rise to harassment. They note the Division has received no complaints against any business over such a policy.

    In their words: U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado, order of March 31, 2026 ↗

  • Leave hearing decorum rules to legislators

    Who holds it: Reps. Lorena Garcia, Mike Weissman and Leslie Herod and Sens. Julie Gonzales and Dafna Michaelson Jenet, the respondents

    The legislators argue that legislative immunity has protected lawmakers for centuries and covers official-capacity suits as well. They say their rules applied to every witness, were meant to keep testimony respectful and free of disparaging personal references, and governed only two hearings on one bill. They could not fine, prosecute or permanently bar anyone. Letting courts probe their motives, they argue, would intrude on legislative independence.

    In their words: Brief for respondents in opposition, No. 26-120 ↗

  • Let courts review hearing speech rules

    Who holds it: Gays Against Groomers, Rocky Mountain Women's Network, Rich Guggenheim and Christina Goeke, represented by the Institute for Free Speech

    The challengers argue that legislative immunity is a personal defense that should not block official-capacity suits seeking only an injunction, and that appeals courts are split on the point. They say enforcing a public comment rule that bars one side's terms is viewpoint discrimination, not legislating. Without court review, they argue, any legislative majority could silence citizens who disagree with it on contested bills.

    In their words: Institute for Free Speech ↗

  • Protect chosen names as part of equal treatment

    Who holds it: One Colorado and the bill's Democratic sponsors

    Supporters argue that recognizing a person's chosen name and form of address is part of treating transgender and nonbinary Coloradans equally. One Colorado says the law removes barriers to accurate documents and promotes inclusive practices across public systems. In its account, the law strengthens dignity, safety and legal recognition, and helps ensure transgender people are respected in schools, courts, workplaces and everyday life.

    In their words: One Colorado ↗

Cite this article

567 Politics staff. “Supreme Court won't hear Colorado's misgendering-rule case as a pronoun law fight reaches the 10th Circuit.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-16. https://567politics.com/news/supreme-court-gays-against-groomers-v-garcia-colorado-misgendering-rule-hb25-1312-tenth-circuit-november-2026

Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Supreme Court won't hear Colorado's misgendering-rule case as a pronoun law fight reaches the 10th Circuit |url=https://567politics.com/news/supreme-court-gays-against-groomers-v-garcia-colorado-misgendering-rule-hb25-1312-tenth-circuit-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-16 |language=en}}
CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
  "id": "https://567politics.com/news/supreme-court-gays-against-groomers-v-garcia-colorado-misgendering-rule-hb25-1312-tenth-circuit-november-2026",
  "type": "article-newspaper",
  "title": "Supreme Court won't hear Colorado's misgendering-rule case as a pronoun law fight reaches the 10th Circuit",
  "URL": "https://567politics.com/news/supreme-court-gays-against-groomers-v-garcia-colorado-misgendering-rule-hb25-1312-tenth-circuit-november-2026",
  "container-title": "567politics",
  "language": "en",
  "author": [
    {
      "literal": "567 Politics staff"
    }
  ],
  "issued": {
    "date-parts": [
      [
        2026,
        11,
        16
      ]
    ]
  }
}

Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.

Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.

Embed this article summary

Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.

<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/supreme-court-gays-against-groomers-v-garcia-colorado-misgendering-rule-hb25-1312-tenth-circuit-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Supreme Court won't hear Colorado's misgendering-rule case as a pronoun law fight reaches the 10th Circuit by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:14px">Supreme Court won't hear Colorado's misgendering-rule case as a pronoun law fight reaches the 10th Circuit by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/supreme-court-gays-against-groomers-v-garcia-colorado-misgendering-rule-hb25-1312-tenth-circuit-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p>
<script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>

READ BEYOND 567POLITICS

Alternate sources & perspectives

Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.

Reviewed 2026-11-16. The source-discovery tool returned only irrelevant results (retail pages for the word 'Supreme'), so this list was chosen by hand from pages opened while reporting. Court filings were read from the Supreme Court and GovInfo sites. Bloomberg Law's account of the Nov. 16 Tenth Circuit argument is paywalled beyond its opening paragraphs and is cited in the story only for what was visible. No public statement from the respondent legislators or the Colorado attorney general on the Nov. 16 events was found at review time. No representative poll on legislative decorum rules or Colorado's chosen-name law was found.

All 567politics news →