Skip to content
567politics.

Policy

Trump got two appeals judges through the Senate this week. A Republican just sank his Texas pick

John Cornyn withheld his blue slip from Justice Department lawyer Elliot Gaiser, using a Senate custom the president has spent 16 months trying to end.

By 567 Politics staffPublished 9 min read

File photo: the U.S. Capitol seen from the west, with the Ulysses S. Grant Memorial in the foreground, in May 2011. Photo: Wknight94 via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/), cropped.
File photo: the U.S. Capitol seen from the west, with the Ulysses S. Grant Memorial in the foreground, in May 2011. Photo: Wknight94 via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/), cropped. · Photo: Wknight94, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 ↗

The Senate confirmed two of President Donald Trump's appeals court nominees on party-line votes this week. In the same three days, a senator from his own party ended the chances of a third judicial pick with a single unreturned form.

Sen. John Cornyn of Texas told CBS News on Wednesday that the nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser to a federal trial court in the Dallas area is "no longer viable." Cornyn declined to return his blue slip. That is the paper form a home-state senator uses to approve or block a nominee for a district court in the senator's state.$

The two outcomes show where a president's power over the courts is strong and where it stops. For an appeals court seat, a simple majority of senators is enough. For a trial court seat, one senator from the right state can still say no. The difference matters more than usual now, because Republicans lose their Senate majority on January 3.

The two kinds of court do different work. The 94 federal district courts are where trials happen: judges there hear witnesses, rule on evidence and sentence defendants. The 13 courts of appeals review those decisions and do not hold trials. Judges on both hold their seats for life once the Senate confirms them. The Dallas-area seat Gaiser was nominated for is one of the first kind.

Two confirmations with no crossover votes#

Senate records show how firm the party line was on the appeals court seats.

On Monday, the Senate confirmed Daniel Domenico of Colorado to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals by 51 to 46, according to the official roll call. On Tuesday, it confirmed Anna St. John of Louisiana to the 5th Circuit by 52 to 46, according to that vote's record.

No Republican voted against either nominee. No Democrat or independent voted for one. The only difference between the two tallies was attendance. Three senators missed Monday's vote: Republicans Ashley Moody$ of Florida and Jim Risch$ of Idaho, and Democrat Chris Murphy$ of Connecticut. Risch and Murphy also missed Tuesday's.

Both appeals court judges were confirmed on straight party linesSenate roll call votes 263 and 265, Nov. 16 and 17, 2026. All yes votes were Republican; all no votes were Democrats or independents

Source: U.S. Senate, vote 263, U.S. Senate, vote 265

Show the numbers
NomineeYesNoNot voting
Domenico, 10th Circuit51463
St. John, 5th Circuit52462
Share this chartPost

Domenico's confirmation shows the rule that applies to appeals courts. He is from Colorado, a state with two Democratic senators. Neither appears among the yes votes or the absences in the Senate's record, which means both voted no. Their opposition could not stop him.

That is because Republicans stopped honoring blue slips for appeals court nominees during Trump's first term, as Politico reported last year. The custom now covers only district judges and U.S. attorneys.

How the Gaiser nomination fell apart in two weeks#

Gaiser leads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, the office that tells the executive branch what the law allows. He is an Ohio native and a former Ohio solicitor general. CBS reported that he lived in Ohio until he joined the administration in 2025, and that his only stated tie to Texas is a one-year clerkship in Houston for a 5th Circuit judge.

The nomination moved fast. CBS, citing Gaiser's Senate questionnaire, laid out the sequence.

Twelve days from first call to formal nomination
  1. Sen. Ted Cruz's staff first contacts Gaiser about the vacancy
  2. Gaiser speaks with Cornyn's office; White House lawyers tell him he is under consideration
  3. Date on his Senate Judiciary questionnaire
  4. Trump announces the nomination on Truth Social
  5. The nomination formally reaches the Senate
  6. Cornyn says in public that Gaiser is not a Texan
  7. Cornyn tells CBS News he will not return a blue slip

Source: CBS News

Cornyn gave CBS three reasons. Gaiser is not from Texas. He has no trial experience, though the job is a trial judgeship. And the White House, in Cornyn's telling, pressed the Senate to act without the vetting a lifetime appointment requires.

A day earlier, at an event hosted by The Atlantic, Cornyn had said the White House did not consult the Senate and that he had offered another candidate. He did not name that person in the remarks CBS quoted.

Gaiser's work at the Justice Department is also contested. CBS reported that he wrote the legal opinion justifying U.S. military strikes on boats suspected of smuggling drugs in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific. In April he concluded that the Presidential Records Act is unconstitutional. In August he concluded that Trump's outside advisers are shielded from later congressional and legal inquiries.

The reasons Cornyn gave were about residency, experience and process. He did not cite those opinions in CBS's account.

Two things are missing from the record. CBS's report includes no on-the-record response from the White House or the Justice Department. It also does not state the position of Ted Cruz$, the other Texas senator, whose blue slip is required too. We found no public statement from Cruz on the nomination in the sources we reviewed. Gaiser had been expected at a Judiciary Committee hearing this week. He was not among the seven judicial nominees scheduled to testify.

What a blue slip is, and why it has survived#

The blue slip is a custom, not a law or a written Senate rule. It works as a gate at the start of the process.

How a district court nominee reaches a Senate vote
  1. Nominationthe president sends a name to the Senate
  2. Blue slipsthe Judiciary Committee asks both home-state senators to approve
  3. Hearingheld only if both senators return a positive slip
  4. Committee votea majority of the panel sends the nominee to the floor
  5. Confirmationa simple majority of the full Senate

Source: CBS News

Under the practice of the current chairman, Sen. Chuck Grassley$ of Iowa, a district court nominee who lacks either slip stops at the second step. Appeals court nominees skip it.

Trump has tried to end the custom since July 2025. That month he called on Grassley by name to drop it, Fox News reported. His complaint then was about Democrats. Sen. Chuck Schumer$ of New York had refused to return slips for Trump's choices for U.S. attorney in Manhattan and Brooklyn, The Hill reported.

Grassley refused. His argument was about arithmetic as much as tradition. A nominee without a blue slip does not have the votes to clear the committee or the Senate floor, he wrote on X, according to ABC News. On the Senate floor he added a second point. Voters outside Washington may not know what a blue slip is, he said, but it shapes which judges and prosecutors serve their communities. Republican Sens. Thom Tillis$ of North Carolina and John Kennedy$ of Louisiana backed him in public.

Supporters of the custom also point to how it worked in Trump's first term. Democrats returned more than 130 blue slips then and helped confirm 84 district judges in states with at least one Democratic senator, HuffPost reported. The same report noted that the custom has blocked picks by presidents of both parties.

Critics, led by the president, answer that the custom hands one senator a veto the Constitution does not mention. The Constitution gives the appointment power to the president, with the advice and consent of the Senate as a whole. Trump has described the practice as outdated and as a tool for the minority party to stall an elected president's choices. He has said Grassley could end it on his own authority as chairman.

That last claim is accurate as a description of the mechanics. The blue slip is a committee practice, and past chairmen of both parties have changed how strictly they applied it. Whether a chairman should do so is the disputed part.

The blue slip under Trump
  1. Republicans stop honoring blue slips for appeals court nominees
  2. Trump calls on Grassley to end the custom for district judges and U.S. attorneys
  3. A Republican senator uses the custom to block a Trump district court nominee

Source: Politico, Fox News, CBS News

This week's case tests both arguments. The fight in 2025 was framed as Republicans against Democrats. Cornyn's move shows the custom also gives a senator leverage over a president of the same party. That is the use its defenders describe when they say it forces the White House to consult. It is also the outcome its critics warned about: a nominee stopped without a hearing or a vote.

The January 3 deadline#

Time is the other constraint. The new Congress begins on January 3, and Democrats are poised to hold 56 Senate seats, CBS reported. We covered how they got there in our election-night story on the six Senate seats Democrats flipped.

After that date, the blue slip will matter less for Trump's nominees than the majority itself. A Democratic chairman will decide which nominees get hearings, and a Democratic leader will decide which get floor votes. CBS reported that few, if any, of the president's pending appeals and district court picks are expected to be confirmed.

Judges are also competing for floor time. The Senate has spent much of November on a permitting bill that the House has not agreed to. A stopgap spending law expires December 11, a deadline we explained in our story on Israel aid and the lame-duck calendar. Republican senators have also been arguing among themselves about their own leadership and direction since the midterms.

Cornyn will not be there when the Dallas seat is next considered. He leaves the Senate in January. Attorney General Ken Paxton won the Republican nomination for his seat, and our coverage of the Texas Senate race followed Paxton's contest with Democrat James Talarico. Whoever fills the vacancy on the Dallas court will need blue slips from Cruz and from Cornyn's successor, unless the Senate changes its practice.

What to watch#

Four things will show where this goes:

  • Whether the White House withdraws Gaiser's nomination, leaves it pending, or names the alternative Cornyn says he offered.
  • Whether Cruz says in public how he would have handled his own blue slip.
  • Whether Trump renews his demand that Grassley drop the custom in the weeks Republicans still control the committee.
  • How many district court nominees who do have both blue slips get floor votes before the Senate adjourns for the year.

The Senate's own records will answer the last question. Its daily floor log lists every confirmation vote and its tally.

Differing perspectives

Should a home-state senator be able to stop a district court nominee such as Elliot Gaiser by withholding a blue slip?

Each position is summarized as its supporters make it, with equal weight and in alphabetical order. A summary is not an endorsement; the evidence for each is weighed in the story above.

  • End the blue slip for district courts

    Who holds it: President Donald Trump and allies who back his nominees

    Trump argues that the blue slip is an old custom, not a law, and that it lets a single senator veto a choice the Constitution gives to the president and the full Senate. He says it has kept qualified judges and U.S. attorneys from being confirmed, and that the Judiciary chairman could end it at once. In this view voters elected a president to fill these seats.

    In their words: Fox News, quoting President Trump's Truth Social post ↗

  • Honor the blue slip and drop this nomination

    Who holds it: Sen. John Cornyn of Texas

    Cornyn argues that a federal trial judge should come from the state where the court sits and should have tried cases. He says Gaiser is an Ohioan without trial experience, and that the White House moved the nomination in days without consulting the Senate. In his view a lifetime appointment needs real vetting, and a home-state senator who knows the local bar is the right person to insist on it.

    In their words: CBS News interview with Sen. John Cornyn ↗

  • Keep the blue slip as a practical test of support

    Who holds it: Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley and Republican Sens. Thom Tillis and John Kennedy

    Grassley argues that the custom protects nominees as much as senators. He says a nominee who lacks a blue slip does not have the votes to clear the committee or the floor, so honoring the slips sets a president's picks up to succeed. Supporters point to district judges and U.S. attorneys confirmed with slips from senators of the other party, and say the custom forces consultation.

    In their words: ABC News, quoting Sen. Chuck Grassley's post on X ↗

Cite this article

567 Politics staff. “Trump got two appeals judges through the Senate this week. A Republican just sank his Texas pick.” 567politics. Published 2026-11-20. https://567politics.com/news/cornyn-blue-slip-gaiser-texas-judge-senate-confirms-domenico-st-john-lame-duck-november-2026

Wikipedia citation
{{cite news |title=Trump got two appeals judges through the Senate this week. A Republican just sank his Texas pick |url=https://567politics.com/news/cornyn-blue-slip-gaiser-texas-judge-senate-confirms-domenico-st-john-lame-duck-november-2026 |work=567politics |author=567 Politics staff |date=2026-11-20 |language=en}}
CSL-JSON for reference managers
{
  "id": "https://567politics.com/news/cornyn-blue-slip-gaiser-texas-judge-senate-confirms-domenico-st-john-lame-duck-november-2026",
  "type": "article-newspaper",
  "title": "Trump got two appeals judges through the Senate this week. A Republican just sank his Texas pick",
  "URL": "https://567politics.com/news/cornyn-blue-slip-gaiser-texas-judge-senate-confirms-domenico-st-john-lame-duck-november-2026",
  "container-title": "567politics",
  "language": "en",
  "author": [
    {
      "literal": "567 Politics staff"
    }
  ],
  "issued": {
    "date-parts": [
      [
        2026,
        11,
        20
      ]
    ]
  }
}

Citations identify this article and its publication date. Assess the reporting and its linked sources before using it as evidence.

Read this article as Markdown or JSON. Cite the original page and retain its sources, dates and qualifications.

Embed this article summary

Paste this HTML into your page. The summary stays linked to the full story and updates with it. No account required.

<iframe src="https://567politics.com/embed/news/cornyn-blue-slip-gaiser-texas-judge-senate-confirms-domenico-st-john-lame-duck-november-2026?theme=auto" title="Trump got two appeals judges through the Senate this week. A Republican just sank his Texas pick by 567politics" width="100%" height="440" style="border:0;max-width:100%" loading="lazy"></iframe>
<p style="font-size:14px">Trump got two appeals judges through the Senate this week. A Republican just sank his Texas pick by <a href="https://567politics.com/news/cornyn-blue-slip-gaiser-texas-judge-senate-confirms-domenico-st-john-lame-duck-november-2026" rel="nofollow">567politics</a></p>
<script async src="https://567politics.com/embed.js"></script>
All 567politics news →