Cass review author turns against Labour's conversion practices ban: 'I can't support this bill'
Ministers quoted Baroness Cass in support in June; she now says the draft could expose clinicians and parents to prosecution, and ministers say they want it right.

Hilary Cass, the pediatrician whose 2024 review reshaped NHS gender care for children, told Parliament on Monday that she no longer supports the government's draft ban on conversion practices in England and Wales. Asked by the joint committee of MPs and peers scrutinizing the bill whether she backed it in its current form, she said simply "no," the BBC reported.
Her reversal matters because ministers quoted her in support when they published the draft on June 25, 2026. It also sharpens the bill's central dispute. Nearly every side says abusive attempts to change a person's sexual orientation or gender identity should stop. They disagree about whether this text can punish abusers without also exposing clinicians and parents to complaints or prosecution.
The government says it welcomes her comments and wants "to get this ban right." The bill's main supporters say the health care protections are already broad, and some want them narrowed. Critics say her evidence shows the bill cannot be fixed.
What Cass told the committee#
Cass, who now sits in the House of Lords as a crossbench peer, gave evidence on the afternoon of November 16. She shared a panel with Professor Gillian Leng, president of the Royal Society of Medicine and of the Medical Protection Society. A second panel heard from the Care Quality Commission, the Health and Care Professions Council and the General Medical Council, according to the committee's inquiry page. The official transcript of that session had not been published when this article was written, so the quotations below come from news reports and Cass's own radio interview.
Her main objection is to the health care clause. The draft bill text says conduct "carried out in the course of providing health care services" is not a conversion practice "unless the person acts in a way that falls far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position." Cass said that test gives clinicians little comfort in a field where the standards themselves are contested.
"The draft bill is already having a chilling effect on healthcare professionals who fear they may be accused of falling far below professional standards, even when they have conducted appropriate and ethical therapy," she said, as quoted by the Guardian. "Standards are hotly disputed in this contentious area and no professional wants to risk complaints and even prosecution, even if they are later exonerated. It is the process which ends up being an unwarranted punishment."
- Intentconduct meant to make a person have, or not have, a sexual orientation or transgender identity
- Health care testcare given as health services is excluded unless it falls far below expected standards
- Abuse testa question of fact, weighing violence, coercion, economic or emotional pressure
- Harm testserious harm to health, or serious alarm or distress affecting daily life
- Penaltyup to five years in prison, a fine, or both
Source: Draft Conversion Practices Bill, GOV.UK, GOV.UK announcement
She also questioned the harm threshold. The offense in clause 2 requires "serious harm" to a person's physical or mental health, or "serious alarm or distress" with "a substantial adverse effect on their usual day-to-day activities." On BBC Radio 4's Today program, Cass said a young person can leave a sound therapy session upset or angry. "Therapeutic interactions can be distressing and often are because you're discussing quite sensitive issues," she said. She told the committee that staff at the new NHS gender dysphoria clinics feared complaints even when no prosecution followed.
According to Parliament News, which published an extended account of the hearing, she linked that fear to referrals to the General Medical Council. She said some doctors have died by suicide while awaiting the outcome of such referrals, and that the chilling effect "isn't theoretical."
The risk she sees for parents#

Cass's second objection concerns families. The bill lists factors for deciding whether conduct is abusive, including controlling or coercive behavior, economic pressure and "psychological or emotional pressure." She said ordinary parenting decisions could fall inside that frame.
"Things like not agreeing to changing pronouns for your child, restricting money if you think they're going to use it to get a breast binder or hormones, and all of those things could fall within the reach of this bill," she said, according to Parliament News. She added that she knew ministers did not intend to catch parents, but that the risk was built into "the way in which the bill is framed."
Her conclusion was blunt. "I can't support this bill as it has too many problems, including the risk to parents," she said. "It would have to be radically changed to be workable and I am not sure that is possible."
Cass did not reject a ban in principle. She told the Today program that a ban is "desirable" but that "we have not yet as far as I can see got a workable bill." In her 2024 review she called conversion practices "abhorrent," and the BBC reported that she still holds that view. Her stated goal is "a bill that protects the people it's supposed to protect, but doesn't accidentally entrap those who you don't want to."
Why her earlier endorsement is now in question#
The government's June press release quoted Cass as "pleased" that the draft defined "not only... what conversion practices are, compared to previous drafts, but also what they are not." She also said then that clinicians must be able "to do their job without fear of litigation."
At Monday's hearing she said she gave that quote without reading the text. "It was sent to me an hour before they wanted a press release and 15 minutes before I walked on the platform to give a talk," she said, according to Parliament News. "So I tried to give the quotes based on the principles that I've been told about but without seeing the bill as drafted, and maybe I shouldn't have done that." The Daily Mail and PinkNews reported a similar account of the timing. The government's statement on Monday did not address it.
This account bears on how much weight the original endorsement should carry. It does not by itself show that her current reading of the clauses is correct. That is a legal and clinical question the committee now has to weigh against other expert evidence.
The case for the bill as a starting point#
- Draft bill published; government release quotes Cass in support
- Committee hears Stonewall, Galop and the Ban Conversion Practices Coalition, then Sex Matters, Gay Men's Network and LGB Alliance
- Survivors Jayne Ozanne and Ian Smith give evidence
- Committee hears the coalition behind the memorandum on conversion therapy and gender identity clinicians
- Cass says she cannot support the bill; written evidence closes
- Next oral evidence session
- Last scheduled oral evidence session
Source: GOV.UK, UK Parliament, BBC
Supporters argue that the bill closes a gap in the criminal law. The government's June release said existing offenses covering domestic violence, coercive control and communications "do not adequately address the unique nature of abusive conversion practices." It said the bill does not criminalize "expressing beliefs about LGBT+ identities" or "explorative conversations," and that a "high threshold for criminality" leaves only abusive, harmful acts in scope. Olivia Bailey, then an equalities minister, said conversion practices "are driven by the false belief that being LGBT+ is shameful and can be forcibly changed."
On the health care point, the bill's strongest supporters read the clause in the opposite way from Cass. At the committee's first session on October 29, Stephen Kiely of Stonewall said the clause was meant "to protect clinicians who offer legitimate, evidence-based care," but called its definition "very broad." He said survivors described abuse by groups that had rebranded themselves as therapists or counselors, and that the draft would exempt them. Stonewall wants the protection limited to practitioners regulated by a statutory body or on a register accredited by the Professional Standards Authority.
Professor Ilias Trispiotis of the Ban Conversion Practices Coalition was asked directly whether the wording would chill health care. "In my opinion, legitimate healthcare is consistent with the Bill, which would not have a chilling effect on healthcare," he said. In his view, the bill as drafted gives LGBT+ people too little protection, not too much.
At the November 12 session, Igi Moon, a psychologist who chairs the coalition behind the memorandum of understanding on conversion therapy, said the groups that signed it back the draft. "We want a legal ban," Moon said, according to the Guardian. The BBC reported that the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy also supports the bill.
The government's response on Monday did not concede any drafting change. "We want to get this ban right, which is why we have put this draft bill forward for pre-legislative scrutiny," a spokesperson told the BBC. "We will take all evidence put forward by the committee seriously as we move forward in ending almost a decade of delay for LGBT+ people who should never have to suffer abuse in an effort to change who they are."
The case for dropping or rewriting it#
Opponents treated Cass's evidence as decisive. Tonia Antoniazzi, the Labour MP leading backbench opposition, said ministers "need to listen to these comments from the respected professional Baroness Cass and withdraw the bill," Parliament News reported. Maya Forstater of Sex Matters called it "arguably the most important intervention on the bill to date." Dennis Kavanagh of the Gay Men's Network called the bill "tyrannical and poorly drafted" and urged ministers to go "back to the drawing board." Simon Calvert of the Christian Institute said the government "needs to listen to her."

Their argument predates Cass's reversal. At the October 29 session, Helen Joyce of Sex Matters said the abuse test borrows from the coercive control offense, which was written for adults. Sex Matters' account of that hearing quotes her: "If my husband takes my phone away from me because he doesn't want me contacting people, that's coercive control. If I do that to my child, that may be responsible parenting." Kavanagh argued that parents cannot read the bill "across their kitchen table" and know whether they are breaking the law.
A November 2 Policy Exchange report co-written by Kishwer Falkner, a former chair of the equality regulator, also called the bill unworkable. Ministers called it misleading, as our earlier report on the committee's evidence sets out. Sex Matters is also pursuing a High Court case over the Hampstead Heath ponds.
What the evidence does and does not show#
Both camps are predicting how professionals and prosecutors would act under a law that does not yet exist.
The "chilling effect" claim rests mainly on testimony. Joyce told the committee that all 30 therapists Sex Matters interviewed expected a serious chilling effect. That small sample was chosen by a group that opposes the bill, so it cannot show how widespread the concern is. Cass's account comes from contact with clinic staff, not a survey. Trispiotis's view that legitimate care would be unaffected is a legal reading, not data.
Trispiotis told the committee that New Zealand, Canada and the Australian state of Victoria already have bans, and Tasmania's lower house passed one in October, as we reported. Committee member Baroness Brown of Silvertown summarized what the committee had heard about other countries: "They did not have prosecutions, but they left the field." That is a remark made during questioning, not a published study.
No representative poll has measured public reaction to Cass's intervention. Our earlier report covers polling on a ban and its limits.
The committee hearings and decision ahead#
Written evidence closed on November 16. Oral evidence sessions are set for November 19, 23 and 26. The committee will then report, and the government will decide what to introduce as a formal bill.
The bill is a Labour manifesto commitment, and the equalities brief sits with Bridget Phillipson, Minister for Women and Equalities. Opposition now includes a figure ministers chose to cite and a Labour MP on their own benches. Supporters say careful drafting, such as a narrower health care exemption or a list of lawful practices, can fix the problems. Critics, now joined by Cass, doubt the text can be repaired.
Differing perspectives
Should Parliament take forward the draft Conversion Practices Bill for England and Wales as it is written?
Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.
Pass a ban with a narrower health care exemption
Who holds it: Stonewall, Galop and the Ban Conversion Practices Coalition
These groups support the bill as a strong start but say its health care carve-out is too broad. They argue that survivors describe abuse by unregulated people who present themselves as therapists or counselors, and that the draft would shield them. They want the exemption limited to professionals regulated by a statutory body or listed on a register accredited by the Professional Standards Authority, and they say legitimate clinical care is consistent with the bill and would not be chilled.
In their words: UK Parliament, Joint Committee on the Draft Conversion Practices Bill ↗
Proceed with the draft and its safeguards
Who holds it: The UK government and Office for Equality and Opportunity
Ministers argue that existing offenses for domestic abuse, coercive control and communications do not fit the specific harm of conversion practices, and that the lack of a legal definition stops police and prosecutors from acting. They say the bill sets a high threshold, catching only abusive conduct that causes real harm, and protects belief, open conversations and legitimate health care. They say pre-legislative scrutiny exists to get the ban right and end almost a decade of delay.
In their words: Office for Equality and Opportunity, GOV.UK ↗
Redraft radically before any ban
Who holds it: Baroness Hilary Cass, author of the 2024 review of NHS gender services for children
Cass says a ban on conversion practices is desirable but that the draft is not workable. She argues that the far-below-standards test and the distress-based harm threshold leave clinicians open to complaints and prosecution in a field where standards are disputed, which already deters them from this work. She also says parents could be caught for refusing pronoun changes or withholding money for binders or hormones. She wants a bill that protects LGBT people without entrapping clinicians or families.
In their words: BBC News ↗
Withdraw the bill
Who holds it: Sex Matters, Gay Men's Network, LGB Alliance, the Christian Institute and Labour MP Tonia Antoniazzi
These critics argue that genuinely abusive acts are already crimes and that the bill's abuse test, modeled on coercive control between adults, does not fit the relationship between parents and children. They say ordinary parenting, therapy and religious guidance could fall within it, that parents cannot tell from the text whether they are breaking the law, and that therapists are already avoiding gender-questioning young people. They want ministers to withdraw the draft rather than amend it.
In their words: Sex Matters ↗
Cite this article
567 Politics staff. “Cass review author turns against Labour's conversion practices ban: 'I can't support this bill'.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-17. https://567politics.com/news/uk-cass-withdraws-support-conversion-practices-bill-joint-committee-november-2026
Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Cass review author turns against Labour's conversion practices ban: 'I can't support this bill' |url=https://567politics.com/news/uk-cass-withdraws-support-conversion-practices-bill-joint-committee-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-17 |language=en}}CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
"id": "https://567politics.com/news/uk-cass-withdraws-support-conversion-practices-bill-joint-committee-november-2026",
"type": "article-newspaper",
"title": "Cass review author turns against Labour's conversion practices ban: 'I can't support this bill'",
"URL": "https://567politics.com/news/uk-cass-withdraws-support-conversion-practices-bill-joint-committee-november-2026",
"container-title": "567politics",
"language": "en",
"author": [
{
"literal": "567 Politics staff"
}
],
"issued": {
"date-parts": [
[
2026,
11,
17
]
]
}
}Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.
Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.
Embed this article summary
Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.
<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/uk-cass-withdraws-support-conversion-practices-bill-joint-committee-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Cass review author turns against Labour's conversion practices ban: 'I can't support this bill' by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe> <p style="font-size:14px">Cass review author turns against Labour's conversion practices ban: 'I can't support this bill' by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/uk-cass-withdraws-support-conversion-practices-bill-joint-committee-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p> <script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
READ BEYOND 567POLITICS
Alternate sources & perspectives
Independent coverage and primary evidence to help you compare arguments. A link is not an endorsement; perspective labels describe the linked material.
- primary evidence
Draft Conversion Practices Bill: inquiry page, witnesses and schedule ↗
UK Parliament, Joint Committee on the Draft Conversion Practices Bill
Lists the November 16 witnesses (Baroness Cass, Professor Gillian Leng, CQC, HCPC and GMC officials), the written-evidence deadline and sessions set for November 19, 23 and 26.
- primary evidence
Conversion Practices Draft Bill (text) ↗
GOV.UK
Clause 1's health care exclusion with its 'falls far below the standards' test and clause 2's serious harm and serious alarm or distress thresholds that Cass criticized.
- primary evidence
Government pushes forward with conversion practices ban to protect LGBT+ people from abuse ↗
Office for Equality and Opportunity (GOV.UK)
The June 25, 2026 launch release with the government's case for the ban, the penalty, and the supportive quotes from Cass, Stonewall, Galop and others.
- primary evidence
Uncorrected oral evidence, October 29, 2026 ↗
UK Parliament
Transcript of Stonewall, Galop and the Ban Conversion Practices Coalition, who want a narrower health care exemption, and of Sex Matters, Gay Men's Network and LGB Alliance, who oppose the bill.
- independent analysis
Cass report author tells BBC draft conversion practices bill is not workable ↗
BBC News
Cass's Today program interview and committee answers, plus the government's full response that it wants 'to get this ban right'.
- independent analysis
Expert behind NHS children's gender services review says she cannot back conversion practices ban ↗
The Guardian
Cass's statement on the chilling effect and risk to parents, and Dr Igi Moon's November 12 evidence that the memorandum signatories want a legal ban.
- independent analysis
Baroness Cass withdraws support for draft conversion practices bill ↗
Parliament News
Extended quotations from the hearing, including the press-release timing account, and reactions from Tonia Antoniazzi, Gay Men's Network, Sex Matters and the Christian Institute.
- independent analysis
Expert behind gender clinics review withdraws support for conversion therapy Bill ↗
The Independent (PA)
Wire account of Cass's statement and of the bill's history since the 2018 pledge.
- other perspective
Baroness Cass withdraws support for Labour conversion practices ban ↗
PinkNews
LGBT-focused outlet's account, including the wider dispute over implementation of the Cass Review.
- other perspective
Baroness Cass says she can't back Labour's 'chilling' trans conversion law ↗
Daily Mail
Critical framing of the bill with Cass's committee remarks on the 15-minute review window.
- other perspective
Criminalising parents who don't affirm: the first evidence session ↗
Sex Matters
The group's own account of its October 29 evidence against the bill on parents, therapists and the coercive-control model.
Reviewed 2026-11-17. Hand-picked from pages opened on November 17, 2026; the automated source-discovery tool returned only unrelated pages about the word 'baroness'. The official transcript of the November 16 session was not yet published, so Cass's committee remarks are cited through BBC, Guardian, Independent and Parliament News accounts. The Telegraph report could not be opened (timeout). Stonewall, Galop and the Ban Conversion Practices Coalition had not published a response to Cass that could be found; their position is cited from the October 29 transcript. No representative poll on Cass's intervention was located.